So you wanna make a new troop?

[NF2335]

You should put a poll for this thread.

[Asmdus88]

You should put a poll for this thread.

But since there are 32 concepts and polls only allow 25 selections I think ppl commenting on here about what they like best is the most accurate way to determine the most desirable concepts.

havent been on here in a while, but still stands that we need 8 more votes from ppl to get us to the minimum sized community sample that would determine what ideas advance to be voted on next

[Coconutko]

None should make it cuz they all suck

[Coconutko]

But the way you did it is not that bad so congratulations on that. The reason I don't like is because it copies lots of troops and coc doesint need that

[Asmdus88]

None should make it cuz they all suck

Nobody likes trolls 😃

[Asmdus88]

But the way you did it is not that bad so congratulations on that. The reason I don't like is because it copies lots of troops and coc doesint need that

Are mainly based off of ones I found on this sub forum; while others are my own. Either way I like all of them I think all have interesting takes on what they could add to the attack strategy of the game. If you wanna vote on anything cool, if not then ok. I'm sure other ppl would be interested in it

[TheHobbityHobbits44]

This is one of the best ideas I have seen on the forum. But not alot of people are voting so I think you should repost it and narrow it down to 25 so you can have a poll. That way you could put all of the ideas into the thread and it would be much more organized, then you could keep on posting at after each round of tournament.
just an idea to organize it better.

[Venomben]

what is wrong with the people on this forum, we need just a few more people to feel strongly about the advancement of coc and get their hands out of their pants. These ideas are some of the truly progressive ones,and while lightning de is annoying, i get it but please guys let us focus on something more productive than argument. so get voting only 8 more and then the next round can commence.

[AceOfRaids]

I haven't been on here in ages. I would vote but I don't know how y'all are doing the votes now.

[Jamesf01]

TROOP IDEAS ON THIS THREAD









1. Doomknight (by Asmdus88) (pg.1)
2. Gremlin (by AceofRaids) (pg.1)
3. Branshee (by Venomben) (pg.1)
4. Bogman (by evjohn13) (pg.1)
5. Hydra (by thehobbityhobbits44; SpicyMooseSpit) (pg.2)
6. Frost Devil (by Asmdus88) (pg.2)
7. Kamafreezee (by Asmdus88) (pg.2)
8. Flamebuoyant (by Venomben) (pg.2)
9. Alchemist (by evjohn13) (pg.2)
10. Cyclops (by Hascerflef) (pg.2)
11. Voodoo Prince (by Swannicholas) (Pg.2)
12. Vampire (by Venomben) (pg.3)
13. Troll (by Asmdus88) (pg.3)
14. Thorns (by Venomben) (pg.3)
15. Ice Pheonix (by Hi-Fliya) (pg.6)
16. Destroyer (by Asmdus88) (pg.6)
17. Blood Hound (by AceofRaids) (pg.9)
18. Wisp (by evjohn13) (pg.10)
19. Tidelementist (by Venomben) (pg.11)
20. Wolf Rider (by KingDao) (pg.11)
21. Sorceror (by ColonelAwesome) (pg.11)
22. Beserker (by Dunghaufen) (pg.14)
23.Wormzier (by MinniJay) (pg.18)
24. Spider (by OmegaDelta) (pg.18)
25. Cannon Giant (by Heymitch) (pg.18)
26. Harpy (by Tinokoo) (pg.18)
27. Cerberus (by EvilRaven) (pg.30)
28. Werewolf (by Asmdus88) (pg.31)
29. Tyrant (by Asmdus88) (pg.31)
30. Minotaur (by Asmdus88) (pg.31)
31. Reaper (by Asmdus88) (pg.31)
32. Night Goblin (by Dunghaufen) (pg.32)

First off i'd like to give a special thank you out to everyone who contributed your ideas or helped to inspire the concepts that are presented on this thread. I'd also like to thank those of you who have continued to show support for this thread idea; you are all very much appreciated guys!!

The list on this thread consists of 32 troops; and of those troops there can only be 4 that would actually have a chance at making it into clash of clans (since there are only 4 available dark barracks spots left.)

To figure out which of these 4 will make the cut; YOU the clash community must vote for your favorite ones.

This will be done in a tournament style fashion, utilizing a "face-off" between each of the various troop concepts; which will be structured into 4 separate categories (dark barracks 7, 8, 9, & 10). At each level of barracks you will be permitted to vote once; for a total of 4 votes. After enough votes have been cast to advance a troop concept up from each face off point; the next round will begin and you will be able to vote yet again for 1 more pick at each barracks level. (There are a total of 3 rounds)

Votes will be cast by commenting on this thread and stating what your favorites are. I will read every one of these and keep track of them to see which troop ideas are the most liked. Once enough votes have been cast we will be able to narrow down a top 4 list for supercell's consideration.

The Tournament below will be updated with each round as certain troop concepts advance while others get eliminated.

Dark Barracks 7

(Wormzier vs Voodoo Prince, Alchemist vs Blood Hound, Wolf Rider vs Gremlin, Tidelementist vs Night Goblin)

Dark Barracks 8

(Werewolf vs Sorceror, Cannon Giant vs Destroyer, Ice Pheonix vs Kamafreezee, Flamebuoyant vs Vampire)

Dark Barracks 9

(Branshee vs Harpy, Hydra vs Spider, Cerberus vs Troll, Thorns vs Wisp)

Dark Barracks 10
(Bogman vs Doomknight, Tyrant vs Minotaur, Beserker vs Frost Devil, Reaper vs Cyclops)
************************************************** **************************************************

Also, for other great ideas involving new defenses, check out Venomben's So you wanna make a new defense? thread

Woah! Those are A LOT of Troop Ideas! He must of put A LOT of work into this!