Read on for reducing clan clogging!!!

[dahimi]

*Slowly Claps*

What? Do you think just because you have a few thousand posts, you are the boss here? Take a step back bro

Where did I say that? Maybe because I have a few thousand posts, you think I'm the boss here? I have no idea what you're trying to say.

You're telling people to look at the poll, but the poll says nothing.

[Madman26]

Disbanding, removing, labeling, penalizing, punishing, badging, etc., etc., all lead to others dictating how I should be playing the game. Something that nobody, other than maybe SC, has a right to do. No matter how hard you try, there is no way to fairily justify any of their use.

Removing the the clan simply cleans up the amount of clans that exist, and also encourage people to be more active! It's not a dictatorship: No one is putting a gun to their head and telling them that they HAVE TO play, it's their choice. If they don't, they just don't have a clan anymore. Also, it isn't a specific person, it's the WHOLE CLAN that has to be inactive in order for it to be disbanded!

Due to that, no harm will be done as any active players will have left the inactive clan long before it is disbanded. (Who wants to be in an inactive clan??!!)

[Madman26]

Where did I say that? Maybe because I have a few thousand posts, you think I'm the boss here? I have no idea what you're trying to say.

You're telling people to look at the poll, but the poll says nothing.

What do you mean the poll shows nothing? Out of 17 people, 9 agree with this notion, 5 do NOT, 1 has his own version, and the rest are in a sense, neutral. Almost double of the voters like this idea! So stop being a spoil-sport and open your eyes! The amount of voters may not be much, but Rome wasn't built in a day! I created this thread like 4 hours ago 😂

[Herpacleese]

Removing the the clan simply cleans up the amount of clans that exist, and also encourage people to be more active! It's not a dictatorship: No one is putting a gun to their head and telling them that they HAVE TO play, it's their choice. If they don't, they just don't have a clan anymore. Also, it isn't a specific person, it's the WHOLE CLAN that has to be inactive in order for it to be disbanded!

Due to that, no harm will be done as any active players will have left the inactive clan long before it is disbanded. (Who wants to be in an inactive clan??!!)

No, not a dictatorship, but you would be dispensing consequences if I don't play/behave a certain way, in this case being to inactive. So once again, it is my choice to be inactive, for what ever reason, if I wish, and therefore should not be punished in any way.

Further, you are attempting to justify this idea be stating that every member needs to show a certain amount of inactivity. How does one determine the reason for another's inactivity and avoid punishing the innocent?

[Madman26]

No, not a dictatorship, but you would be dispensing consequences if I don't play/behave a certain way, in this case being to inactive. So once again, it is my choice to be inactive, for what ever reason, if I wish, and therefore should not be punished in any way.

Further, you are attempting to justify this idea be stating that every member needs to show a certain amount of inactivity. How does one determine the reason for another's inactivity and avoid punishing the innocent?

Look, its not quite a punishment. If you don't log on even once in a month, id say thats a serious case of inactivity! Having your clan disbanded is not a huge thing. Just join a new one! This idea will weed out duplicate and inactive clans!

[adam1130]

Honestly, I think this would really irritate people. What if someone's wi-fi goes out and will take a long time to fix? Goes on a long vacation without wi-fi? Ect. As said, the clan has a right to exist as long as it hasn't been manually dis-banned by the leader.

[Brenn]

Look, its not quite a punishment. If you don't log on even once in a month, id say thats a serious case of inactivity! Having your clan disbanded is not a huge thing. Just join a new one! This idea will weed out duplicate and inactive clans!

But why does it matter?
We don't need to get rid of these clans. Supercell just has to improve the search results a bit.

[adam1130]

But why does it matter?
We don't need to get rid of these clans. Supercell just has to improve the search results a bit.

I agree completely.

[Raptor23]

*Like this idea? Support it by giving this thread a nice bump and voting!*
* Tell your friends!*
*If you don't agree, post here and say why!*


Supercell,

This is a serious request that is not really neccessary, but it would not require too mich code or time to make. It just makes life easier though

I suggest, if all the players in a clan are completley inactive (havent logged on once) for 21 days, the clan will automatically be disbanded (broken), and the people inside will be clan-less. This helps because there are less clans clogging up the search system, and this does not hurt people, as they must be inactive if they havent logged on for 21+ days, and thus, they dont care/wont know (hehe) that they are no longer in a clan.

If you do not like my idea (im talking to other forumers now), please tell me why RESPECTFULLY! I have not provoked anyone by making this thread, so please do not start a flame war!

P.S: Edit: The time period for the clan to be deemed as inactive, and be disbanded, is open to debate! I have no probs in that... As long as it's not something ridiculous like 1 year!
3 weeks is just an EXAMPLE, and my personal opinion.

Thank you for taking the time to read this! Please rate and share!

I reckon time should be 3 months

[Madman26]

Honestly, I think this would really irritate people. What if someone's wi-fi goes out and will take a long time to fix? Goes on a long vacation without wi-fi? Ect. As said, the clan has a right to exist as long as it hasn't been manually dis-banned by the leader.

Ok then, lets make the amount of time 3 months then, thats fair!