Clan war whitelist option (Opt In/Out of War)

[iceageg]

There is no downside to this being added, great idea.

Actually there are. Whether you agree with them or not you should make sure you brush up on them so you know what negatives to expect if it gets implemented.

[Satse]

But then the leader Will only chose the best people, and the clanwar Will be unfair. Now if you Search clanwar for example 10vs10 you Will see both clans have for example about 4000 points how you fond another clan in clanwar is based on how much points your clan has. so no, for this update there has to be much changee in coc

[iceageg]

But then the leader Will only chose the best people, and the clanwar Will be unfair. Now if you Search clanwar for example 10vs10 you Will see both clans have for example about 4000 points how you fond another clan in clanwar is based on how much points your clan has. so no, for this update there has to be much changee in coc

As a fellow opponent to this idea I don't see this argument as one of the problems. It would be fairly easy using the current match making system to balance that part out. However, a clan picking it's 10 weakest players, then pumping them full of max level troops to attack with will make it impossible to create even match-ups.

[Phyxios]

But then the leader Will only chose the best people, and the clanwar Will be unfair. Now if you Search clanwar for example 10vs10 you Will see both clans have for example about 4000 points how you fond another clan in clanwar is based on how much points your clan has. so no, for this update there has to be much changee in coc

Currently If the leader doesn't want you in the war he will/could just kick you before hand, this is not an issue with this system.

[Ztyler99]

I don't know if I like this idea or not. What if the person wants to attack in the war but don't get on during prep day to say "yes I want to" and click the little box. I think that all the boxes should be checked saying everybody will then they can uncheck it if they don't want to. That way people don't miss out on the war that they wanted to fight in. Another thing I am wondering is, when would this take place. Would people check yes or no before the war search starts? Because you can't have a prep day for 40v40 war then 20 people say no. They'd have to be able to click the box saying they don't want to before clan war search even starts. Make since? I like the idea but it needs a little more explaining.

[Phyxios]

I don't know if I like this idea or not. What if the person wants to attack in the war but don't get on during prep day to say "yes I want to" and click the little box. I think that all the boxes should be checked saying everybody will then they can uncheck it if they don't want to. That way people don't miss out on the war that they wanted to fight in. Another thing I am wondering is, when would this take place. Would people check yes or no before the war search starts? Because you can't have a prep day for 40v40 war then 20 people say no. They'd have to be able to click the box saying they don't want to before clan war search even starts. Make since? I like the idea but it needs a little more explaining.

This is before they can even search for a war.

[Spudsicles]

I don't know if I like this idea or not. What if the person wants to attack in the war but don't get on during prep day to say "yes I want to" and click the little box. I think that all the boxes should be checked saying everybody will then they can uncheck it if they don't want to. That way people don't miss out on the war that they wanted to fight in. Another thing I am wondering is, when would this take place. Would people check yes or no before the war search starts? Because you can't have a prep day for 40v40 war then 20 people say no. They'd have to be able to click the box saying they don't want to before clan war search even starts. Make since? I like the idea but it needs a little more explaining.

This has to happen before the Leader/Co-Leader even starts the war.

Basically they should implement a check list where the members will check a box if they would like in the next war. Then the leader can go in and see who wants in and who doesn't, and then he can choose the members that will be active in the war based on who checked the box. He will then choose the correct amount of members needed to start a war (10, 15, etc). He obviously can choose members that didn't check the box if he needs to fill in a gap to make a war team.

[Phyxios]

This has to happen before the Leader/Co-Leader even starts the war.

Basically they should implement a check list where the members will check a box if they would like in the next war. Then the leader can go in and see who wants in and who doesn't, and then he can choose the members that will be active in the war based on who checked the box. He will then choose the correct amount of members needed to start a war (10, 15, etc). He obviously can choose members that didn't check the box if he needs to fill in a gap to make a war team.

pretty much this..

[Ztyler99]

This has to happen before the Leader/Co-Leader even starts the war.

Basically they should implement a check list where the members will check a box if they would like in the next war. Then the leader can go in and see who wants in and who doesn't, and then he can choose the members that will be active in the war based on who checked the box. He will then choose the correct amount of members needed to start a war (10, 15, etc). He obviously can choose members that didn't check the box if he needs to fill in a gap to make a war team.

Okay. That would make since. So preventing the leader to choose whoever he/she wants, do all the people with checked boxes attack automatically or can to the leader say to somebody that wants to go to war that they can't? Because if the leader or co leader choses who attacks. I feel like that would lead to conflict.

I don't like it if the leader and/or co leader choses to attack. I would like it better if everybody that said yes goes to war and if u need to fill more spots then you can pick some of the ppl who wanted out knowing that they may not attack.

[Ricven]

Me and my clan have been experiencing this a lot. Just the last war we were in we had a guy on a cruise and had no cell service.

We wound up losing because he was unable to attack and others just were not attacking.

Bad thing is some clans have people within them that people are friends and know each other in real life. It is not fair to them because they do not want to attack in a war for what ever the reason to be forced to just because they want to be with a friend in a clan.

It seems that they could implement an opt in or out of war option for people and then the war would be based on how many people opted in. So for example if a clan of 50 people on have 35 of the 50 opt in for the war then the clan would be placed in a 35 vs 35 person war. I was thinking it could simply be a setting in the settings side that u could click that says opt in for war and unless you manually change it, then you will never go to war.

The rewards would not be as great as the higher of course, but now we are not being forced to kick friends out for not wanting to attack in wars. This is a great game and some just like the regular multiplayer aspect of gaming with no wars. However clans are being punished and usually losing because people refuse to attack.

I hope this option can be implemented into the game, because it will definitely make the game more fun for the ones who wish to war all the time and also for those who do not want to be forced into the war.

Another issue is some of the lower people don't feel that there ready for the war bc of lack of practice or they just want to build up their base more by farming before going and getting involved in a war.

Ric