Should SC do something about open Town Halls?

[crucible]

i think TH sniping is fine, I would rather be sniper by a th6 in master 2 than get attacked by a fellow th10.

[ChiefThomas]

Yes. It would help greatly with loot to not have 90% of bases under a shield 24/7. My suggestion is to have the TH hold a significant amount of loot. Or make a higher penalty for losing your Town Hall during a raid. Not sure what penalty could be, but it's a good possibility.

[ronny2011]

if they make th10 hold 100k each resources in th, 75k each for th9, 50k for th8, and 25k for th7... i think people will start protecting their th better.

[Japperan123]

No Thx, Its good as it is this way

[bigc221]

if they make th10 hold 100k each resources in th, 75k each for th9, 50k for th8, and 25k for th7... i think people will start protecting their th better.

I'd still put out my town hall. 75k and a guaranteed shield is worth it instead of the possibility of several raids taking up to 350k a piece. Don't even need one good raid to make it up. All this would do is make th sniping more viable as a way of saving up and probably make way more people start sniping.

[theEvilEmpire]

the point of the game should be to defend your base as best you can, the fact that majority of players play with THs outside proves its a loophole that should be closed

[JZDaBoss123]

No they shouldn't, it's part of farming! What type of changes do you want?

[JAZZPRIME74]

Yes. It would help greatly with loot to not have 90% of bases under a shield 24/7. My suggestion is to have the TH hold a significant amount of loot. Or make a higher penalty for losing your Town Hall during a raid. Not sure what penalty could be, but it's a good possibility.

Then raid in the morning or right before you go to bed if you want a lot of loot or just drop maybe 50k until you find a unactive its not that hard.

[241m]

the point of the game should be to defend your base as best you can, the fact that majority of players play with THs outside proves its a loophole that should be closed

I bet they also intended that people would push to as high of a league as they could all the time, instead of dropping down to farm. Where are you at right now?

[youngthegreat]

Do you guys think something should be done about open town halls to make it less rewarding? Just want to see opinions here. Not like I can really control these things, but please no flame wars, just opinions.

If it's so rewarding most of the players should put their th outside.
While you next you don't see many th open.
Not even in your clan


What bothers you? You want to attack someone and he always gets shiled with open th?
Open Th even gives loot bonus and that pretty helps players to get some loot.
Give me a break. Can't believe these th botheres someone.
I am happy to snipe it but I most of the players have it inside.


In addition why do you think about what SC intended?
Are you SC related person? If it helps and if the customers are happy and
if they do not have problem with it no need to change it.