Sister/Feeder Clans (Edited)

[toggle57]

Because I feel that too many clans linked to only one Main Clan can only lead to disaster with organization.

But thats just a FEELING you have based on what exactly?

Seems like a silly limitation to me... (but then thats my feeling).

[Ztyler99]

I REALLY want linkage of sister/feeder clans BUT

I think you have gone WAAAAY over the top designing a "solution"

The basic need here (as i see it) is to provide simple links between clans so that they can be centrally administered.

1. No need for people to move between these clans to manage them. Leave em where they are. A simple clan family chat tab where clan management can administer all clans in the family is all that is required. Of course transfers are certainly possible but the existing invite system could just be used.

2. No need to mess with clan wars. Just leave them as independent clans and let them fight as usual with the people that are actually physically in each clan.

3. No need for additional clan management roles. Leader continues to be leader except that he now controls all clans in the family. co-leaders and elders would be physically present in each clans and separate from each other in terms of their admin rights.

Honestly I think its best when people just explain what the problem is rather than try and come up with a specific solution. Trust the guys at supercell with that.

I totally disagree. That's just my opinion though.

[toggle57]

Yes, but there will be a function, (I will add in later), that allows a clan to detach themselves as well.

Dont like this idea.

IMO the point of linking clans is central control and management of a group. All the rest is fluff.

I dont want to start building feeder clans that fill up with people due to the reputation of my main clan and my main clans good management - only to have them break away at some later date because a co in the feeder decided he wants to take over.

No way.

[toggle57]

I totally disagree. That's just my opinion though.

Fair enough... and I may be wrong but I don't think you have a snowballs chance of getting all that stuff implemented.

Its easy to make a huge following of kids drool at the thought of such a huge list of cool sounding changes.

Your thread is a classic example of scope creep... you started with a complex idea and slowly massaged it with every tweak everyone through at you.

Not being a hater.... just a realist.

I sincerely hope supercell implements sister clan linking... its badly needed - but your idea is waaaaay too much.

[Lucas10]

This is a great idea! But my clan already has feeders so how will that work if we wanted those clans in the family?

EDIT: Sorry if this has already been metioned, I'm too lazy to look through the pages

[TurtleBandits]

Fair enough... and I may be wrong but I don't think you have a snowballs chance of getting all that stuff implemented.

Its easy to make a huge following of kids drool at the thought of such a huge list of cool sounding changes.

Your thread is a classic example of scope creep... you started with a complex idea and slowly massaged it with every tweak everyone through at you.

Not being a hater.... just a realist.

I sincerely hope supercell implements sister clan linking... its badly needed - but your idea is waaaaay too much.

I respect your opinion, but I think that I will have to agree to disagree. We will se what happens.

[TurtleBandits]

Plus I knew that this was a lot. But thats why I separated in sections, because I figured this would be too much to be added into one update. So I figured first would come the tab that connected the two, then chats to buff it up, and then all the smaller additions to put shine and wax. Basically this is gonna be an update that will come in parts

[Lipkinhew]

IMO, the idea of sisters/feeder clans is not the main intention or it's not what clash of clan ought to be, it had twisted the main concept of the game. Where the idea of the sister/feeder clan inserted too much of management genre, causing it to lost its original strategic way in attacking and defending, hence I don't see the importance in allowing idea sister/feeder clan to be implemented. Plus, considering the disadvantages, it might bring a disaster due unbalanced clan ranking where the top 5 highest trophy clan combining together. It was very unfair cause good attacking skill and bases doesn't matter anymore. With the implementation, socializing, networking, relationship, management are over-stressed in the game, the players could not enjoy clashing anymore just because of too busy on managing the clans, shaping clash of clans to become a management/business type of game. Originally, the idea of clan help us to join together and the implementation of clan war has enhanced the connection and team spirit within a clan. However, the idea of sister/elder clan will end up forming an organization, where is too big to consider as a team anymore.

In conclusion, my main point is the idea of sister/elder clan is not the way of clashing. (No offense)

[ragerrodent]

Amazing modifications! I loved the original idea, but this is even better!

[toggle57]

IMO, the idea of sisters/feeder clans is not the main intention or it's not what clash of clan ought to be, it had twisted the main concept of the game. Where the idea of the sister/feeder clan inserted too much of management genre, causing it to lost its original strategic way in attacking and defending, hence I don't see the importance in allowing idea sister/feeder clan to be implemented. Plus, considering the disadvantages, it might bring a disaster due unbalanced clan ranking where the top 5 highest trophy clan combining together. It was very unfair cause good attacking skill and bases doesn't matter anymore. With the implementation, socializing, networking, relationship, management are over-stressed in the game, the players could not enjoy clashing anymore just because of too busy on managing the clans, shaping clash of clans to become a management/business type of game. Originally, the idea of clan help us to join together and the implementation of clan war has enhanced the connection and team spirit within a clan. However, the idea of sister/elder clan will end up forming an organization, where is too big to consider as a team anymore.

In conclusion, my main point is the idea of sister/elder clan is not the way of clashing. (No offense)

Not sure that you understand in any sister/feeder suggested idea that I have seen the clans in the group still exist as separate entities, have separate trophy counts, war separately as a individual clans.

Sure people can move around between clans but that has always been possible even without this proposed change.

This change does not imply that all the clans in the family become a single super clan - it simply allows for consistent management of multiple clans by a managment team.

If you already understood all that ... then I obviously dont understand what you are trying to say.