Crush the hopper!

[m201806h]

Seriously, I can't believe only one other person read this idea.

Isn't everyone tired of clan hoppers? Unfortunately, there isn't much we can do about it, you know? People are going to come and go as they please, because there is no way to hold anyone accountable. When you're hiding behind an anonymous screen name, you're as brave as a lion and do as you please, right?

Well, what if we introduce a little incentive to stay? I've read an idea about adding a "reputation" to a player's profile. Well, let's face it. That requires a butt load of programming, a lot more committed memory, and not a lot of results. Most users of this game don't care who they are recruiting, and aren't going to go through the process of screening thoroughly. In fact, if 48 out of 49 clan members did screen a recruit, that 49th player would ruin the update.♥

What I'm here to suggest is fairly simple. Just add an "attack deserter" button for the loosing clan to abuse. This button would be in the chat box only, so this player would only suffer the abuse until the chat box refreshed, and obviously the same shield rules would apply. So, nothing TOO devastating, but still something to make the clan feel a bit better and a slight deterrent to the "hopper."

[fivefivesix]

I wish there was some indication of how long they were in their last clan or how many clans they have been in in the last 4 weeks when the "can I join your clan" request comes in. I don't even mind the donation troops, it's just a disruption to the clan when pop in and out. I'm sure that there are some clans that don't mind but our clan has been together for almost 2 years and always are welcoming new people but hoppers just suck.

[dahimi]

This has been posted a million times. It's also way too easy to abuse.

[rwelshjr]

This has been posted a million times. It's also way too easy to abuse.

You can only break even on abuse. NOT having it is currently about the most abused thing in the entire game. I don't think worrying about abuse has any validity here.

[fivefivesix]

This has been posted a million times. It's also way too easy to abuse.

And now we see who is afraid that they would never be let in a clan again, isn't that right Hoppy McHopperson?

[m201806h]

Has it really been posted that much? I know I've posted it once before, I just feel kind this is a plausible update, without being an unreasonable burden on the programmers. I'm not asking for free gems, more loot, or changes to the basic boundaries of the program. I'm not proposing to add an entire new server to the system to maintain the reputation of every player in the game. In just asking for a slight modification to a feature that already exists.


Nothing extravagant. There is one more thing i meant to add, however. There would NOT be an option to attack members who are kicked! This is for obvious reasons.

(In case the reasons are not obvious enough, the biggest one is to prevent abuse of the feature. )

[Rotscheidt]

Data could be irrelevant. We have players that come and go, even some co's. How is that feature of use for us long time gamers? We've had ppl being called hopper while they stuck with us for abt a year...

[iceageg]

Free movement between clans is a very good thing and should not be prevented. Set your clan to invite only and the overwhelming majority of the hoppers you don't like won't join anymore. If they do feed them 5 goblins and boot them out immediately. Exp for you and you get that warm fuzzy feeling and a smile when you boot them. Hoppers are a good thing and should not be stopped.

[CoFusion]

Here are 3 better options which are fairly simple to implement.

1. Bonus xp for being in a clan the entire season.
2. A counter in the profile of clan war attacks NOT used.
3. Under Attacks/Defenses won, the number of clans you've been in that season.

[Firmanator]

Make a website or thread were people can post the hoppers and search up their name to see whether someone has been caught "hopping" I think as though it could help

Hopefully a supercell member sees this post and says "Yea, Thats important" and puts something like my suggestion in the Topics of the Clash Forums.

Anyway Thanks
- Firmanator