[PETITION] Make Heroes Usable in Clan Wars... While Upgrading.

[Seuss145]

Spells don't work while the spell factory is upgrading is what I said. Spells work just fine if the spell itself is upgrading. And look at an upgrading BK. is there any old sword there? And by making him a new sword, that doesn't necessarily mean from scratch. That builder could easily be re-melting down the old sword and adding new material, because if you look at the BKs info, his sword is broken.

You said you still have the recipe to make spells meaning you can still make spells, so your still contradicting. You just cleared it up about the BK but it was contradicting before.

[ColonelAwesome]

You can still get attacked in those 3 mins, that's how the shield system works.
In addition, I was saying how shields don't break when attacking in war as appossed to attacking in raids. That still doesn't counter my supporting detail to the main arguement, mainly says some sense in what it is, it's a game, not everything is sensible.

actually it does counter your argument. Re-read my post and don't take it so literally.

[ColonelAwesome]

You said you still have the recipe to make spells meaning you can still make spells, so your still contradicting. You just cleared it up about the BK but it was contradicting before.

[Seuss145]

That still doesn't help your case, just bumps this thread

[ColonelAwesome]

You said you still have the recipe to make spells meaning you can still make spells, so your still contradicting. You just cleared it up about the BK but it was contradicting before.

I have decided that you are no longer arguing because you think you are right. You are arguing for the sake of arguing.
Brb. I have to go eat dinner. This quarrel shall resume in half an hour lol

[Seuss145]

I have decided that you are no longer arguing because you think you are right. You are arguing for the sake of arguing.
Brb. I have to go eat dinner. This quarrel shall resume in half an hour lol

Just trying to prove my point, im just countering your counters, ok be back in half an hour

[ColonelAwesome]

You raid with troops that are ready to battle. You cant raid on multiplayer with heroes upgrading. They made clan wars attacking like multiplayer on purpose. If they wanted you to use heroes in war while upgrading, they would have added it by now.

I dont see how this many people can agree with this. There is no reason that your barb king and archer queen SHOULD be able to be used in war attacks. A war attack is still a regular attack, just on an odd landscape. If your BK and AQ are available to attack for war when they are upgrading, they would have to be available for regular attacks. This thread makes no sense

I don't know.

I do believe the heroes are defending warbases even while upgrading but indeed thet can't be used in attacks.
So, comparing with other defenses, the hero does what all other defenses do, be fully operational on the previous level.
On offense it does behave like spells rather than troops. If you upgrade the spell facture during war you can't create spells similar to not being able to use the king while it is upgrading.

think of the posts above, all from October of last year. Its annoying that this thread has come back to life. ILike2Clash, RockTheRock, and myself have already stated numerous reasons as to why this shouldn't be implemented. However, most people just read the original post, reply to it, and forget about the thread.

[ColonelAwesome]

That still doesn't help your case, just bumps this thread

Also, as I have said before, I stated that new spells can be created while they are upgrading. New spells Cannot be upgrading while the spell factory is upgrading. Troops can be made while they are upgrading, but not while the building they are made in is upgrading. Barb King cannot attack or defend while upgrading just like how a defense doesn't function while upgrading. He cannot attack while upgrading just like how spells cannot be made while factory is upgrading and troops cannot be made while barracks is upgrading.

[Seuss145]

Also, as I have said before, I stated that new spells can be created while they are upgrading. New spells Cannot be upgrading while the spell factory is upgrading. Troops can be made while they are upgrading, but not while the building they are made in is upgrading. Barb King cannot attack or defend while upgrading just like how a defense doesn't function while upgrading. He cannot attack while upgrading just like how spells cannot be made while factory is upgrading and troops cannot be made while barracks is upgrading.

However army camps can be used while upgrading and cc troops can be requested while the cc is upgrading,

P. S. Sorry for the late reply, got wrapped up in a bit of homework

[Seuss145]

think of the posts above, all from October of last year. Its annoying that this thread has come back to life. ILike2Clash, RockTheRock, and myself have already stated numerous reasons as to why this shouldn't be implemented. However, most people just read the original post, reply to it, and forget about the thread.

To counter, a war attack is different from a regular raid. Your shield does not break as it is a war attack rather than a multiplayer battle, so therefore war attacks are not the same as multiplayer attacks and different concepts can be used as long as it is not too drastic of a change, heroes usable in wars while upgradinf is not too drastic of a change though