Three Ideas for COC that would make it much more enjoyable!!

[KingOdy]

1. Clan wars, give us xp when we donate to clan castles. When I am stocking my clans clan castles for my team, it can get expensive. For instance, if I stocked my clan with 49 max dragons, thats over 2 million elixir. Besides a clan win (if we do), that doesn't benefit me at all. Instead of getting 1,225 experience points and adding to my Friend in Need achievement, it does nothing.

2. Filling Clan Castles in War -> option for only Co-leaders and Leaders to do so.

3. This one is a little bit iffy but I think would encourage better activity; Leaders can check profile for amount of war raids not completed. If a player leaves a clan or does not do their war raids, it will add to the number (however if a player is kicked before they can war raid, it will not show up on their profile).

The amount of players that leave during clan wars is very frustrating and there needs to be something done about it.


Thoughts?

[Aleksander]

1. Very easy to exploit. Make barbarians, donate them, get exp, friend dumps them, rinse and repeat

2. CC is for the whole clan and you can always dump the troops you don't like but this is not an entirely bad idea

3. Is this like for the player's entire CoC-career? Because if it is this would be very bad news for many people that are just not that into wars and then try to join new clan. A bit iffy indeed

[Dalibor]

If u ask me,it would be more COOL if they would make War Chat,so we could chat with our enemies and make more fire btw us...But,noone is asking to me

[Ninja352]

If u ask me,it would be more COOL if they would make War Chat,so we could chat with our enemies and make more fire btw us...But,noone is asking to me

That was completely off topic and a completely seperate request. Many people have already made threads for that idea.

To the OP, number 1 won't happen, I don't like number 2 since some of my higher lvl members are not co or even elder, and I don't like number 3 for the same reason Aleksander pointed out.

[KingOdy]

Well thats an easy fix to #1.. person can only donate once to each clan castle.

You guys are brutal with your responses, its as if nobody wants the game to change.

[noobworldorderREP]

i think when you donate to CC during a war it should count toward donation count and give xp

[dahimi]

Well thats an easy fix to #1.. person can only donate once to each clan castle.

How exactly does getting XP, which is largely worthless, worth the loss of freedom to donate to clan members as often as you wish? You're basically losing something that has value in exchange for something that doesn't.

That doesn't seem like a bad trade off to you?

Also, doesn't this somewhat contradict #2 (which is also unnecessary because troops can be dropped). You're going to have a hard time filling clan castles if only a couple in the clan can donate and you can only donate to folks once.

You guys are brutal with your responses, its as if nobody wants the game to change.

Just because we don't like your changes doesn't mean we don't like all changes.

Even you say #3 is iffy. SC is not going to mark people with a permanent record of doing things which are perfectly legal in game that you don't like. It's also pretty fixable with decent clan management and a good application process.

Quit letting people in with no application process and then going to war immediately after.

[ChiefJoshuaCOC]

just give giants to everyone without them knowing and they can trash them

[KingOdy]

How exactly does getting XP, which is largely worthless, worth the loss of freedom to donate to clan members as often as you wish? You're basically losing something that has value in exchange for something that doesn't.

That doesn't seem like a bad trade off to you?

I am not quite sure you understand what we are talking about (perhaps I worded my comment wrong?).

Clan Castles in War, as in -- defence. Why would you want/need to donate to a members clan castle more than once every war?

[Joshokitty]

Cool ideas but I have some thoughts...

1. I think this is cool but it is not anyone's problem but yours. If you want to donate maxed dragons, that is your choice. No one will stop you and it's not like anyone will force you to donate dragons either.

2. Why.. just why? I like donations to be open to everyone. If it means so much to you, the new updates have a feature where you can dismiss troops unwanted for yourself.

3. This is bad reputation? No. I do not like this because it is just what some people do. If they choose to hop, let them. Uncomplete war raids can be checked in the Clan War statistics anyway. If the person leaves, whatever. It may be annoying but adding a bad reputation does not help anyone.