Clan War Ranking System Idea!

[BmooDyy]

SC is unfair with the ranking's gem reward. Changing the ranking system is needed.


1) The clans used way more gem, they still have to pay money for more gems
2) Always the top five or so, the very existence of the ranking reward is a mockery.


And it make senses because for the sake of logic I don't shake my hands with you in a village truce to go in lala land and farm all day. Logic wise, we would be attacking other clans, not making peace and not atking other Clans.

The reward system doesn't work with the way clans are ranked now, with my system (or another version of it) the gem rewards will never be guaranteed to the same clans all the time. It should be a reward not a given and I think a clan should have to win wars to get the reward.

[Ayyyyyema]

Because clan wars shows how a clan is doing together, their strategies, how they work together and etc beside that trophies in clans with more members is higher than in clans with less members (clan members shouldn't be considered as a factor). Yes, Clans that do not do wars should be considered as a bad clan because you can't work together well...

♥♥♥♥! My clan CHOSE not to do wars because our goal is to upgrade our bases instead of wasting elixar on pointless wars. Dont even try to tell me that measly loot bonus is any help, we can farm that shorter then TWO DAYS. And im one of the noobs of my clan, our majority are nearly maxed th9s.

You see, clan wars are for FUN. How much will fun improve your base? I get that nearly maxed th10s love something to do, and clan wars are completely for them. But what about everyone else? Well while you're wasting your time and resources on wars (which I Hope you are unless you just blow at wars) we're stealing your loot and improving our bases, like evvvveryone did before clan wars.

You may need to hold back on upgrades, if you dont then you're probably just a low th, but we dont. Enjoy slowing your progress, while we grow stronger every time you go to war!

We also trophy push every couple of season to see how high we can go, and of course, showing off those "great strategies"

Anyone can arrange a clan with high and low ths to add variety and high lvl troops to low player, thus winning wars. Pretty simple. The more you war, the more war wins. How is that skill? How fast you can gain as much loot as possible (even during bad loot season that everyone claims) and upgrade your base, thats more of a skill then your petty war wins. Mass drags for 3 stars, HA what a joke

[Ayyyyyema]

Also Imo, if this idea is implemented, trophy pushing would be obsolete. Everyone would farm lower then they normally would, and it'd be almost a troll on lower ths. Why would you wanna be in champs if you can farm in crystal and destroy th9s easily And repeat with every lvl. I know id just sit in gold forever and troll premie th8s and th7s.

[BmooDyy]

Anyone can arrange a clan with high and low ths to add variety and high lvl troops to low player, thus winning wars. Pretty simple. The more you war, the more war wins. How is that skill? How fast you can gain as much loot as possible (even during bad loot season that everyone claims) and upgrade your base, thats more of a skill then your petty war wins. Mass drags for 3 stars, HA what a joke

I don't think you're fully understanding, the individual trophies would stay and continue to be the same. The clans just wouldn't be ranked by them, the more war wins equals more points which means a higher ranked clan. It does take skill and a good clan to wins wars, which are profitable when won and bonuses are collected.

[xelrix]

clan wars, which has a ranking system based on trophies, would be relevant if winning wars actually award trophies.

whats the point of joining a war if you could be number 1 without doing any?

dont get me wrong, i have nothing against those in "pacifists" clans. more gameplay varieties is always better.
its just that right now, clan wars is just an inferior alternatives to get trophies, yet, still being a fundamental features in a game where players form clans and be competitive.
clan wars doesnt have much depth compared to the already shallow individual ranks.

[komohammad]

♥♥♥♥! My clan CHOSE not to do wars because our goal is to upgrade our bases instead of wasting elixar on pointless wars. Dont even try to tell me that measly loot bonus is any help, we can farm that shorter then TWO DAYS. And im one of the noobs of my clan, our majority are nearly maxed th9s.

You see, clan wars are for FUN. How much will fun improve your base? I get that nearly maxed th10s love something to do, and clan wars are completely for them. But what about everyone else? Well while you're wasting your time and resources on wars (which I Hope you are unless you just blow at wars) we're stealing your loot and improving our bases, like evvvveryone did before clan wars.

You may need to hold back on upgrades, if you dont then you're probably just a low th, but we dont. Enjoy slowing your progress, while we grow stronger every time you go to war!

We also trophy push every couple of season to see how high we can go, and of course, showing off those "great strategies"

Anyone can arrange a clan with high and low ths to add variety and high lvl troops to low player, thus winning wars. Pretty simple. The more you war, the more war wins. How is that skill? How fast you can gain as much loot as possible (even during bad loot season that everyone claims) and upgrade your base, thats more of a skill then your petty war wins. Mass drags for 3 stars, HA what a joke

well, you know this idea clan war ranking system is based on that clan wars has no sense to play now as you said. but if this change happen then clan wars will have meaning to all clans...

[OneAndOnlyBramble]

So if this happened there could be a th 7 only clan that have won all of their wars and then will have to war a clan full of maxed bases, lots of the wars would be unfair

[Ayyyyyema]

So I'm assuming you dont read full posts? If you did youd realize what I'm saying, is non war clans or clans with less often wars(once a month) are NOT considered "bad clans" mainly because of your strange clan ranking system.

And PLEASE dont try to tell me it takes "skill" to win wars. It takes decent use of effective strategies from at least half of your clan. Sorry no skill there. The players add up in war, but when you trophy push, every player is essential and the last few players may be booted for lack of improvement. What "improvement" do you see in your clan members attacks? You can see war progression from last two war attacks. With trophy pushes, you see: CONTINUOUS strategic attack after strategic attack. Lol not just two.

People need to stop acting like wars are SO important, theyre fun. Thats what they were meant to be, fun. Now let's talk about what they are NOW. Until sc changes that, thats all wars are. War wins are SUPER easily worked around, so for now. Im sorry, but your war wins mean NOTHING to me. Other then the fact that you can assemble a diverse clan being that clan war matchup is pretty unfair half the time. If you show me all strong bases in your clan, then you'll get my respect. Other then that, your war wins are almost sad to me for how much time you waste in wars rather then growing as individual players.

Im sorry. I really dont care if the game is called "clash of clans" it doesnt necessarily mean IN WAR. It can mean, in highest ranked clan. Stop using that in your excuse.

[BmooDyy]

So if this happened there could be a th 7 only clan that have won all of their wars and then will have to war a clan full of maxed bases, lots of the wars would be unfair

Everyone would start on an even playing field with 1,000 points. At first all the top clans would be playing some bad clans, but after a while it would become "fair" and clans would get more even match ups. It makes sense though that the more wins and points you have, that the clans would war against better and stronger clans.

[BmooDyy]

So I'm assuming you dont read full posts? If you did youd realize what I'm saying, is non war clans or clans with less often wars(once a month) are NOT considered "bad clans" mainly because of your strange clan ranking system.

And PLEASE dont try to tell me it takes "skill" to win wars. It takes decent use of effective strategies from at least half of your clan. Sorry no skill there. The players add up in war, but when you trophy push, every player is essential and the last few players may be booted for lack of improvement. What "improvement" do you see in your clan members attacks? You can see war progression from last two war attacks. With trophy pushes, you see: CONTINUOUS strategic attack after strategic attack. Lol not just two.

People need to stop acting like wars are SO important, theyre fun. Thats what they were meant to be, fun. Now let's talk about what they are NOW. Until sc changes that, thats all wars are. War wins are SUPER easily worked around, so for now. Im sorry, but your war wins mean NOTHING to me. Other then the fact that you can assemble a diverse clan being that clan war matchup is pretty unfair half the time. If you show me all strong bases in your clan, then you'll get my respect. Other then that, your war wins are almost sad to me for how much time you waste in wars rather then growing as individual players.

Im sorry. I really dont care if the game is called "clash of clans" it doesnt necessarily mean IN WAR. It can mean, in highest ranked clan. Stop using that in your excuse.

To the part I bolded, that sentence right there shows that skill is needed so you are contradicting yourself. Also, if your clan is a "non war" clan then this change wouldn't affect you or your clan mates at all. Please keep my thread as professional as possible so that this idea will at least be considered by Supercell. Thank you.