Read on for reducing clan clogging!!!

[Madman26]

C'mon guys :/ Please keep this thread alive! I found it stuck on page 11 within loads of garbage! This is the last time I will bump my own thread... If you support this idea, please give me a bump! It helps a lot! I cannot bump again, I already feel bad doing this because it is against the forum rules.

[SkyMage1001]

I suggest, if all the players in a clan are completley inactive (havent logged on once) for 21 days, the clan will automatically be disbanded (broken), and the people inside will be clan-less. This helps because there are less clans clogging up the search system, and this does not hurt people, as they must be inactive if they havent logged on for 21+ days, and thus, they dont care/wont know (hehe) that they are no longer in a clan.

This problem is like debt: The longer it goes on un-solved, the bigger the problem gets! Especially since the game has so many players that join new every day! Its best to eliminate the problem at the roots...

The idea of removing a clan is not so good. As many have said before, there are many circumstances in which a clan may be forced into inactivity. Even if this were to be implemented, the clan search function wouldn't be improved by much, because the issue is a lot of somewhat active clans sharing the same name. This isn't going to help that.

C'mon guys :/ Please keep this thread alive! I found it stuck on page 11 within loads of garbage! This is the last time I will bump my own thread... If you support this idea, please give me a bump! It helps a lot! I cannot bump again, I already feel bad doing this because it is against the forum rules.

I've made quite a few threads, and never bumped them because people will only respond to threads they want to. If it is stuck on page 11, that tells you that this idea is not very popular.

[Madman26]

The idea of removing a clan is not so good. As many have said before, there are many circumstances in which a clan may be forced into inactivity. Even if this were to be implemented, the clan search function wouldn't be improved by much, because the issue is a lot of somewhat active clans sharing the same name. This isn't going to help that.

Why not? The issue is active clans sharing the same name, but the clans that are sharing the same name are mostly INACTIVE! And not inactive like logging on for a few minutes in a day, inactive like not logging on for 3 MONTHS!!!
Also, usually, these are clans with a maximum of 5 people. No active player will join this clan, thus, no harm will be done. How will an inactive player feel bad about their clan being disbanded due to the fact that they didn't play for a few months? They have no right to complain.

Also, this idea will encourage people to be more active in order to keep their clan from being disbanded.
Keep in mind that it only requires one person to log on within the clan to keep the clan alive. If even one person out of 50 (lets just say) logs on, the clan won't be disbanded. They don't even have to attack or anything, simply open up the app and let it load...

[Jietoh]

The idea of removing a clan is not so good. As many have said before, there are many circumstances in which a clan may be forced into inactivity. Even if this were to be implemented, the clan search function wouldn't be improved by much, because the issue is a lot of somewhat active clans sharing the same name. This isn't going to help that.

Having to reform your clan after the entire population of the clan has gone inactive is a minor inconvenience. Yes you won't be able to get those inactive players back but in this case the system does you the favor of removing them. While there are many circumstances in which a clan may be forced into inactivity, the cases where this happens and then the players become active again must be exceedingly rare. 99.99% of the time the entire clan is inactive is because they players simply quit playing the game and didn't bother the quit the clan before they did so.

[Madman26]

Having to reform your clan after the entire population of the clan has gone inactive is a minor inconvenience. Yes you won't be able to get those inactive players back but in this case the system does you the favor of removing them. While there are many circumstances in which a clan may be forced into inactivity, the cases where this happens and then the players become active again must be exceedingly rare. 99.99% of the time the entire clan is inactive is because they players simply quit playing the game and didn't bother the quit the clan before they did so.

Exactly. Whats more is, that why would the leader even WANT to get those inactive players back. Those instances where the clan was by chance not able to be active, even if they wished to, are very very very rare. In that case, I'm sure the leader or a dedicated member can get the other players back together.

[kroneker]

What a clan is made for
To keep friends in touch ... of course
To get more strong troops ... even
To fight the war ... surely


How is a clan with less than 10 people? useless
How is a clan of people who are inactive? useless


My proposal is simple, if a player does not connect for 20 days becomes inactive and no longer elegibile for war.
If a player remains inelegibile for 3 consecutive wars is eliminated from the Clan
The clans with less than 5 players are automatically disbanded after one week.

[Madman26]

What a clan is made for
To keep friends in touch ... of course
To get more strong troops ... even
To fight the war ... surely


How is a clan with less than 10 people? useless
How is a clan of people who are inactive? useless


My proposal is simple, if a player does not connect for 20 days becomes inactive and no longer elegibile for war.
If a player remains inelegibile for 3 consecutive wars is eliminated from the Clan
The clans with less than 5 players are automatically disbanded after one week.

The war thing is up to the clan leaders in my opinion. The eliminate is also up to the leaders. But I think 1 week is farr too short of a time period. As I have said before, I think it should be atleast a month (30 days), but that can be adjusted. Personally I thought 3 weeks, but per discussion here, I now agree on 2-3 months. The clan members are not a variable. Of course, mostly this affects clans with 5 members or less, but the variable is wether atleast one member in the clan has logged on atleast ONCE during the defined grace period.... Regardless of the number of members.

Thanks for your feedback though!

[Madman26]

not 21 maybe like 30-40

I am not sure what you mean?

Do you mean days? As in how many days does the clan have to be inactive in order for it to be disbanded by the system? Well then, I agree. 21 days is my opinion, but 1,2, or 3 months seems to be most peoples opinions... Go with the majority I guess, hehe 😉.

[Bastion15]

Well I disagree. everyone should have the rights to have and stay in a clan. Even if they are inactive thats the basic principles of humans rights if they are inactive let them in a clan let them don't get some player to leave like an object. Some people will come back to COC and they will just play it so let them if they are inactive let them they aren't harming anyone so they're not creating any lag or some sort. And also you will just make another trouble because of COC constant update or maintenance people seem to get bored of it until now the new troop is drawing some old player in and make an inactive come back a little more active. If they start it some people will lose it and will stop playing it you will just cause another trouble instead of repairing it people here want useful updates not something that only work for certain people . And what will happen if they came back huh like a clan that's for all friends and then when they realize there's a new update and came back just to find that their clan been disband and what they will be mad plus how about a friend clan that's having a test they will decide to study then play a game. Think about it some clan have a good reason to be inactive. Anyway that's my opinion

[BrianHotshot]

What a clan is made for
To keep friends in touch ... of course
To get more strong troops ... even
To fight the war ... surely


How is a clan with less than 10 people? useless
How is a clan of people who are inactive? useless


My proposal is simple, if a player does not connect for 20 days becomes inactive and no longer elegibile for war.
If a player remains inelegibile for 3 consecutive wars is eliminated from the Clan
The clans with less than 5 players are automatically disbanded after one week.

I think deleting inactive clans will anger many people, automatically kicking inactive players out of the clan??? NO. Players has the right to stay in a clan, as long as they don't get kicked out of a higher ranking player. If this automatic kicker is put into use, then what would elder, co-leader, leader's kicking power be used for? Just because you're inactive doesn't mean there should be negative consequences towards you.