The Whole troop donation issue solved!!!

[ImLaird]

As plain and easy as it is everyone has went completely around the solution.
1. New barricks just like old ones but are donate only barricks. Starting troop donation? The first one that is costly and timely. WIZARD and Balloon. Of course reg donations of archers and low cost go through normal request. Even lv7 to a lv 1 troop gamer. Level upgrades are dependent on what troops you already have upgraded. Just another barrick is all it is.. but two..one for normal one for dark.
2.. A camp for SELLING troops that's visible to clanmates to see what you have ...for sale..!!
Eg. So someone of low level says I need a lv4 drag. Ok well limited still to your reg. Castle, the teammate can send other a troop request.
3. Request for troops from higher level people with max or just higher troops can be made. If someone has those troops built for donating. In donate only camps. Since the minus out feature is available .it will apply to donate barricks and camp(s)
4. Camp sizes are upgradeable as normal camps so nothing really changes except donaters have a way to build and store troops they know the clan will ask for and have them training seperate from their own. Ending wait on your battle while you donate to someone ,(because that's how you roll). And giving the clan an option in wars to pull off a mass attack at begining , should they want to. Not any diff than hitting one at a time. Except it would be neat to do.
5. The main thing about this thread: ALL Donation troops are SOLD To the clanmates. And the elixer will be traded out from storage to storage automatically just as any elix is added to your storage. The press of the buy troop button will be available for someone. And their castle dependent on size will grey out troops they can't buy and fit in their castle.
So if your willing to donate..guess what..it doenst cost you anything but prebuild elix and new buildings to add to your village. All the same features of regular barrios and dark barrios with the perk of storing seperately in another camp. Where you have your own troop store for purchasing troops at anytime except for war castles where as a clan you fill normally as you may or may not.
This solves several issues...and gives more people the willingness to build higher cost troops for donations because..
A. Your not out elix for building the troops
B. Your not out time to build troops for others while your busy.
C. If you need a little more elix and have donation troops left..someone can purchase those and you get your elix back to your storage.
D. New people join clan and ask for best troops in the request. You do not have to stop and ask are you staying or ask anything. They send troop request to the one they find has the troop made they need or ask for troop to be built(place) an order. Ok here's a key part of that...once the request or order is made. The elix is exchanged automatic..at that point. So you don't build something on the fly thinking you get elix back once troop is made..and they leave. Sticking you with a troop. And less elix..even tho eventually it can or will be bought. So they can leave..go back to their clan or where ever...and when troop fjnishes, it flys or walks to them like normal if they were in your clan still. If this is technically possible. This feature would protect the donater and reciever in case kicked from clan or disconnection from dying battery or any reason you'd be disconnected. Selling of troops is a good way to alliviate asking for something they can't afford or make, and payback the donater for elix out for building troops. Which I would keep a camp full of em so the clan economy would boost internally by ones with too much elix and all builders busy can buy from clan mates or make an order to be made, therefore elixer can be 'donated' as so many in my clan say. " I wish I could donate you some elix" after being told ..I need elix. Well ...while you have elix ..fill that donation camp and 'hide' elix or store it in built troops and qued. So simple is this I wouldn't understand why everyone wouldn't want this feature in the game. Solving several problems at one time. And more buildings to buy and upgrade benefits your defence.your clans economy and Supercells gem sales.

[TheKingSam]

I stopped reading after you put "level 5 dragons"

[ImLaird]

My post is a solution, which is not the problem. Any other typos like #5 talks about Selling your troops for internal clan economy boost. Instead of just donating them. Thanks for misreading tho. One bad post won't kill the thread. Because Selling your bigger troops is the most important part as you pointed out. If they did come up with lv 5 drags then I would buy one for backup!!! Lol..

[Sirix]

I stopped at 'selling troops' not to be mean but because the idea of allowing players to transfer resources from one player to another is ruled out. This makes it no longer like donations too

[sirhybrid]

There are so many spelling mistakes, and the grammar isn't good. .. And it isn't explained well either. Please clarify. .. everything.

[ColonelAwesome]

As plain and easy as it is everyone has went completely around the solution.
1. New barricks just like old ones but are donate only barricks. Starting troop donation? The first one that is costly and timely. WIZARD and Balloon. Of course reg donations of archers and low cost go through normal request. Even lv7 to a lv 1 troop gamer. Level upgrades are dependent on what troops you already have upgraded. Just another barrick is all it is.. but two..one for normal one for dark.
2.. A camp for SELLING troops that's visible to clanmates to see what you have ...for sale..!!
Eg. So someone of low level says I need a lv4 drag. Ok well limited still to your reg. Castle, the teammate can send other a troop request.
3. Request for troops from higher level people with max or just higher troops can be made. If someone has those troops built for donating. In donate only camps. Since the minus out feature is available .it will apply to donate barricks and camp(s)
4. Camp sizes are upgradeable as normal camps so nothing really changes except donaters have a way to build and store troops they know the clan will ask for and have them training seperate from their own. Ending wait on your battle while you donate to someone ,(because that's how you roll). And giving the clan an option in wars to pull off a mass attack at begining , should they want to. Not any diff than hitting one at a time. Except it would be neat to do.
5. The main thing about this thread: ALL Donation troops are SOLD To the clanmates. And the elixer will be traded out from storage to storage automatically just as any elix is added to your storage. The press of the buy troop button will be available for someone. And their castle dependent on size will grey out troops they can't buy and fit in their castle.
So if your willing to donate..guess what..it doenst cost you anything but prebuild elix and new buildings to add to your village. All the same features of regular barrios and dark barrios with the perk of storing seperately in another camp. Where you have your own troop store for purchasing troops at anytime except for war castles where as a clan you fill normally as you may or may not.
This solves several issues...and gives more people the willingness to build higher cost troops for donations because..
A. Your not out elix for building the troops
B. Your not out time to build troops for others while your busy.
C. If you need a little more elix and have donation troops left..someone can purchase those and you get your elix back to your storage.
D. New people join clan and ask for best troops in the request. You do not have to stop and ask are you staying or ask anything. They send troop request to the one they find has the troop made they need or ask for troop to be built(place) an order. Ok here's a key part of that...once the request or order is made. The elix is exchanged automatic..at that point. So you don't build something on the fly thinking you get elix back once troop is made..and they leave. Sticking you with a troop. And less elix..even tho eventually it can or will be bought. So they can leave..go back to their clan or where ever...and when troop fjnishes, it flys or walks to them like normal if they were in your clan still. If this is technically possible. This feature would protect the donater and reciever in case kicked from clan or disconnection from dying battery or any reason you'd be disconnected. Selling of troops is a good way to alliviate asking for something they can't afford or make, and payback the donater for elix out for building troops. Which I would keep a camp full of em so the clan economy would boost internally by ones with too much elix and all builders busy can buy from clan mates or make an order to be made, therefore elixer can be 'donated' as so many in my clan say. " I wish I could donate you some elix" after being told ..I need elix. Well ...while you have elix ..fill that donation camp and 'hide' elix or store it in built troops and qued. So simple is this I wouldn't understand why everyone wouldn't want this feature in the game. Solving several problems at one time. And more buildings to buy and upgrade benefits your defence.your clans economy and Supercells gem sales.

There were too many words to read them all. Also, your grammar was bad, so its hard to follow

[PhilISuppose]

wish I could donate you some elix" after being told ..I need elix. Well ...while you have elix ..fill that donation camp and 'hide' elix or store it in built troops and qued. So simple is this I wouldn't understand why everyone wouldn't want this feature in the game. Solving several problems at one time. And more buildings to buy and upgrade benefits your defence.your clans economy and Supercells gem sales.

The fact that you actually suggest that hiding elixir away is a good thing simply boggles my mind.
If everyone could do this there'll be even less elixir available to raid.

-1 terrible idea.

[ImLaird]

The fact that you actually suggest that hiding elixir away is a good thing simply boggles my mind.
If everyone could do this there'll be even less elixir available to raid.

-1 terrible idea.

Where do i say its a good thing?
To clarify what you interpret me to say, I added these words because of the fact that everyone know s you can do this. If you want me to ...well I will say its better than the normal way that everyone does hide elix, because the elix in these troops is someone else's, goes back into your storage when request is made. Its the truth so I put it out there, just didn't clarify it will return to storage and back up for grabs, So you have your own temporary savings account. Since there is no loot problem, this feature to further yourself in the game, but also help others in the clan is a great idea!! If everyone can create a good economy inside their own clan with troop building for one another , we can end struggles of getting some to donate and creating a way to encourage that by filling a camp, by itself, with barricks separate from regular ones, to make higher cost and time consuming troops available to the clan. NoT trading resources!!! Allowing another player to use his elix to have you build him troops, without bothering your gameplay but for a second creates harmony and keeps peace.

Just for you..the one boggled mind guy ...I believe this game is called Clash of Clans...but don't they have wars now? Isn't ..." all is fair in love and war " a pretty good term to use when you are doing it to help and better your clan. Oh by the way I've added a new guy to your clan, he will spy for the other team, whomever it may be. So wrap your mind around that one, is that fair? Helping your clan is a GOOD thing. Because eventually they will need elix or troops and guess what. One of you will be able to help the other. Thanks for sharing and allowing me to explain more! Clash on!!

Sorry to the grammer students, the typos are typos but come and go so the typos really are but are not no mo. Lawl..(lol)

THANKS FOR READING AND VOTING ON JUST WHAT THE CONTENT OF THE POLL IS ABOUT !!! NOTT HOW ITS WROTE OR LENGTH OF .. TOO LONG ? JUST read first paragraph and fifth..the rest is what SC requires for an idea. Thanks again for your vote in the poll . Heck don't even read it just vote yea.. sounds great to me !! We should do this!! Any positive review is fine. Lawl..

[Rolfy]

Well LOL...reading that as left me bonkers ha. I have no idea there was a problem with troop donations. Would have been nice to have put down what the problem was/is.

Anyways, TBH i dont really like your ideas/suggestions. Why would I want to sell my troops to clan mates? Youre suppose to help each other, an you shouldnt put a price on that!

HMM..what else was there?? Well im pretty sure there wasnt much I liked there..maybe if you could explain with less words an more paragraphs mate, like in layman terms or something?

Sorry I couldnt vote, none of the options were anything what I was lookin for

[lanesteele240]

You either give or you dont. I see no issue