I have a similar impression too sometimesOriginally Posted by Clasking
This idea rocks!
This idea is good but could use some work
This idea is not good!
I can't read!
I have a similar impression too sometimes
Good general idea I think it would have to be shorter though, having a war that last like 5-6 days is too long. Tournaments of 8 clans would be best and probably make better matches. Also in any setup the tournament rules should be each clan member gets 1 attack only. This would keep it very competitive by not allowing "base scouting", it would also speed up the tournament. There also needs to be a new system idea behind tournaments, it can't be just to get more loot, it would need a new ranking system of sorts and greater clan perks and such.
Clan Wars Season Pass Tournaments
I have an idea about clan wars tournament. We can have a ranking system for clans per season just like their trophy count, but this time for promoting clan wars, clans would be ranked by their winnings in clan wars they had in a season. Of course, there should be a multiplier for clan war with more participating members, in other words, a 50vs50 war win should have more points than a 40vs40 and so on. In addition to the current rankings, there can be a local and global ranking list for clans based on their obtained scores in clan wars. In the end of season, top clans, might be awarded some gems or resources.
Great idea, I actually stumbled upon this when coming over here to suggest something similar. Also tought about a tournament, but a competition would also be great, so that every clan gets to battle eachother. 2 pointes for a win, maybe make draws possible (1point), and loss obviously 0 points. Would take some time, but for clans who are constantly in battle it wouldn't be a problem. Also you'd need less clans to get the same number of fights, ruling out the matchup problem, of at least improving it. I know this idea isn't worked out nearly as well as the thread starter's, but might be a nice inspiration for an idea that may be concidered by SC. It's basicly the same but a league instead of a tournament. Didn't read this entire topic so I'm sorry if someone else already came up with this.
Grt idea needs to be implemented right away...!!
TH Cap to Solve Match Making
The biggest issue you've got is the match making. I think a TH cap would fix that so that when you select a Tournament you also select the cap level you'd like to compete at. The cap would limit your hero level, troop level and defence level to the appropriate TH level. Match making simply becomes a numbers game, you need the correct amount of clans interested in the same tournament type. If you select clan members with defences and troops below the cap that's your choice but it has no effect on the matching.
This would require a third base layout tab to put your tournament villages. Would create a bit of a mess around troop training as well which I'm not sure how exactly to solve but at the moment I would suggest that it is done from the tournament screen and they go into the camps there but still training from your barracks queues and village resources. CC donations would also be capped with troops only available at higher TH levels capped at lvl1. Donation refund would include the lost resources for the level drop.
I believe this offers the competitive players the perfect arena to test their skills as nobody would have a tech advantage. Also they could shackle themselves at past TH levels to see if they can remember how to do it. Probably TH9 up only maybe down as far as TH7 just depends where the threshold is between everyone being 3 starred for a draw and there actually being a chance to win.
/signed and pls implement it now!haba
Dear Staffs of CoC, This idea is good, even at a time of definitive ban, this gladden many players to continue playing now.
Think this.
The bonus for 1/2/3/4 places should be bigger.(you just won four wars in a row, each getting harder and you only get 15% more...) Clan castles also cant hold enough loot for four war wins. Clans that lose early would be waiting a while. Players might leave at any time, so its risky. Overall, this idea is pretty buggy.
I think this is a great idea and needs to be brought on as the game is losing interest for a lot of people, especially those maxed Th11 now.
In terms of the issue of time frame - you could have different sized tournaments of course; for example a 4 clan tournament would only be 2 semi finals and a 3rd place playoff....so it's only 2 back to back wars allowing clans the loot could be scaled accordingly too.
like wise you could have an 8 clan tournament which would be 3 wars max.......
But overall great idea and I say yes, yes, yes do it supercell, please do it!!!!
Posting Permissions
