Yes, this can work!
No, this idea could never work.
Maybe, but it needs work.
I'm liking this idea as a leader. I voted maybe, because I think multiple claims is a better idea.
The leader, plus Co's should then be able to remove claims. And claims should not prevent people from being able to attack a village, so it's pure informative for the rest of the clan that you would like to attack a certain village.
On the other hand, granting a allow option by a Co\leader for someone claiming a village is also a good option in my opinion.
Hello, and thank you very much for your input here.Originally Posted by glim
I will say that this ability I have outlined in this thread is equipped with the function for leaders AND co-leaders to remove claims.
Now as far as the claiming itself, I see you also do not necessarily agree with the "claim locks in a base until the time limit is reached" part of this idea.
You should know you bring up a good point about having a said "allowance" granted to certain clan members. That is a very good idea you have there that I will strongly consider moving on from here.
Thank you again.
IGN: King | Level: 80 | TH: 9| Clan: NOVA Oz FC |
Come see the next up and coming feature in Clan Wars HERE!
This is probably one of the best ideas I've seen on here!
Thank you very much. Although you should know that no idea is truly perfect, and could always use some massaging. I ask that if you come up with anything you would like to share about base claiming in wars, please do not hesitate.
That goes for everyone as well.
Thanks again.
IGN: King | Level: 80 | TH: 9| Clan: NOVA Oz FC |
Come see the next up and coming feature in Clan Wars HERE!
Yes. But co leaders and leader should be able to call for their clan. Otherwise trolling will be on the next level.
its indeed a good idea. No need to keep bumping it though. SC has it on their list of things they are working on. This list has several things and they are taking them in order of priority as they see it so please just be patient.
in the meantime this is not hard for a leader to manage, many of us do in fact. It just needs the members to be on board to coordinate, not just flying off and hitting stuff without checking.
Where do you find this list? Not in the ideas sticky as far as I have seen. I'd love to see what is next on that list.
In the meantime, yes, there is no dispute that is what we leaders must do. Hands down. I cannot wait for clan wars to become even better in the near future. I feel there a little more that can be done with clan wars, and if this is included into it, I believe many people will be happy. And as I stressed in the very first line, this does not need to be a permanent feature, but just something you can toggle on/off each war very simply.
And for the record, I am not doing anything that is unnecessary in this thread. I am simply respectfully responding to the generous feedback people are giving here, like I am doing now.
IGN: King | Level: 80 | TH: 9| Clan: NOVA Oz FC |
Come see the next up and coming feature in Clan Wars HERE!
As requested
This was posted last April. if you look at each of the updates that took place since then (Q2, Q3, and Q4 of 2014) you can see that they are actively following through on it with something in each update. I too have my pet feature on that list I want to see. But I have to admit that the ones that they did do so far probably were more impactful to the game so I am not stressed that they did not get to mine yet.
Ok, skimmed through the thread as best I could to get the most important info, but may have missed a few things.But I got a simple question... Can this feature seem simple, and self explanatory, to a new person playing this game?
You have a very detailed idea, but the original post is rather long. The only way this idea will have any hope of being used is if it doesn't seem overly complicated to a player. Not saying it cannot have complicated effects. Simple features can have many hidden nuances and effects, and if those effects help gameplay, all the better.
Sure, and I thank you for that.
Ill tell you this, clan wars can be as simple as it gets. You attack in the game, you attack in a war situation. They are two in the same. The difference is not in game play, but strategically who will attack who in a war situation. That being said, I think that the claiming feature is simply an extension off of that strategy.
I agree the post seems long, but I felt I needed to get everything out and explain it to the fullest. Perhaps I have stated too much, and for that I will consider re-writing the initial post.
As far as my believing this to be complicated to new users, the answer is simply no. To select a base of your choice seems simple enough to do. The harder work rests with the leaders of the clan, co-leaders included, who will need to regulate who has claimed what base.
Look for a recreation of the thread by next week.
IGN: King | Level: 80 | TH: 9| Clan: NOVA Oz FC |
Come see the next up and coming feature in Clan Wars HERE!
