Originally Posted by Hulkified
This may be an issue for you, but it is not as much of an issue for players with max bases. Clans like Ice Ice Baby!! are much more likely to have fair match ups.
Or you could just add another 10 players, get to 50... and have a more challenging experience....
Reddit Troopers chooses to be very competitive, not just through skill but through "clan control". Add some high level th10 players and you will be more challenged.
A "mmr" system will never happen. Ever.
First off, it would be incredibly difficult because it would need to take into account individual players rather than a clan, since a clan can change members at any time. Failure to take that into account would result in widespread abuse. Secondly, it would have to take into account not just "skill" and wins, but also base levels, which is pretty much impossible to do simultaneously.
This may be frustrating, but again there are easy ways for reddit troopers to remedy this. I wouldn't be surprised if some of those clans see your war wins and automatically give up btw.
There are tens of thousands... probably hundreds of thousands of clans out there, and the vast majority of them are relatively casual. Trying to implement an absurdly complex mmr system for the top .0001% of clans that are having it too easy but aren't going all out as th10s will never happen and expecting it to happen is ridiculous.
Maybe (and i do mean maybe) a MMR system could be implemented, but it would only work for maxed or near maxed th10 bases with a minimum of all inferno walls. You can't have match making ratings effectively without a bracket system, and there is no way to effectively bracket th8s, th9s and most th10s.
if you want to be challenged, then challenge yourself.
skill is impossible to quantify with an algorithm without an equal playing field. You can say Barry Bonds is more "skillful" at baseball than a high schooler I suppose, and therefor a TH10 is more "skillful" than a th8, but since we all know that comparison is ridiculous, you should accept the fact that it would be nearly impossible to calculate skill.
Like i said early, Maybe war leagues that separate TH levels could work, with th10s could have a war league separate from th9s, but beyond that it wouldn't work. They would also have to be a specific clan number for war (45 or 50 probably). And if they did do that, you can be ASSURED that the majority of the best war clans would break up and fracture into th level instead of juking around with their town hall distribution.
