New clan rank - War Minister!

[devil9394]

There are so many things related to clan wars which are not under the control of the team, so I want to suggest a new clan rank: War Minister.
A clan should only be able to have maximum 2 War Ministers at a time, two players who take the responsability of managing the war. This new rank should have more permissions than the other ranks don't have (except for the Leader):

1. They should be able to choose who participates in the wars before they hit the "Start War" button; obviously if they choose for example 33 members, only the top 30 will participate.
Advantage: This will help those clans who have members in vacation or are temporarily unfit for war to always fight their best in wars.

2. They should be able to remove troops from the clans inside a war for the other members as well (now everybody only has access to his own clan castle troops insde war base).
Advantage: Troops donated by mistake can easier and faster be removed from the members and be replaced with something more adequate. In this way, you will not have to wait for that member to log in and inform him to remove the troops, but the War Minister(s)/Leader can do it for him.

Both of these new permissions should be given to the two War Ministers as well as for the Leader. The two suggestions may seem not so important but they would change and help the clan wars.

Additional restrictions to the War Ministers:
1. They can not ban more than 20% of the clan members for the wars; this will prevent exaggerated number of bans in the wars. (The percentage can be reduced if needed).
2. They can not ban the Leader from participating in the war, the Leader should remain the supreme rank.

Thanks for reading and I am waiting for opinions.

[Jessi810]

The idea is great! The only one I don't like is choosing a member who will go to war. This could be solved by kicking the member then sending him/her an invite if the member can't participate in war. Just a suggestion.

[Sirix]

It sounds troublesome to kick and reinvite people and less loyal members would not return, not that it's a bad thing necessarily

[arieoreos]

There are so many things related to clan wars which are not under the control of the team, so I want to suggest a new clan rank: War Minister.
A clan should only be able to have maximum 2 War Ministers at a time, two players who take the responsability of managing the war. This new rank should have more permissions than the other ranks don't have (except for the Leader):

1. They should be able to choose who participates in the wars before they hit the "Start War" button; obviously if they choose for example 33 members, only the top 30 will participate.
Advantage: This will help those clans who have members in vacation or are temporarily unfit for war to always fight their best in wars.

2. They should be able to remove troops from the clans inside a war for the other members as well (now everybody only has access to his own clan castle troops insde war base).
Advantage: Troops donated by mistake can easier and faster be removed from the members and be replaced with something more adequate. In this way, you will not have to wait for that member to log in and inform him to remove the troops, but the War Minister(s)/Leader can do it for him.

Both of these new permissions should be given to the two War Ministers as well as for the Leader. The two suggestions may seem not so important but they would change and help the clan wars.

Additional restrictions to the War Ministers:
1. They can not ban more than 20% of the clan members for the wars; this will prevent exaggerated number of bans in the wars. (The percentage can be reduced if needed).
2. They can not ban the Leader from participating in the war, the Leader should remain the supreme rank.

Thanks for reading and I am waiting for opinions.

you would do great as an idea maker, just saying. you are THE BEST idea maker/detail writer i have seen who is less than a week in the forums. and even compared to all people in the forums, you rank pretty far above average!

i think that is enough explaining on my opinion.

[devil9394]

The idea is great! The only one I don't like is choosing a member who will go to war. This could be solved by kicking the member then sending him/her an invite if the member can't participate in war. Just a suggestion.

Right now in my clan we are doing something similar (since we don't have any other option..): we kick the member and send him to the 'academy', a secondary clan created for this purpose and maintained by a chosen player. However, I don't know how this looks to you, but to me it is quite annoying sometimes.

Tomorrow I will also go in a trip for 6 days in the mountains (doubt will find any internet there), what should I do? quit the clan and join back after 6 days? During summer now there are a lot of people in vacation.

This leaving, coming back, leaving.. how does such a clan look to you? because to me it looks really bad. Instead, if I could simply ban somebody from the war then that would be different, players wouldn't have to juggle between clans and would just remain in the main one until their vacation is over.

you would do great as an idea maker, just saying. you are THE BEST idea maker/detail writer i have seen who is less than a week in the forums. and even compared to all people in the forums, you rank pretty far above average!

i think that is enough explaining on my opinion.

Thanks man, I really appreciate it.