Challenge/Dueling system!

[Heston]

I am not sure if this has been requested yet but I want to see what everyone thinks about having a system where you can challenge your clan mates on raiding their defenses and testing your offense skills. Now how my idea shapes out is first you have to request a challenge on one of your clan mates and if he accepts then you can pick from your own arsenal what kind of units you will bring.

I am also adding the idea that the units you choose to bring is around how much your income currently is but not using your current income (thus making you use what you usually raid for Matchmaking because people don't normally attack with 20 dragons). And no loot would not be lost or gained because its just like a free test.

What would also be nice is when the request is accepted the one that is challenge can watch live almost like a clan war match! This would be a very nice way to give feedback to your clan mate defenses immediately (and to also asses yourself).

For the final idea is to add a cool down to requesting a duel because it would be annoying to be spamming duels to someone all day, 2 - 3 hours seems fine.

What made me think about this is because my clanmate is a HUGE gloater and he believes there is no way to reaching and destroying his town hall in the match making system so I was hoping to find him in the system but that's impossible.

EDIT: If you have just read this then post comments on how to add/change this idea to catch SuperCell attention! It has not been ruled out and so far the reasons are:
- Exploitations during Clan Wars
Here is the summary
Ok so how this idea is going so far is:
-> If a clan member has not made adjustments in his base then is eligible for requesting/being requested for challenge
-> after challenge is done cannot be requested for X amount of Minutes
-> during clan wars this feature is Disabled
-> no loot would be gain for the attacker or lost as defender
-> Watch Live would hopefully be introduced (somehow in clan chat box)
-> will not effect Matchmaking stats OR Achievements

[HiFliya]

I am not sure if this has been requested yet but I want to see what everyone thinks about having a system where you can challenge your clan mates on raiding their defenses and testing your offense skills. Now how my idea shapes out is first you have to request a challenge on one of your clan mates and if he accepts then you can pick from your own arsenal what kind of units you will bring. I am also adding the idea that the units you choose to bring is around how much your income currently is but using your current income (thus making you use what you usually raid for Matchmaking because people don't normally attack with 20 dragons). What would also be nice is when the request is accepted the one that is challenge can watch live almost like a clan war match! This would be a very nice way to give feedback to your clan mate defenses (and to also asses yourself). For the final idea is to add a cool down to requesting a duel because it would be annoying to be spamming duels to someone all day, 2 - 3 hours seems fine

What made me think about this is because my clanmate is a HUGE gloater and he believes there is no way to reaching and destroying his town hall in the match making system so I was hoping to find him in the system but that's impossible.

Welcome to the Forums!
Unfortunately this idea would be highly exploited during CW for the purpose of reconaissance and practice. Though it wont be perfect, it would give an idea of how to effectively two or three star a base. Use the search bar and you will find hundreds of other players requesting a Sandbox mode sort of thing
Thanks for Reading
Hi-FLiya

[Heston]

you broke my heart HiFliya but thanks for the fast post! Now I must channel the power of my fantasies to hope for the day a similar system appears! haha

[HiFliya]

you broke my heart HiFliya but thanks for the fast post! Now I must channel the power of my fantasies to hope for the day a similar system appears! haha

haha im usually fast on these kinds of posts as its generally the same thing and i kinda know what im going to say before hand. Especially in this subforum, its mostly people asking for the same thing over and over again, however there will be that one idea that is so original that it piques my interest.

[Heston]

So the cool down to requesting duels was not enough? What if it costed... gems? o___O

[HiFliya]

So the cool down to requesting duels was not enough? What if it costed... gems? o___O

Well its not the cooldown thats a problem, its the exploitation during Clan wars, where clan members will change their base to resemble an opponents and have another mate practice attacks against it.

[Heston]

Aw dam so will disabling this feature during clan wars remedy this problem HiFliya? Or if you were to have your very own system on this, how will it go? More feedback more power!!

EDIT: this includes from preparation to end.

[HiFliya]

Aw dam so will disabling this feature during clan wars remedy this problem HiFliya? Or if you were to have your very own system on this, how will it go? More feedback more power!!

Id have it so that the only way that this would be remotely possible, was if a member changed his Base within the past 24 hours, they shouldn't be able to spar/ spar with. That way the prep time doesnt allow for a recon attack, and people still have time to redo their base with an original time and have it tested in a timely manner. Of course there is still the matchmaking attacks possible, but that is part of the building process. Players would have to accept/decline a spar from their peers so that they are not happening every second of the day without you knowing.

Request from the Member List in you Clan, just add a new interface like CC troops, or like Clan Mail, no pics and dont feel like generating some...

Another point, Elixir/Dark Elixir would have to be used. I said this in an earlier thread. Knowledge and Experience should have a cost, and that cost is the Elixir used to create your army. Loot would not be won or lost, from either player. League bonuses would not take effect, trophies are ruled out too. So this idea would be strictly knowledge and experience based. As well as a little bit of gloating.

[Heston]

Wow. I am totally swayed by your piece of information. Even if it does cost elixirs I would totally go gung-ho all in on my best friend to see what I can do. Have you already gave this piece into this kind of request already?(Just curious)

I do feel like going totally sandbox free elixirs for a test was a little to much on the of an edge for the player for a WHOLE lot of information. its gotta feel worthy you know :))

Have this been hinted in any SuperCell sneak peek forums yet?

[HiFliya]

Wow. I am totally swayed by your piece of information. Even if it does cost elixirs I would totally go gung-ho all in on my best friend to see what I can do. Have you already gave this piece into this kind of request already?(Just curious)

I do feel like going totally sandbox free elixirs for a test was a little to much on the of an edge for the player for a WHOLE lot of information. its gotta feel worthy you know )

Have this been hinted in any SuperCell sneak peek forums yet?

Nope, i actually have not given this idea any thought until my last post here. It was literally a compilation of reasons i knew why people didnt like this and a solution for both sides of the argument.

as for Sneak peeks, I dont know if SC has had anything along these lines