I spend a lot of elixer each war on topping up war CCs for my clan member colleagues but there should surely be some XP or at least an update so that these troops are included in your donated / requested ratios??
Be great if you could add in the elixer of donated troops to the winnings of the embers who donated maybe?
Anyways, love the game and spend far too much time playing it! Lol
Hopefully you can do something with my comment.
Cheers
Tobs
I absolutely agree. I spent tons of elixir putting dragons in all my clan mates war castles and you wouldn't know it by looking at my donations. In my old clan, we had to make 2000 donations to get CO. Counting war castle donations, I would have been well past 2000. But my donated/requested ratio looked like ♥♥♥♥ because most of my donations were during war prep. It's a shame for someone to put so many resources toward defending their clan mates and not even get any recognition. I'd be happy just to see the numbers in my donations. That's it.Originally Posted by jimothy73
I agree 100% it could even become a new acheivement to receive gems from the fine CoC woman
I think it's fine how it is. You shouldn't need an incentive to help in the war effort, you should be motivated by teamwork and comradery not the reward you get for doing it. Also, this is not the correct sub forum, this sub forum is for troops and spell ideas only, this thread belongs in the new ideas and requests section.
I also throw in troops for my clan and no recognition. It would also force or make members to contribute in the pre war
Awesome. Just awesome. Why didn't I even notice or think about this. You're a genius.
The problem.
I was thinking about this the other day. Some fool in my clan gave me giants for war defense! I was furious. I Deleted them an had him donate me wizards and archers instead. Thats the problem. A clan can easily get everyones donations to 1,000 plus if one person deletes their cc troops and has their friends and clan mates donate another few troops. Its a cycle thats almost infinite and the only limit is the 24h prep time (and of course your own resources). This is probably the main reason why and im sure its fixable. I wouldn't take advantage of the system because my friend im need achievment has already been met. Im sure most people (especially in the lower clans) would beef up their donations just to help with recruiting and to brag/show off. Personally i think that donating in war is the reward when you win because ive seen many close wars where the troops donated really pulled through. I honestly dont mind even though i easily donate 200 troops in war. I can easily make the lost elixir up in generally 2-3 raids. Also as mentioned above this thread is in the wrong place.
I think that the donations don't get counted, but the XP should be gained. As it is kind of like hopping between clans and donating. Even if they remove the troops, u get xp, and u lose ur troops, so it could be the same for war
Posting Permissions
