War matching I think needs work

[thomasandkulas]

you cry too much.. its just a game.. accept reality..

[Fusi0n]

It's a problem and there's no getting around that. We as users of this content can ask for remediation to make it more appealing and playable.

[Astar]

Oh just got matched up with a clan we are now going to thrash!! Seems fair...

[cjm1991]

The short and sweet answer, the system isnt fair. Our last war we were matched against a clan with 20+ players with maxed everything including walls/heros while only have 1 player with just max heros(not even walls). Their bottom player had a base equal to our top 15 in a 45 vs 45.. Something needs to be done.

[Bertold]

I totally agree that it isn't fair. My clan is just about to loose its fourth war in a row. This time we were matched against a clan with 3 TH10 and 5 TH9 while our clan has ZERO TH10 and four TH9. People in my clan are pretty frustrated because of this.

While there are many threads complaining about CW matching, I chose this one to report my problem because here we seem to have a good discussion about the reasons. My thoughts:

- I also think that maxing base before TH upgrade may have negative effect. In my clan we are patient and go very mature before we upgrade.

- Same applies to walls. We have spent many many millions on our walls, while enemy clan seems to having spent less on walls but more on town halls, wizard towers and x-bows. Now, if let's say 3 million spent on walls may count the same as 3 million spent on an x-bow, then good night...

- We are 25 members only. As suggested earlier, this could lead to less possible matches, while this wouldn't have to be if they would just let the algorithm run longer.

- There had been better matches earlier this year, just after CW was introduced. Bad matching only occured within the last 2 months. Either we have been just unlucky, or an "adjustment" in the matching system has come with one of the last updates, which seems to be to the disadvantage of clans like mine.

I really hope that SC will improve matchmaking soon, or at least give some hints what to care about when going to war. Otherwise my clan may brake apart soon...

[Astar]

Your thoughts now Tinkerbell???

[Glaciesvir]

In the end, almost all bases above their #10 were left unattacked because 7 of our th9 didn't stand a chance against inferno bases.

Couple thing that you might consider based on my experience with the game and clan wars. Th10 getting three starred is a very rare thing so when attacking a th10 one star is gold and two stars is basicly maximum performance. Below th10 the expectations is that three stars are what matters.

When you consider the first point it opens up the path for th9's to get one star from a th10 and depending of base layout even two stars on occasion.This is not that much different for many th10's that lack a maxed gowiwi/gowipe and /or skills to use it.

[JtB]

Attachment 54707So this is the enemy clan #13 Attachment 54708and this our #13

You're telling me this is a even match?

You cant just go by one base and claim the war isnt fair.

[Fusi0n]

The only big difference is that they have more than twice our lvl 100+. Activity level needs to play a factor for sure, I for one don't like easy matches. We just beat an inactive clan 94-15. Their attacks were horrid, enough said.

SC needs to collect data on activity, of course used for the sole purpose of clan war matchups.

[JtB]

Couple thing that you might consider based on my experience with the game and clan wars. Th10 getting three starred is a very rare thing so when attacking a th10 one star is gold and two stars is basicly maximum performance. Below th10 the expectations is that three stars are what matters.

When you consider the first point it opens up the path for th9's to get one star from a th10 and depending of base layout even two stars on occasion.This is not that much different for many th10's that lack a maxed gowiwi/gowipe and /or skills to use it.

Premie town hall 10's get 3 starred all of the times in wars, they are so easy to beat. Town hall level doesnt matter, its the development of the defenses and the level of the attacking troops, plus the skill with which they are used.