Clan Leader Ability to Ban Member From Clan War

[Alejosoft]

As a clan leader I would like to be able to "ban" or prevent a member from being eligible for the next Clan War search. Many times I have seen the case where some of my clanmates don't want to be eligible for war because they won't be active in the game for the next couple of days for personal reasons. So the only option I have is to kick them out of the clan and hope that they will come back. As a leader I don't want to be kicking people out of my clan, it's kinda awkward, and some members could feel confused if they don't know why I'm doing it. So adding this ability will allow me to control who can go to war without kicking people out. I'm thinking that this could be a flag on the member that once the next clan war search happens gets reset automatically. So that this member will be eligible on the subsequent clan war search.

[ItsED]

That's a good idea -- or have members opt out of the war with permission of the leader/co-leadership

[Denrochee]

What if the people the leader "bans" do want to war? They cannot due to the leader having absolute power. I have been kicked and subsequently reinvited from multiple wars due to probable inactivity during war time, heroes upgrading, or any number of reasons and I have no problem coming back. If they are so inactive that they cannot talk to the leader and opt out (by leaving and rejoining) then why do you want them in your clan anyway?

The only good outcome I see in this is leaders abusing the absolute power over their war. If you don't want them to be part of the clan kick them, if they can't war for personal reasons they should have no problem leaving and rejoining.

[THEBIGCLASH3R]

Good idea. I actually have this problem right now, I told my leader to kick me and re-invite me when they have found a clan war opponent because I won't be able to participate in our clan war this weekend.

[Alejosoft]

What if the people the leader "bans" do want to war? They cannot due to the leader having absolute power. I have been kicked and subsequently reinvited from multiple wars due to probable inactivity during war time, heroes upgrading, or any number of reasons and I have no problem coming back. If they are so inactive that they cannot talk to the leader and opt out (by leaving and rejoining) then why do you want them in your clan anyway?

The only good outcome I see in this is leaders abusing the absolute power over their war. If you don't want them to be part of the clan kick them, if they can't war for personal reasons they should have no problem leaving and rejoining.

I agree with the risk of this being abused by an evil leader, but also members have the right to leave if the leader is abusing power. Which then probably will encourage other members to leave the clan if they don't agree with their leader's decisions. So member also have a powerful tool in their hands "leave". As a good leader I don't want my members to feel abused and even worse leave the clan because they think I'm being unfair.

[flav86]

totally agree.







C.o.C. Reloaded unbeaten Clan, visited us!

[Alejosoft]

Please guys let's support this idea. We need to make Supercell add this ASAP!

[Sokitani]

As a clan leader I would like to be able to "ban" or prevent a member from being eligible for the next Clan War search. Many times I have seen the case where some of my clanmates don't want to be eligible for war because they won't be active in the game for the next couple of days for personal reasons. So the only option I have is to kick them out of the clan and hope that they will come back. As a leader I don't want to be kicking people out of my clan, it's kinda awkward, and some members could feel confused if they don't know why I'm doing it. So adding this ability will allow me to control who can go to war without kicking people out. I'm thinking that this could be a flag on the member that once the next clan war search happens gets reset automatically. So that this member will be eligible on the subsequent clan war search.

I like the everyone deciding for themselves if they go to war idea more because this could cause people getting upset.

[DaveKT]

I submitted a similar request below. This would increase war activity by allowing clans to have many more wars since in every clan there are members that would like to have a higher frequency of wars. In essence, you could have continuous wars where the members can each opt-in as many wars as they would like. The leaders should have control of opting-in/out any non-leader member. It would greatly increase the efficiency of people jumping in and out between wars which means more war activity for the clans. It's safe to assume that the more game activity, the better for SuperCell.

The power abuse argument makes no sense since power abuse can occur today. Power abuse polices itself, those leaders end up with a clan without members.

-----------------------------------------------------------

Allow Clan Members to Opt-In or Opt-Out for Clan Wars

By allowing clan members to opt-in or opt-out for each war would prevent the churn of clan members having to leave when he/she is unable to participate in a war. Also, it would allow clan members seeking different war frequencies to stay in the same clan.

A time delay (configurable would be ideal) could be implemented after the Start War! button is selected. The default would be that all members are opt-out and each member would need to opt-in during that time window. Once the pre-war search time has expired, a clan search would resume like normal and all members who have opt-in would be included in the war unless they're the lower trophy members outside of the 5 member increments (just like the way it works today).

[Pookafish4]

Please guys let's support this idea. We need to make Supercell add this ASAP!

Please don't bump your thread!

I don't think leaders should choose who is in the war, the members should pick if they want to be in the war or not.