[PETITION] Make Heroes Usable in Clan Wars... While Upgrading.

[DraakarDraekonis]

/Not Signed

...I can think of a few reasons why Supercell might have not implemented this yet. At a basic level, you only have to take a hero down for long enough to miss an entire war if the hero you are upgrading is higher than level 4.

If that hero is the queen, you are -by necessity- a th9 player.


1) Being "pulled" out of a war (you don't really have to pull out of war with an upgrading hero; your hero still defends. You just have to have good clan management for target selection) makes it so that it takes longer for you to hoard dark elixir for your next hero upgrade....so it extends the grind towards maxing out your heroes.

2) Perhaps the reason they have not enabled everyone to war with heroes even while upgrading is specifically to temporarily pull the attacking power of high level players down to provide some fluidity to the overall game environment.

3) Perhaps another reason they have not enabled this is to require enhanced cooperation between clan leadership members. Especially with clans that have more members than they war with, it also encourages clans to put bench players into their wars while top players in a clan sit themselves out (again, there's no requirement that you pull yourself out of a war while upgrading a hero)

[adrock]

/signed
This will never happen simply and only because its a big source of SC gem purchases.

When you upgrade your bins or cc you can still use them, just not at the new level until the upgrade completes. The ONLY reason that SC doesn't do this with royals or towers is because they get paid from frustrated players who can't wait.

If they got rid of all timers then it would have to be a pay-to-play subscription service. Maybe they should allow people to switch their accounts over to subscription system without build timers? Its an idea, not sure it would work.

[AbdeAli123]

Signed i do agree

[J1M808]

/signed


10 chars

[Titan501]

/sign

[Draco10877]

/signed

It is a pain to wait for multiple days for the hero to finish up. Having them upgrade in lab instead like the other troops seems like a better option.

[Clan64]

Happy to sign

[Clan64]

/Not Signed

...I can think of a few reasons why Supercell might have not implemented this yet. At a basic level, you only have to take a hero down for long enough to miss an entire war if the hero you are upgrading is higher than level 4.

If that hero is the queen, you are -by necessity- a th9 player.


1) Being "pulled" out of a war (you don't really have to pull out of war with an upgrading hero; your hero still defends. You just have to have good clan management for target selection) makes it so that it takes longer for you to hoard dark elixir for your next hero upgrade....so it extends the grind towards maxing out your heroes.

2) Perhaps the reason they have not enabled everyone to war with heroes even while upgrading is specifically to temporarily pull the attacking power of high level players down to provide some fluidity to the overall game environment.

3) Perhaps another reason they have not enabled this is to require enhanced cooperation between clan leadership members. Especially with clans that have more members than they war with, it also encourages clans to put bench players into their wars while top players in a clan sit themselves out (again, there's no requirement that you pull yourself out of a war while upgrading a hero)

What total rubbish. An upgrade takes 7 days, that's at least 3 wars if you are doing wars back to back.
If you are at the top or near top of your war map it is essential that you have both heros or you are severely disadvantaged in war.
Any sensible player will not be in war without heroes unless they are low in the war map where it matters less. So your number 2) argument does not hold water.
There might not be a requirement to pull yourself out of war, but if you want to win, you go into war with the best opportunity to win and not deliberately out yourself at a disadvantage.
Not sure why you have put forward these arguments. But still it adds to the count of replies. And I'm sure by now SC are not looking at the replies here any longer.

Cheers 👍

[jeprice]

This is a good idea

/signed

[paulting]

haha totally /signed