How to Control Clan Members Involved in War

[rigerz]

We, like many other clans, have the issue of players being inactive in Wars, or some members wanting to war and others not so they end up leaving and weaker players being in wars where they struggle to win.

my suggestion is that there is some form of spell or button that can be player activated and lasts for 24 hours. If war is declared during those 24 hours then ONLY the players with that activated are involved in the war. It may also be beneficial if leaders and co-leaders had the ability to change members and elders 'war setting'.

This is would mean that:
- all clan members would be active and want to participate
- you could do a war for say your top 10 members to show the new players how to war
- a bottom 15 war for new players to find a more suitable war where they don't get ripped apart by enemy top 10
- no leaving of clan prior to war being declared
- maybe some other benefits I cant think of.

The way I would do it is to have to war logo that appears by a players rank in brown when activated and grey when it isn't. Leaders can change everyone's setting in the clan ( including other leaders ) and other members / elders can only change their own. After 24 hours it self deactivates.

Im sure there are ways to improve on this so please comment below, or if a similar idea has been suggested I could find then maybe post a link to it and they can be combined.

Thanks for reading!

[MinkiSan]

We, like many other clans, have the issue of players being inactive in Wars, or some members wanting to war and others not so they end up leaving and weaker players being in wars where they struggle to win.

my suggestion is that there is some form of spell or button that can be player activated and lasts for 24 hours. If war is declared during those 24 hours then ONLY the players with that activated are involved in the war. It may also be beneficial if leaders and co-leaders had the ability to change members and elders 'war setting'.

This is would mean that:
- all clan members would be active and want to participate
- you could do a war for say your top 10 members to show the new players how to war
- a bottom 15 war for new players to find a more suitable war where they don't get ripped apart by enemy top 10
- no leaving of clan prior to war being declared
- maybe some other benefits I cant think of.

The way I would do it is to have to war logo that appears by a players rank in brown when activated and grey when it isn't. Leaders can change everyone's setting in the clan ( including other leaders ) and other members / elders can only change their own. After 24 hours it self deactivates.

Im sure there are ways to improve on this so please comment below, or if a similar idea has been suggested I could find then maybe post a link to it and they can be combined.

Thanks for reading!

This will work but i think it just needs tweaking and i think the sequence for war should go.
1) A leader declares a war
2) All members of the clan opt in or out by pressing the in or out icon next to their name in the clan castle (if someone doesn't activate their icon the leader can declare them out)
3) The leader then starts a search for war as usual
one major change to war needs to be that once you have opted in you are unable to leave the clan until the war is over. There should also be a stat added for the amount of wars a player took part in but didn't attack twice. Another star for who donated what to the clan castle on the war map.
This way a leader can keep more control over a war and the match ups will be better because people can't leave. Tracking who attacks twice will help with people not joining in after they say they will.

[Mallan]

I like the sound of this as well. Good thinking Clanners.

[rigerz]

I particularly like that idea of not being able to leave the clan once war has been declared that you have opted in for, should certainly be included in a future update in my opinion

[awesomness2016]

First, even if you can't leave the clan, no one can force you to attack, so I don't see that don't any good.

Second, there is already a thread on this that Supercell has responded to, and the easiest solution is to have a toggle but the players (and possibly leaders) can switch at any time. That way whenever a leader starts a war search, it includes everyone who is marked as active.

[rigerz]

have you got a link to it? I'd quite like a read

[MinkiSan]

First, even if you can't leave the clan, no one can force you to attack, so I don't see that don't any good.

Second, there is already a thread on this that Supercell has responded to, and the easiest solution is to have a toggle but the players (and possibly leaders) can switch at any time. That way whenever a leader starts a war search, it includes everyone who is marked as active.

true but if they have no choice than to stay they will be more likely to attack. If the stat were tracked (wars vs total attacks in wars) and you could see that you would also be able to decide if you wanted them in to start.

It has to be better than now, you start a war, the top # are included! some of those people decide to leave! you lose the war and there are people in the clan who would have battled!