Clan membership - how long are you / your mates in the clan?

[RedB]

How about we could finally see, how long we and our mates are in the clan? This would allow f.i. (co-)leaders to decide about promotions or time-based-stuff in a clan...
Worth considering?

[JeremiahF]

Not bad , Maybe it will be added in the near future

[Azhairin91]

How about we could finally see, how long we and our mates are in the clan? This would allow f.i. (co-)leaders to decide about promotions or time-based-stuff in a clan...
Worth considering?

Can upgrade about score clan win,lose&draw and point clan .and have a clan ranking?

[iceageg]

I don't see a problem with it but I also don't see much value. Our clan has many members who have been 100% loyal for 6+ months but they regularly switch visit with other friends for a few hours, myself included and I am the founder/leader of the clan. Any clan with a feeder/sister clan would have very inaccurate data as would many war clans who boot/drop before starting the next war.

Again, I don't see any problem with this information being public but I don't think it the information will be accurate enough to be useful.

[RedB]

I don't see a problem with it but I also don't see much value. Our clan has many members who have been 100% loyal for 6+ months but they regularly switch visit with other friends for a few hours, myself included and I am the founder/leader of the clan. Any clan with a feeder/sister clan would have very inaccurate data as would many war clans who boot/drop before starting the next war.

Again, I don't see any problem with this information being public but I don't think it the information will be accurate enough to be useful.

Think of all new / young clans, where they have a rule f.i. "we promote to elder when you stay a month with good donations or 2 months with standard ones". This of course would not change the game, but I think it would be a useful feedback for the leaders. There are clans with "core"-members, lets say 30 of them are 100% loyal, but 20 people would come&go if they just simply do not like it in some clan...
And this info could be for members-eyes-only.

[iceageg]

Think of all new / young clans, where they have a rule f.i. "we promote to elder when you stay a month with good donations or 2 months with standard ones". This of course would not change the game, but I think it would be a useful feedback for the leaders. There are clans with "core"-members, lets say 30 of them are 100% loyal, but 20 people would come&go if they just simply do not like it in some clan...
And this info could be for members-eyes-only.

Some of my 100% loyal members (myself included) move around the most. It isn't a matter of loyalty. Just a byproduct of the limited communication tools available in the game. If they (like me) have friends in a different clan it reflects positively on their loyalty that they come back. Again, nothing wrong with the idea but I don't believe the data will be reliable.