Clan War, Wins Achievement Bonus for Entire clan

[josan]

Give the entire clan a reward for winning a certain # of wins such as 25, 50, 100, 250 clan war wins. Let there be a winning bonus prize that can be divided by the entire members of the clan for achieving those milestone. The bonus can be something like (# of members x 200,000) of gold and elixir. These achievement bonus can be divided by the members of the clan according to their clan seniority. So most senior member would get the most bonus reward (been in clan the longest, so helped get most of those wins) while new member receive very little on nothing at all, since they are new.
The Achievement bonus would increase according to the number of clan war wins the clan has achieved.

[HeavensFace]

hum, nice idea, it would encourage players to participate more in wars.

[luk3namop]

The problem with this idea is that people occasionally join and leave a clan, maybe it would just have to be a personal achievement for number of CW wins?

[Phyxios]

There could always be a required set time in the clan to get the achievement, it would prevent clan hopping, but I think it'd be better for it to be a personal achievement, so its more fair.

[josan]

The problem with this idea is that people occasionally join and leave a clan, maybe it would just have to be a personal achievement for number of CW wins?

Why is this a problem. This idea is to reward those who have stayed loyal to the clan longer, and have helped the clan the most to attain such achievement and thus receiving larger portion of the reward. If you, as you put it occasionally join and leaves the clan, How does it help the clan? it makes it more fragmented. The idea is to maintain the clan together as much and as long as is possible. By making the reward increase according with how long you been in the clan, wouldn't make some people stay with the clan longer?

[Phyxios]

Why is this a problem. This idea is to reward those who have stayed loyal to the clan longer, and have helped the clan the most to attain such achievement and thus receiving larger portion of the reward. If you, as you put it occasionally join and leaves the clan, How does it help the clan? it makes it more fragmented. The idea is to maintain the clan together as much and as long as is possible. By making the reward increase according with how long you been in the clan, wouldn't make some people stay with the clan longer?

what about the loyal people who get kicked because they went camping or out of town for a weekend/week and missed a war?

the point is, that its not fair.

[HeavensFace]

what about the loyal people who get kicked because they went camping or out of town for a weekend/week and missed a war?

the point is, that its not fair.

maybe it should be by rank...

[josan]

what about the loyal people who get kicked because they went camping or out of town for a weekend/week and missed a war?

the point is, that its not fair.

This can be easily solve by keeping track of the number of "Service" hours you have with particular clan. SO if you get kicked out for being inactive when you resume your clan membership the accumulated time on this clan will still be there.