Matching on Clan Wars its a ♥♥. Outnumber with Town Hall 10 on clan wars.

[JohnnyBGood]

I'm new to the forum and I don't know how they match the clans on war. It's not fair that the opponent have 4 more Town Hall 10 with inferno tower than are clan. Better upgrade troops and better base. We lost by 1 only becouse outnumber on town hall 10. I like competition cuz thats all the war its about but not like this......They need to see this before its to late......

Sounds like a competitive match.

Not sure what you hoped to gain by crying about it on the forum.

[hande]

No, you are wrong. Your anecdotal evidence isn't valid and you misread my post, i'll try again. With EQUAL SKILL an early (not previously maxed th9) th10 is a major major advantage over a maxed th9. I'm glad YOU and YOUR clan are so skilled that you can easily 2 star th10's but that is not common.

Feel free to post some epic vids of your th9 clan members 2 starring an average non-♥♥♥♥♥♥ed base setup TH10 with double IT's and 3 xbows. Just an average th10 that upgraded from a non-maxed th9. If you have a way to consistently 2 star them you are just flat out amazing and in the 0.01% of coc players. In fact, start a thread about it because I know lots of players could benefit from your mad skillz.

Bottom line, we've all had clan wars where the other clan looked like they would dominate but didn't secondary to being clueless. The matchmaking system doesn't know how much skill a particular clan has, therefore it's job is to assure equal matchups assuming equal skill.

Disagree, many early th10s are just scrap and dont necessarily even have all the spells and other stuff you are claiming to give them a major advantage. Regardless if they have, many th10s are puny attackers. They may be brilliant farmers but war is sth quite different. How do you explain otherwise that most of the time my base is not even attacked. Most of them even seem to think our maxed th9 bases look scary because even they remain fairly often unattacked and actually at least in the last ten wars a th10 has not 3 starred our maxed th9 bases, inversely what you claim to be easy for a th10. Enemies of same or higher lvl than my base attack much lower lvl bases instead, sometimes with good, sometimes with bad success. Even in the last war saw a th10 that could not 3 star one of our th8 bases. We attack them from top to bottom. Our skills are hardly 'mad' but we are dedicated players who put much effort to learning. People who dont learn will soon find themselves looking a new clan.

[Mobad]

We often get matched with clans that have th10s. Our top player is only a mid th8. I've noticed that they often have a player that only has a th4 with minimal defences. Seems to bring their score way down so they can out match others.

[BigDarrick]

Disagree, many early th10s are just scrap and dont necessarily even have all the spells and other stuff you are claiming to give them a major advantage. Regardless if they have, many th10s are puny attackers. They may be brilliant farmers but war is sth quite different. How do you explain otherwise that most of the time my base is not even attacked. Most of them even seem to think our maxed th9 bases look scary because even they remain fairly often unattacked and actually at least in the last ten wars a th10 has not 3 starred our maxed th9 bases, inversely what you claim to be easy for a th10. Enemies of same or higher lvl than my base attack much lower lvl bases instead, sometimes with good, sometimes with bad success. Even in the last war saw a th10 that could not 3 star one of our th8 bases. We attack them from top to bottom. Our skills are hardly 'mad' but we are dedicated players who put much effort to learning. People who dont learn will soon find themselves looking a new clan.

I am going to have to agree here. We are currently matched up against 8 TH 10s versus our 3 and we expect to romp them. But our nines know what the heck they are doing. And yes, 5 of their TH 10's blow. Premmie. But our top TH 9's can certainly 2 star a regular TH 10 on a regular base. I would not say they could do it on a well built/designed base or well upgraded one.

So on the surface it looks like we are outmatched. But like our last war were we were also outnumbered 3 TH 10 vs 7 TH 10, we still one due to better base designs and their attacks were not as good as ours.

All that being said, I certainly agree the matchmaking process need serious work. We have gotten some raw deals. But just comparing TH 10s isn't enough to make that case. Its a part of it, but certainly not the end of it.

[Terraist]

Most of the time we win anyway because we are just that good, but when there are 4x as many Th10s as your clan all having max troops and max defenses, its a moot point.

T1Girr

Add this to an already long list of posts that ooze with arrogance. Obviously not a moot point if you are just that good.

I realize MM needs work, I'm complaining about it often as we have had a great many more mismatches than fair ones ever since we started our new clan. All I'm saying is that the OP has no right to call the war a mismatch when the war was only lost by 1*. Obviously MM was spot on.

Now, if a clan went up against, let's say, 4x more TH10 with max troops and defenses (which I doubt would ever happen in your clan, I mean come on, 8 fully defensively maxed TH10?) and fought hard and lost by 30* anyways. Then yeah, obvious mismatch.