Choosing member to part in clanwars

[sFoster83]

Imagine a clan with 49 people. Yes those 4 don't participate, but what if the leader choses only 10 for war. That's 39 people. A lot more than four. This could lead to bullying which supercell doesn't want. If they are goin to implement some feature like this it will be the members deciding whether they want to participate or not. Not the leader.

You said "But a clan is a team, everybody participates"
This is very cut and dry. It's not true.

Sorry if this is hard to face for you.
FWIW I am all for an opt-out feature.

[Cooper123]

You said "But a clan is a team, everybody participates"
This is very cut and dry. It's not true.

Sorry if this is hard to face for you.
FWIW I am all for an opt-out feature.

Yeah a clan is a team. That's what I'm saying. I'm just showing you how this can be exploited to bully other players. It won't be implemented. Period.

[BlackJesus52]

Imagine a clan with 49 people. Yes those 4 don't participate, but what if the leader choses only 10 for war. That's 39 people. A lot more than four. This could lead to bullying which supercell doesn't want. If they are goin to implement some feature like this it will be the members deciding whether they want to participate or not. Not the leader.

Yeah a clan is a team. That's what I'm saying. I'm just showing you how this can be exploited to bully other players. It won't be implemented. Period.

the point of clan wars is to get loot, so why wouldn't you want to take your best players into war. Also if the feature was put into the game why would you join a higher clan if you know they probably would choose you for war?

[Cooper123]

It's sad how nobody sees my logic. Argue with me all you want but this won't get implemented.

[SABBY1988]

its really good and useful idea

[BlackJesus52]

It's sad how nobody sees my logic. Argue with me all you want but this won't get implemented.

I think it has a good chance to get put in the game. If you have a 49 people In a clan you can only take 45 to war since clan war goes up by 5 so you would only be excluding 4 people. And if you continue to not get chosen to be in war you just leave the clan...don't see how you can get bullied on a game on the phone

[QueenReezy]

It would be nice if players can choose if they want to be in a war or not. Sometimes i don't have enough elixir (or I'm saving for an upgrade) to make "good" troops and people start back to back wars with no recovery time. I would find it unfair if I'm kicked out while I've made good contribution to the clan before.

But if you make the choice to be in a war and then you don't attack... Kick!!

[HiFliya]

Like others before me have said. Clan leaders who care more about their war record than the fun of Clan Wars will bring their elite attackers with high tier troops and killer strategies ONLY. Forget winning as a team, it would be the same 10-20 players attacking every two days.

Leaders should not have this power, it should go to the Member to choose when he/she wants to go to war. Leaders can set their own provisions about that but should not have the power to restrict members to war.

[Ketchupfied]

Like others before me have said. Clan leaders who care more about their war record than the fun of Clan Wars will bring their elite attackers with high tier troops and killer strategies ONLY. Forget winning as a team, it would be the same 10-20 players attacking every two days.

Leaders should not have this power, it should go to the Member to choose when he/she wants to go to war. Leaders can set their own provisions about that but should not have the power to restrict members to war.

i agree having the solely the leader to decide might be unfair. better to have live the first couple of hours from the preparation day to opt in or out of war.