Read this

[Zenya]

You guys that keep saying "ruled out"... that doesn't make you sound professionals... and you just don't want any ideas but your own... stop being critics. Just post ideas and not hate on ours.... I wouldn't call you haters fellow clashers. You guys are the reason clash barely ever changes

Don't cry about it. It's to improve the forums. Would you like wolfs that smash through walls and kill the th? or gem mines? of course you would but its to over powered

[zachUVA]

You guys that keep saying "ruled out"... that doesn't make you sound professionals... and you just don't want any ideas but your own... stop being critics. Just post ideas and not hate on ours.... I wouldn't call you haters fellow clashers. You guys are the reason clash barely ever changes

Ok, here's the deal on ruled out ideas:

1. The decision to rule out an idea is exclusively Supercell's. No forumer (including mods) decides what does or doesn't get ruled out.

2. As stated in the newest sticky, threads with ruled out ideas will be deleted from now on. Why? 2 reasons: so that this subforum is no longer cluttered with ideas threads for features that will not be added, and so that people who spam "ruled out" and start pointless arguments over it will no longer be able to up their posts counts with it.

Your basic point is well taken though: this subforum is supposed to be about the ideas, their merits, and critiques/feedback on the ideas. Derailing threads over forum etiquette is not acceptable (that's why we have mods).