Hopper optional idea, and alternative cc troop options for hoppers!

[Street3]

The draw to the game is making your village your village, and making your clan your clan! OPTIONS to do so can only make the game more addicting please keep this in mind before posting negatively and calling other people name's!!!!!!!

Have a check box in clan edit to allow the donation of troops to hoppers!!! Simply said HOPPERS Welcome will allow clans to still collect experience from hoppers!

If you check to allow hoppers nothing changes! However if you didn't then what happens is this,

If someone joins your clan does not ask for troops they can leave with no penalty!

If someone joins your clan and ask for troops then leaves they lose the troops that were donated! They simply dissapppear no one gets them or gets them back just poof gone!!(This will make the incentive to want to make sure they wish to be in the clan before requesting troops!)

If someone joins your clan and uses them before leaving then they have a 2 hour penalty before they can join another clan including one that allows hoppers!

If someone joins and gets kicked after asking for troops then they lose the troops and gets a 2 hour penalty!

If someone gets kicked and they did not ask for troops then there will not be a penalty!


Alternative for hoppers!
A way for supercell to make money off of this would be to add a button to the clan castle (only those without clan) that would fill the CC by using GEMS! So if you go to your CC where you would normally see your clan mates you will see a button TROOPS FOR GEMS! If they hit the button then they would be taken to a special barracks, each troop will cost the equivalent of GEMS it would take to get them if you were missing the elixir to create them! It would look just like the barracks just GEMS in place of elixir! And it would work the same way to you would have to wait for the troop to be trianed or use more GEMS to speed it up!

I think this would be a good option considering everyone gets free GEMS almost everyday!

Hope you like the idea please post your comment and related ideas!!!!

[JAZZPRIME74]

This is actually a good idea but what if someone's looking for a clan with good troops and request to see what he gets but gets gob?

[Street3]

This is actually a good idea but what if someone's looking for a clan with good troops and request to see what he gets but gets gob?

That is a good question! I would say if the leader won't do nothing about it then it's a bad clan! But I would say a dump option or a filter like others have posted about would solve that!

Maybe if someone donates something you don't want you can press dump and it would send all the donated troops back to the ones who donated and your request would disappear from the chat window!

So it would be like you never asked and gives you the chance to see how seriously the leader takes this kind of transgression! Then you can choose to request again or leave without penalty!

Let me know what you think and I can add it to my thread!

[Street3]

What about the alternative for those that don't want to be in a clan!

[magnor]

That seems like a lot of different scenarios that need to be added to the game just to fix a problem that can also be fixed by changing your clan to 'invite only'. It can also be solved by simply donating archers to someone who just joined. 5 archers is what, 2 and a bit minutes of training time and under 2000 elixir. They leave, you get 5 more XP points, everyones's happy.