Loot Changer:Remove shield when TH is destroyed?

[Jacko2130]

First you suggest no shield if TH is destroyed and now you suggest 30 minute shield if TH is destroyed?

So if I go to sleep for 8hrs I have the potential of losing 16 defences?

I dont think you have thought this through and are now adding bad points from CoC clones as solutions to what exactly?

Players being taken out of the que because a th sniper has given them a free shield.just think because im sure youve done it, how many times has someone th sniped u when youve had full storages?

I imagine a lot.40% or whateva it is still stands, if someone has to have a crack at your storages they will more then likely hit that number 99% of the time.

Please dont tell me you havent used a th sniper to protect your full storgaes from being raided.

I can gove you 20 peeps off the top in my clan with full storages and townhalls out.

ps did not check grammer ♥♥♥♥.

[Jacko2130]

Gonna keep adding ideas good and bad to opening post as to why this may or may not be a good idea.just getting a whole lot of hate atm lol.

[VincentVegas]

Players being taken out of the que because a th sniper has given them a free shield.just think because im sure youve done it, how many times has someone th sniped u when youve had full storages?

I imagine a lot.40% or whateva it is still stands, if someone has to have a crack at your storages they will more then likely hit that number 99% of the time.

Please dont tell me you havent used a th sniper to protect your full storgaes from being raided.

I can gove you 20 peeps off the top in my clan with full storages and townhalls out.

ps did not check grammer ♥♥♥♥.

Yes I have had my TH outside and sometimes it get snipes and sometimes I get hit for storages plus my TH. In both situations I get a 12hr shield. This has always been part of the game and an integral way as to how farming works.

The idea that Th sniping is the reason for poor loot is nonsense, we have always had THs outside we havent always had poor loot.

[Jacko2130]

Will add pics too of various people with townhalls out and full storages as an example of the bases that are hiding away from us haha.

[DirtyTrickster]

I think its a great idea.

Less shields = more available loot. It's simple

K.I.S.S.

[VincentVegas]

Will add pics too of various people with townhalls out and full storages as an example of the bases that are hiding away from us haha.

Plz dont bother, it adds nothing.

[Jacko2130]

Yes I have had my TH outside and sometimes it get snipes and sometimes I get hit for storages plus my TH. In both situations I get a 12hr shield. This has always been part of the game and an integral way as to how farming works.

The idea that Th sniping is the reason for poor loot is nonsense, we have always had THs outside we havent always had poor loot.

I dont think i stated that this is the sole reason for poor loot, what i wanted was opinions on why this is a bad/good idea.

Nothing more.You said it yourself youve used exposed townhalls to protect your loot.if your lvl 100+ I imagine you would have been taken out of the search many a time.

Now imagine the amount of times i would have had a chance at cracking your storages had you not been given a free shield from a th sniper.

[Jacko2130]

I think its a great idea.

Less shields = more available loot. It's simple

K.I.S.S.

My exact thoughts, this is going into opening statement.

[Xenomancers]

No its a bad idea.

The perceived issue with loot has never been anything to do with TH outside.

How do you distinguish between a TH that has been destroyed normally and one that was an easy snipe?

Are you seriously trying to say that putting townhall outside and people trophy pushing does not result in less available raid-able loot? I'd say it's pretty ignorant to say it doesn't reduce loot available for raiders.

[Beancounter]

I have always liked the idea of removing the th shield. It is a beyond lame mechanic.

The fact that *losing* is the best defense in the game is stupid. If they did implement then they would need to cut the percentage for a shield lower. Like 30% instead of 40%.