It uses examples as why implementing this wouldn't make sense, which is pretty much why it shouldn't be implemented.Originally Posted by Seuss145
It uses examples as why implementing this wouldn't make sense, which is pretty much why it shouldn't be implemented.
Clash of Clans: stopped at TH 9, Level 99
My Thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/417960-New-dark-elixir-troops-and-Pure-Elixir-idea
I would rather have the bk/aq sit out than have them part of the spell factory if those were the only two options.
I said a counter to those quotes already, but here it is again. It would still make sense to use heroes in war. How come your shield doesnt break when you use a war attack? Because it's war, not normal raiding. So just like that, an upgrading hero being used in wars can work out. A hero popping into your inventory when using a war attack would not be senseless at all.
Last edited by Seuss145; March 22nd, 2015 at 10:04 PM.
They would also have to add a health bar above an upgrading hero (Which would look rather stupid) and the hero could not just randomly pop up in your inventory. When upgrading a spell factory, you cant make more spells. This is no different
Clash of Clans: stopped at TH 9, Level 99
My Thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/417960-New-dark-elixir-troops-and-Pure-Elixir-idea
Would it look stupid? The look of the hero doesn't compare to the uses, you can say lvl 1 drakes look stupid but ppl still use them.
I know about the spell factory, but I countered with the clan castle and the shield system, if you can't counter those 2, then your arguements are not strong enough to make someone believe it is not worth implementing
Last edited by Seuss145; March 22nd, 2015 at 10:18 PM.
Your war base is for full defensive use entirely, and nothing else. your regular base is for offense and defense. Nothing on your regular base works while being upgraded except troops, spells, and your clan castle (And resource storages obviously). These all make sense: If the alchemists are figuring out how to make your troops stronger, they aren't building newer versions of troops, so your troops can still be used. When they are making a new recipe for a spell to make it stronger, you still have the old recipe to make spells with. Whilst upgrading the clan castle, you can still walk around in buildings that are being renovated right? However, if a builder is making a new sword for you while you sleep, you cant go out and attack somebody with a sword for two reasons. 1: You are asleep. 2: You have no sword.
Clash of Clans: stopped at TH 9, Level 99
My Thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/417960-New-dark-elixir-troops-and-Pure-Elixir-idea
This isn't really contributing to the idea and doesn't really counter my posts. Also, spells don't work while being upgraded, you said it yourself earlier and now you say otherwise. Contradicting. Also you said NEW sword, so there is the old sword, right?
And the shield system? You aren't attacking a random player's base. Think of the normal attack system as random squabbles over tribes. And clan wars are big wars. If your enemies are unable to see your base, then leaving for three minutes to help a cause wont alert them. If you savagely attack somebody's base while you are invisible, the other "tribes" nearby will notice the sudden attack and they will respond with another attack. If your base is destroyed, your "shield" is the other tribes seeing your village as destroyed and seeing that you learned a lesson from it.
Last edited by ColonelAwesome; March 22nd, 2015 at 10:35 PM.
Clash of Clans: stopped at TH 9, Level 99
My Thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/417960-New-dark-elixir-troops-and-Pure-Elixir-idea
Spells don't work while the spell factory is upgrading is what I said. Spells work just fine if the spell itself is upgrading. And look at an upgrading BK. is there any old sword there? And by making him a new sword, that doesn't necessarily mean from scratch. That builder could easily be re-melting down the old sword and adding new material, because if you look at the BKs info, his sword is broken.
Clash of Clans: stopped at TH 9, Level 99
My Thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/417960-New-dark-elixir-troops-and-Pure-Elixir-idea
You can still get attacked in those 3 mins, that's how the shield system works.
In addition, I was saying how shields don't break when attacking in war as appossed to attacking in raids. That still doesn't counter my supporting detail to the main arguement, mainly says some sense in what it is, it's a game, not everything is sensible.
