Reward for the most heroic attack and defence with bonus loot

[monoliz]

this will encourage to attack higher players or at least of the same level, and as an addition to your idea, it will be nice to discourage players from attacking low level enemies, leaving low players without any possible stars. it can be done in a way of penalty to war bonus

[LEGEND123]

this will encourage to attack higher players or at least of the same level, and as an addition to your idea, it will be nice to discourage players from attacking low level enemies, leaving low players without any possible stars. it can be done in a way of penalty to war bonus

yeah thats the plus point andgood for the clan war and thanx all for liking my idea

[hawdog]

I can see the negative side of this.

It will encourage players to attack such high players that they can't even get 1 star. And they will have wasted their attack because they are trying to be greedy and trying to gain the extra bonus for most heroic attack.

This is a selfish consequence, and it will work against your clan's effort to win the war because of greedy individuals trying to attack bases that are too strong for them.

I believe that people should only be attacking a base they think they can AT LEAST confidently 2-star.

Giving an extra bonus for most heroic attack will earn your clan a bunch of zero-star attacks when those weaker players should have been attacking weaker enemy bases.

[LEGEND123]

I can see the negative side of this.

It will encourage players to attack such high players that they can't even get 1 star. And they will have wasted their attack because they are trying to be greedy and trying to gain the extra bonus for most heroic attack.

This is a selfish consequence, and it will work against your clan's effort to win the war because of greedy individuals trying to attack bases that are too strong for them.

I believe that people should only be attacking a base they think they can AT LEAST confidently 2-star.

Giving an extra bonus for most heroic attack will earn your clan a bunch of zero-star attacks when those weaker players should have been attacking weaker enemy bases.

yeah thats why there loot should be less as i mentioned in the post or the most heroic attack should be picked random whoever has scored three stars on higher town hall

[hawdog]

yeah thats why there loot should be less as i mentioned in the post or the most heroic attack should be picked random whoever has scored three stars on higher town hall

you want to pick a random player who scored three stars on a higher townhall?

But this is no longer the "MOST heroic attack" anymore............ it is a "RANDOM heroic attack", do you see what I mean?

I'm pretty sure the formula for most heroic attack is quite simple, it should be this:

If the attack wins 1 star or more, then --> (enemy war base #) - (attacker war base #) = the highest number in your clan.

If there is a tie, then the higher stars earned or higher %age destroyed would be the tie breakers.

[LEGEND123]

you want to pick a random player who scored three stars on a higher townhall?

But this is no longer the "MOST heroic attack" anymore............ it is a "RANDOM heroic attack", do you see what I mean?

I'm pretty sure the formula for most heroic attack is quite simple, it should be this:

If the attack wins 1 star or more, then --> (enemy war base #) - (attacker war base #) = the highest number in your clan.

If there is a tie, then the higher stars earned or higher %age destroyed would be the tie breakers.

yea that's an improvement for this idea a agrees with you ill add that to my post and thanx

[LEGEND123]

comment guys hey hey hey hey hey