View Poll Results: This Base is

Voters
493. You may not vote on this poll
  • no good i can easily 3 star this base.

    113 22.92%
  • no good i can easily 2 star this base.

    164 33.27%
  • just ok it frequently gives up 1 star.

    84 17.04%
  • awesome it only gives up 1 star.

    71 14.40%
  • dont bother posting war bases again, you failed.

    13 2.64%
  • awesome please keep posting logs and possibly updates.

    52 10.55%
  • ok, but make a better one that isnt just for suckers.

    45 9.13%
Multiple Choice Poll.
Page 1 of 32 12311 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 314

Thread: Th9 Clan Wars Base "Sucker Punch"

  1. #1
    Pro Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    Erie, PA
    Posts
    710

    Th9 Clan Wars Base "Sucker Punch"

    The base i proudly name "sucker punch" because looks noobish in design, yet knocks most people on thier ♥♥♥.

    This base works well for developed townhall 9's, however after replies of others its also effective for new th9's who had respectable defensive upgrades.


    Current design. Adjusted walls to seperate Air Towers slightly and adjusted troop pathing for spring traps. The Air Bombs and Mines were also moved to better defend against the new LavaDog. This was done to help against hogs and air attacks. 9/16/2014




    How well does this base perform against specific troop compisitions?


    Ground Attacks

    GoWiPe
    This attacking composition is deadly to the "Sucker Punch" if used by good attackers. I have tweeked the base enough to stop suckers from 3 starring it, however you will have to deal with the common 2 star losses
    How many times has this base been hit by GoWiPe? 1
    On average how many stars? (2 stars/1 battle) = 2

    GoWiWiPe
    This attacking composition is almost as deadly to the "Sucker Punch" if used by good attackers as GoWiPe. I have tweeked the base enough to stop suckers from 3 starring it, however you will have to deal with the common 1 or 2 star losses.
    How many times has this base been hit by GoWiWi? 2
    On average how many stars? (1 stars/2 battles) = 0.5

    GoWiWi
    This attacking composition should be deadly to the "Sucker Punch" if used by good attackers, but it is not. I have tweeked the base enough to stop suckers from 1 or 2 starring it.
    How many times has this base been hit by GoWiWi? 9
    On average how many stars? (8 stars/9 battles) = 0.888

    Giant . . .
    With this attacking composition at best you can hope for is 1 star, it really just destroys giants.
    How many times has this base been hit by Giant based compisitions? 5
    On average how many stars? (4 stars/5 battles) = 0.8

    Valk . . .
    Epic fail for this composition "Sucker Punch" cripples the valkeries ability to hit multiple buildings.
    How many times has this base been hit by Valk based compisitions? 1
    On average how many stars? Zero

    Mass Hog
    This attacking composition could be deadly to the "Sucker Punch" if used by good attackers. I have a variation to defend againt them, however thier are plenty of hog suckers that fall short of even getting 1 star on either version. I personally would stick with the current version unless you get hogged often.
    How many times has this base been hogged? 5
    On average how many stars? (6 stars/8 battles) = 0.75

    Air Attacks

    Mass Dragon
    This attacking composition fails to defeat the "Sucker Punch" more often than not. Reguardless of deployment it will keep attackers from getting more than 1 star.
    How many times has this base been draggoned? 1
    On average how many stars? 1

    Ballonian
    This base is excelent in defending against ballonian, the townhall is surrounded by anti air towers. One great thing archer queen it will actually lure minions away from hitting the Townhall.
    How many times has this base been hit by Ballonian? 1
    On average how many stars? 1

    Dragloonion
    Slightly better than the mass dragon attack, but this attack also fails to defeat the "Sucker Punch" more ofthen than not. A skilled attacker with the right deployment has a better chance to 2 or 3 star this base.
    How many times has this base been hit by Dragloonian? 1
    On average how many stars? 1

    LaDragon
    This attacking composition might be deadly to the "Sucker Punch" if used by good attackers. LavaDogs are are new to the game so time will tell.
    How many times has this base LaDragoned? 1
    On average how many stars? 2


    Mixed Attacks

    HoLoWiWi
    This attacking composition is deadly to the "Sucker Punch" working on a fix, but realistically you will have to deal with loosing stars to good attackers.
    How many times has this base been attacked by HoLoWiWi ? zero
    On average how many stars?
    zero


    War Statistics
    I will be adding logs from every battle of every war to keep the integrity of the war statistics.

    War | Battles | Stars
    01 | 4 | 1
    02 | 3 | 1
    03 | 2 | 0
    04 | 2 | 1
    05 | 2 | 1
    06 | 1 | 2
    07 | 2 | 2
    08 | 7 | 1
    09 | 2 | 2
    10 | 2 | 1
    11 | 1 | 2
    12 | 1 | 2
    13 | 1 | 2
    ________
    13|30| 18 (totals)

    Star Equation, to find the average stars per war.

    3/((total wars*3)/(total stars))
    3/((13*3)/(18))= 1.385
    What does this mean? On average you might only loose 1 star per war, so that is good.

    Base Effectiveness Equation, to find how well your base works in wars.

    ((total battles*3)-(total stars))/(total wars) =
    ((30*3)-(18))/(13) = 5.5
    What does this mean? On average you are costing your enemy 5 stars per war, so that is very good.

    Original design for wars 1-5


    Updated design for wars 5-7.




    Variation for Mass Hog attacks





    Last edited by Natesmiles; September 23rd, 2014 at 10:21 PM.

  2. #2
    Pro Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    Erie, PA
    Posts
    710

    War Logs

    War Stats


    Replay 1/4 of a 1 star loss.


    Replay 2/4 of defensive win.


    Replay 3/4 of defensive win.


    Replay 4/4 of defensive win.
    Last edited by Natesmiles; July 13th, 2014 at 07:11 PM.

  3. #3
    Centennial Club
    Join Date
    Jun 2014
    Location
    Tennessee
    Posts
    105
    First two attack looks the same or it just me ?

  4. #4
    Senior Member Porkloin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Location
    Atlanta, Georgia, US
    Posts
    388
    Nate, how about a non-dark picture of the base before it gets attacked?

    I looked at your non-war base, and it seems pretty stout.

  5. #5
    Pro Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    Erie, PA
    Posts
    710
    Quote Originally Posted by Lordkiat View Post
    First two attack looks the same or it just me ?
    You are correct, fixed it. Doing it all on a IPhone is not that easy.
    Natesmiles a valued member NIGHTBREED !!!
    SuckerPunch
    an epic war base.
    Temptation a trophy base that will intice people to hit you and fail.
    The Offering V9.2 a farming base for maxed out towhall 9's who dont need to protect elixir.

  6. #6
    Pro Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    Erie, PA
    Posts
    710
    Quote Originally Posted by Porkloin View Post
    Nate, how about a non-dark picture of the base before it gets attacked?

    I looked at your non-war base, and it seems pretty stout.
    Opps sorry, again iphone issues. I have another war log to post as well.
    Natesmiles a valued member NIGHTBREED !!!
    SuckerPunch
    an epic war base.
    Temptation a trophy base that will intice people to hit you and fail.
    The Offering V9.2 a farming base for maxed out towhall 9's who dont need to protect elixir.

  7. #7
    Centennial Club
    Join Date
    Jun 2014
    Location
    Tennessee
    Posts
    105
    If someone rage balloon from bottom and when they all drop on all four of the telsa ur townhall is gone

  8. #8
    Pro Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    Erie, PA
    Posts
    710
    Possibly, the ballon with heal and rage failed horribly from the bottom.
    Natesmiles a valued member NIGHTBREED !!!
    SuckerPunch
    an epic war base.
    Temptation a trophy base that will intice people to hit you and fail.
    The Offering V9.2 a farming base for maxed out towhall 9's who dont need to protect elixir.

  9. #9
    Senior Member tomasaki's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    203
    That balloon attack came from the west, not south.

    Rage Balloon or Gowiwi from the bottom can easily get 2stars.

    Clan name: XG
    Username: oti
    TH10

  10. #10
    Pro Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    Erie, PA
    Posts
    710
    War Stats #2


    Replay of defensive win 46%


    Replay of 1 star loss 42%


    Replay of defensive win 48%



    As you can see this base gets attacked frequently in clanwars, and most people bring the wrong troops to tackle this base.

    Even though they get to watch thier fellow clan mates fail, fail, fail, and fail again.

    Two 1 star loss in each war after getting hit 7 times is pretty good, right?
    Natesmiles a valued member NIGHTBREED !!!
    SuckerPunch
    an epic war base.
    Temptation a trophy base that will intice people to hit you and fail.
    The Offering V9.2 a farming base for maxed out towhall 9's who dont need to protect elixir.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •