CC troops that target

[ragerrodent]

Ok, so I was just playing COC and people were complaining about wb's in their CC...Lol one of em was askin "Won't they target my walls on defense?!" Funny, but it got me thinking.
Troops that target specific things shouldn't be available on defense...that means no wb, gobs, giants, hogs, etc... No u might be thinkin, "Wait! What about offense?" Well I'm thinking that when u request troops u choose whether they're for offense or defense. The offense version allows u to receive anything...the defensive one allows only troops with no specific targets. Now this doesn't prevent u from using the defensive version on an attack or vice-versa. If u want something like gobs even for defense (I know someone who likes em)u can select offense. This is just a way to possibly avoid them. Seriously, it doesn't make sense that wb's, which target walls, should ignore your own walls and hit troops!

[PhilISuppose]

Ok, so I was just playing COC and people were complaining about wb's in their CC...Lol one of em was askin "Won't they target my walls on defense?!" Funny, but it got me thinking.
Troops that target specific things shouldn't be available on defense...that means no wb, gobs, giants, hogs, etc... No u might be thinkin, "Wait! What about offense?" Well I'm thinking that when u request troops u choose whether they're for offense or defense. The offense version allows u to receive anything...the defensive one allows only troops with no specific targets. Now this doesn't prevent u from using the defensive version on an attack or vice-versa. If u want something like gobs even for defense (I know someone who likes em)u can select offense. This is just a way to possibly avoid them. Seriously, it doesn't make sense that wb's, which target walls, should ignore your own walls and hit troops!

Troops with specific targets will attack other things when their specific targets aren't available, so that's all giants or wall breakers or goblins currently do.
Giant, can't see defense to attack, attacks nearest target (so troops if on defense)
Goblin, can't see resources to attack, attacks nearest target (so troops if on defense)
Wall breaker, can't see wall to attack, attacks nearest target (so troops if on defense)

[ragerrodent]

Troops with specific targets will attack other things when their specific targets aren't available, so that's all giants or wall breakers or goblins currently do.
Giant, can't see defense to attack, attacks nearest target (so troops if on defense)
Goblin, can't see resources to attack, attacks nearest target (so troops if on defense)
Wall breaker, can't see wall to attack, attacks nearest target (so troops if on defense)

Dude, look at my signature, or my amount of posts...do I look like a noob? I'm aware of all of this! My point is that on defense these troops attack other troops, when technically there's walls or defenses or resources available, they're simply yours! Besides, I'm trying to make a way to where u don't have to get these troops but not totally eliminate the possibility

[PhilISuppose]

Dude, look at my signature, or my amount of posts...do I look like a noob? I'm aware of all of this! My point is that on defense these troops attack other troops, when technically there's walls or defenses or resources available, they're simply yours! Besides, I'm trying to make a way to where u don't have to get these troops but not totally eliminate the possibility

You archers from a clan castle don't attack your own buildings either, and they have no special target to choose to attack. Surely they should run out of the clan castle and start attacking your own building rather than running half way across the map to attack troops.

Oh wait, it's because it only attacks the opponent who is attacking your base, it all makes sense (well to me anyway)

It's like asking why your own cannons don't start attacking your own clan castle troops when they come out. It's because it doesn't make any sense!

And to be honest your post DOES make you sound like a noob. I don't care how many posts you have or what level you've got to, if you post dumb stuff, I am going to point it out.

[ragerrodent]

You archers from a clan castle don't attack your own buildings either, and they have no special target to choose to attack. Surely they should run out of the clan castle and start attacking your own building rather than running half way across the map to attack troops.

Oh wait, it's because it only attacks the opponent who is attacking your base, it all makes sense (well to me anyway)

It's like asking why your own cannons don't start attacking your own clan castle troops when they come out. It's because it doesn't make any sense!

And to be honest your post DOES make you sound like a noob. I don't care how many posts you have or what level you've got to, if you post dumb stuff, I am going to point it out.

And I don't care how many mistakes u find in my idea, if I think of an idea worth sharing I'm going to share it! What is wrong with a way to help stop receiving troops u don't want? It's better than about 95% of all the threads posted in this subforum

[PhilISuppose]

And I don't care how many mistakes u find in my idea, if I think of an idea worth sharing I'm going to share it! What is wrong with a way to help stop receiving troops u don't want? It's better than about 95% of all the threads posted in this subforum

Good do keep sharing ideas!

I'll read anything that's not
Resource donations
Resource exchange
Builder stacking or upgrades

I just didn't think this one made any sense, sorry.

[ragerrodent]

Good do keep sharing ideas!

I'll read anything that's not
Resource donations
Resource exchange
Builder stacking or upgrades

I just didn't think this one made any sense, sorry.

If I had one of those, I'd shoot myself due to self-shame...but honestly, what is it about my idea that u don't thin works? How is this bad?

[PhilISuppose]

If I had one of those, I'd shoot myself due to self-shame...but honestly, what is it about my idea that u don't thin works? How is this bad?

It's just a bit random. And solves a problem that doesn't really exist for me.

If we're really all that worried about what troops we get, then make a filter that's completely configurable as to the troops that can go into a clan castle request.

I don't see how an offensive/defensive toggle helps prevent you from getting given rubbish...

[ragerrodent]

It's just a bit random. And solves a problem that doesn't really exist for me.

If we're really all that worried about what troops we get, then make a filter that's completely configurable as to the troops that can go into a clan castle request.

I don't see how an offensive/defensive toggle helps prevent you from getting given rubbish...

It's just sorta a way to explain why these troops aren't allowed to be donated

[Isaacium]

I get it. That way people don't donate stupid troops like giants and wall breakers. But if you want troops like giants and wall breakers, u can change it to offensive.