Ok I see what your intention is. But what you describe is no longer a clan WAR.
What you describe lacks the best part of clan wars, which is competition.
I think that the current version of clan wars is still the best thing. Maybe matchmaking could be tweaked a little bit, but it's not up to Supercell. They can only match you up against whichever clans request to start a war. So if no one suitable for your clan requests, you can be stuck waiting hours and hours for an appropriate match.
Considering all the pros and cons, I think Supercell has done a fantastic job with clan wars as-is.




