Clan War - Solve Matchmaking by governing attacks from higher THs

[T1Girr]

Root Problem:

• The clan who is offensively and defensively stronger is currently able to bully lower Town Halls for more 3-stars than the weaker clan is capable of getting regardless of skill.

Given:

• The clan who has more attackers with greater skill should always be the clan that wins, not the one that can bully the weaker guy using higher level troops/heroes, and stronger defenses.

Disclaimer:

• I am well aware that an elite clan can overcome mismatches most of the time

Solution?

• When a higher lvl Town Hall attacks a lower level, their troops are reverted back to max for the TH they are attacking. A TH10 can only bring 220 troops, 4 spells, and lvl 30 heroes when attacking a TH9 in clan war. They cannot bring freeze spells, and when they deploy their troops, they are lvl 5 wizards, lvl 4 golems, lvl 3 PEKKA, etc. (The difference in troop cost could be refunded or calculated as a penalty)

Anyone who has a problem with this solution would be admitting their lack of skill. I believe Clan Wars are intended to be balanced skill competitions, not bullying massacres. Furthermore, this would not even make things completely even as the stronger clan would still have a defensive advantage. However, this would at least make match-ups more skill-oriented and give everyone a fighting chance to prove themselves as the better clan.

Thanks for reading, and I value your input.

T1Girr

[dahimi]

What a horrible idea. So basically you seek to remove any advantage one might have from leveling their base.

The match making system attempts to match you up equally. Sometimes it doesn't. Sometimes your clan is stronger. Sometimes the other clan is stronger. It's not a big deal.

[webbie]

I think this is a great idea. While we're at it how about lower th levels get their units buffed up to the maximum for the townhall they are attacking. As a townhall 8 I would love to attack a th10 with 240 slots max level golems, wizards and pekkas as well as lvl 40 heroes and freeze spells.

[wsuh88]

Oh gawd dafuqdidijustread?

Only conclusion i can come up with is
1. OP is a noob
2. OP is calling others (who are higher TH than him) noobs

Some one pls remove this useless suggestion

[Jayarikahs]

Why not just give every one in the war a completely maxed TH 10? They can still layout their war base during prep day, train units (at no cost to them with 0 train time), and this way every one in the war will be considered "even" or "balanced". It will solely rely on the attacker's ability and judgement of how they want to perform their attack.

[wsuh88]

Why not just give every one in the war a completely maxed TH 10? They can still layout their war base during prep day, train units (at no cost to them with 0 train time), and this way every one in the war will be considered "even" or "balanced". It will solely rely on the attacker's ability and judgement of how they want to perform their attack.

Cant really tell if this is a troll post or legitimate suggestion. But at least it sounds far more sensible than OP's ridiculous suggestion

[Jayarikahs]

Cant really tell if this is a troll post or legitimate suggestion. But at least it sounds far more sensible than OP's ridiculous suggestion

A little bit of both. I know this suggestion would not ever be considered, but I thought it was still better than OP's.

[2SmallButts]

Nothing is perfect in life and so is CoC. You get on with it like you do with the inequalities of life.

[PhilISuppose]

This is lame.

Really really lame.

Matchmaking is perfectly fair (I am not saying it's always even) you'll get matched to as many clans weaker than you as stronger than you.

Why penalise someone who has made the effort to upgrade their troops?

Might as well say that when a TH10 attacks a TH9 that the TH9 base gets to have free infernos.