Clan Wars: War Base Calling Ability

[X7386]

I don't like this idea.

Player claiming base: permanent claim = so many potential problems.....

Player going inactive, leader forgets to "revoke" and another player is forced to raid much higher or much lower. What if the leader forgets to log on?

What if a player calls and leaves?

What if a player decides to attack a different base than called?

It is also first come, first serve meaning that this will happen:

It will make unfairness to the people who lived in different time zone

[kinganthony]

I don't like this idea.

Player claiming base: permanent claim = so many potential problems.....

Player going inactive, leader forgets to "revoke" and another player is forced to raid much higher or much lower. What if the leader forgets to log on?

What if a player calls and leaves?

What if a player decides to attack a different base than called?

It is also first come, first serve meaning that this will happen:

Thank you for your comment! I appreciate any constructive feedback that will make this idea better. Allow me to clarify some of your concerns.

I'm not sure if your first comment is referring to this idea becoming a permanent function or not. In any case, if you were to see this in game, the leader and co-leaders will have the option on the war search function to enable this feature.

For your second, you must first remember that the leader AND co-leader/s have the ability to revoke claims AT ANY TIME. So the leader forgetting to log on becomes irrelevant. And no one is forced to attack any higher or lower than they would like to.

Third, regarding a player leaving, as previously stated the leader and co-leader/s have the ability to revoke claims at any time.

Fourth, the player's first attack MUST BE YOUR CLAIMED BASE. Additionally, you only get ONE claim per war up until the time limit of the 12th hour of war day.

Fifth, regarding the time zone differential, you have 12 hours of preparation day to get on and claim a base. That is above and beyond the amount of time required to get on the game and get your claim in, regardless of when the war starts your time zone.

Hope this helps you get a better idea

[rwelshjr]

While I agree that some for of calling "Dibs" on a base would be a valuable addition I would prefer something a bit more robust. I posted some details a while back but like most good ideas it quickly ended up on later pages.

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...nagement-ideas

I believe this is on their list of things they are considering for implementation. See the opt in/out threads where I posted that list. You will notice that this is also there.

And yes, I agree with your suggestion.

[kinganthony]

I believe this is on their list of things they are considering for implementation. See the opt in/out threads where I posted that list. You will notice that this is also there.

And yes, I agree with your suggestion.

Yeah that person who you quoted actually made a related thread pertaining to this idea. However, the ideas are both different in their functionality.

Do you mean that Supercell has considered this idea? I haven't seen anything in the ruled out sticky just yet.

And thank you for being a supporter of this function.

[Wokki]

This is why my clan uses Clashcaller.com to claim bases in war

[kinganthony]

This is why my clan uses Clashcaller.com to claim bases in war

That is very interesting.

I took a look at the website, and while it may be a great way to keep tabs of people on a website, I believe that having an in game function such as this would alleviate much confusion for everyone.

What do you think of this idea in this thread, though?

For the time being, however, I would consider using this for my current wars. Thank you for showing that here.

[Theblob123]

I like the idea BUT PLEASE STOP CHANGING FONT COLOR AND FORMAT

[General7100]

I think it will work well if they dont claim it and no one else can attack it.

Just claim it while the other members of the war can attack it as well.

Other members will not attack it if it just says "Claimed by _____" because they would be notified.

[Drewbiedoo]

Souldnt number 1 take number 1,etc,etc... Lol

[kinganthony]

I like the idea BUT PLEASE STOP CHANGING FONT COLOR AND FORMAT

Hello, and thank you for your feedback. My apologies, but I simply did not want a plain, boring look to my thread.

I think it will work well if they dont claim it and no one else can attack it.

Just claim it while the other members of the war can attack it as well.

Other members will not attack it if it just says "Claimed by _____" because they would be notified.

Thanks for your feedback here. I see what you are trying to say, you would like to have a claim feature, without the part that locks it for a time limit.

Always an option to consider, but the advantage to this is there is more of a structure to it, and not as much as an informal feel to it.

Souldnt number 1 take number 1,etc,etc... Lol

Ah, that would make sense. However anyone who has been through a clan war (let alone has led one) will tell you that for the most part, and I stress here not in all cases, people multiple levels higher or lower attack much higher and lower than their level. Thus, ruining their chances at more stars, etc.