Clan War Update - Don't allow people to leave once war has started

[jammer0816]

I know every clan faces this issue and in some cases, it can cost a win. Granted....you can't make someone attack during war of course but the incentive would be there that since you're in it, you win...you get the loot...then you leave.

So...with that....the war starts, no one can leave the clan until the war if over. if someone tries to leave, give them a message stating something like "you can't leave a war in progress". Right after the war ends, the person will be removed from the clan. Regardless if they attack or not.

Thanks for listening.

[00Neel]

I know every clan faces this issue and in some cases, it can cost a win. Granted....you can't make someone attack during war of course but the incentive would be there that since you're in it, you win...you get the loot...then you leave.

So...with that....the war starts, no one can leave the clan until the war if over. if someone tries to leave, give them a message stating something like "you can't leave a war in progress". Right after the war ends, the person will be removed from the clan. Regardless if they attack or not.

Thanks for listening.

The idea is swell

[vekool]

I second this.

[HectikWalnut]

What if they are going between family clans??? Think About Those Kinda Details. Otherwise good idea!

[iceageg]

It is a horrible idea to force somebody to stay in a clan they don't want to be in.

[jammer0816]

It is a horrible idea to force somebody to stay in a clan they don't want to be in.

You're missing the point here. They aren't being forced to stay at all. As soon as the war is over...they automatically are dispelled from the clan as they wished.

The problem many clans face are people joining for war and then leaving which basically is a type of sabotage if you ask me. But as I mentioned earlier, you can't make them battle, they just won't be able to leave during an active war. Maybe doing it this way could be a little bit of an incentive for them to battle and get any loot they win and then they're gone.

No harm, no foul. Could be a win win for everyone. Could be ....

[iceageg]

You're missing the point here. They aren't being forced to stay at all. As soon as the war is over...they automatically are dispelled from the clan as they wished.

The problem many clans face are people joining for war and then leaving which basically is a type of sabotage if you ask me. But as I mentioned earlier, you can't make them battle, they just won't be able to leave during an active war. Maybe doing it this way could be a little bit of an incentive for them to battle and get any loot they win and then they're gone.

No harm, no foul. Could be a win win for everyone. Could be ....

Forcing them to stay in a clan they don't want to be in for up to 48 hours. I guarantee you they won't participate in the war if they are trying to leave. Zero attacks from them either way. If you force them to stay it will just end up being some trivial argument in clan chat. Drama that nobody wants or benefits from. Forcing people to stay in a clan for any period of time is a horrible idea.

[jammer0816]

all good. i still disagree with your comment but do understand.

this still should be something to be addressed some how. i mean mercy. our last three wars we had 3-4 people leave right after the war started. they got their troops and left. it's another form of clan hopping and it costs not only you but the clan as well.

end the hopping...clear the clan castle if you leave a clan. simple.

[Bman151995]

I agree with the o.p. I was also thinking that there should be something like a clan world war? That probably doesn't make sense but let me explain. So instead of a single clan versus another clan, there should be alliances so it can be 2v2 or 3v3. Also, have a war chat tab so that people in the war can communicate better. I know that we have lost 2/3 of our wars due to people leaving. So we should either be able to choose who fights, or replace people if they leave. I know this is a lot to ask, but thank you all for listening.

[ClashySquill]

Lets say I'm just looking for a good clan, then I join this clan and they immedietly start a war, but then I discover they suck at wars, what, now I'm stuck in a crappy clan for 2 days