Cavebears *new thread*

[Jorgbear]

DP				2268
Tanys				1888
Azuhma				1724
fofo b.				1471
Phoenix				1308
mayana 70				1101
CookleDo				999
Chris	New			957
MsPlumr				916
Andrew				883
Sidlon				861
123bigboo				783
Jorg				761
Rudekid				720
shawn				698
Buttnutz				692
Molly McSmashie				685
spoon				642
firemelt				614
Quasihobo				596
Zac Coleman				531
Optophobe				507
Rusty 6				490
Slaine	New			490
mjmalino				445
Scu	New			443
bizron				439
boomster9				439
Dayala				374
Deblet				370
Mattluca				357
zacw54321	New			352
fidanzal				334
Tardis X Doctor	New			334
Kiddywear				281
Gobchopper				254
Pitchbl4ck				251
angels4				197
BloodElfHans				188
Bob Fossil				173
Sam	New			171
Arlando	Sleeping			122
Dabo				90
GoldSnow99	Sleeping			75
Bostrich1				65

Now removing those sleeping/new and those weknow about the following have failed to meet the required donations of 200 perweek.

Bloodelfhans 188
Bob Fossil 173
Dabo 90
Bostrich 65

The Guardian recommendation is therefore that thefollowing are fed to fluffy: Bostrich, Dabo for failing miserably.

Bloodelfhans was just under so the recommendationis that he be requested to move to Riverbears.

It is recommended that Bob Fossil, as a longstanding member of the bear clans and an elder, be requested to join one of theless active bear family clans until activity increases to cavebear requirements.

[kc99]

I would love to have Bob back at IceBears !!! SEND HIM !!!

[EpicVertex]

Hello, TARDIS x DOCTOR here, does anyone know how I can contact Leech re: an avatar picture?

[SpeChi]

Hello, TARDIS x DOCTOR here, does anyone know how I can contact Leech re: an avatar picture?

PM him here on the forum.

[EpicVertex]

PM him here on the forum.

Thanks I have contacted him

[HansClashOfClans]

Sorry to disturb you guys but I would like to report a little mistake.

I donated over 500 troops over the past week. I don't understand why it says 188 in your statistics. I think you can ask around and people will tell that I have been donating actively. May I please rejoin cavebears?

Also I just got level 5 archers...

EDIT: Can't show a screenshot too prove it, statistics have been removed already...

[Jorgbear]

Sorry to disturb you guys but I would like to report a little mistake.

I donated over 500 troops over the past week. I don't understand why it says 188 in your statistics. I think you can ask around and people will tell that I have been donating actively. May I please rejoin cavebears?

Also I just got level 5 archers...

EDIT: Can't show a screenshot too prove it, statistics have been removed already...

Hi hans I've pm'd you

[mayana70]

Hello,

Our rules currently say that we donate archers (or barbs) by default and anything else only after we
have clarified with the requestor that the other troops are "okay"
(... or somebody had asked for certain troops, then it is evident)

I observe that many cavebears have dragons in their portfolio and they are occasionally willing to donate them
and so far I have no indications that anyone would have prefered archers instead of a dragon.
People tend to like dragons in their CC . Practically I see quite a few of them flying between our camps every hour.

"problem statement":
It requires time to ask the question and answer it (and in 95% you get a YES anyway).
That is wasted time and often by the time the process is finished someone else has donated a
few archers and there is no room left for a dragon. The potential recipient is sad.

I hereby formally request (dead hand´s policy applies) that dragons are allowed as donations without
need for prior communication with the requestor.

Free the dragons!

so what about archers (and barbs) then?:
I understand that some people can´t make dragons (yet) and some can not hold them in their clan castle (yet).
That is not a problem per se (I see it rather as a goal). I think we all understand that and we had all been in that situation.
Getting and giving lvl3 archers is also still okay - really!
Also people are still encouraged to fill their clanmates castle swiftly (also when it only holds 10 or 15 spaces), which does
require having some archers in store.
(Does everybody know that you can already queue-up archers before you leave for a raid... they will be ready when you return)

Mayana 70

mayana 70
elder of cavebears
manager of garbage disposal in the cave
senior consultant on axe-throwing physics and duells by throwing empty barrels of mead
imperial cross-clan "undersecretary of state for independence and simplicity"
founder and leader of: nothing except my family (and the leadership for that is disputed :-)
organiser of parties whenever I upgrade something cool like TH or wiz tower
citizen of the cave and one of these cold places in Europe
TH: yes, level: yes, but always changing
archer, brb, giant troop level: never high enough
trophy level: Tell me where the best loot is between 0 and xxx and will go there
frequent user of apple hardware
proud user of prematurely placed healers (also soemtimes far away from the troops to be healed)
... because I am phycially challenged by the tactile requirements of my 2x2cm display (estimate)
donations: archers ... and other stuff if you ask politely (somehow no-one likes my wizards. why?)
Pls. try to join our clan and ask for a dragon in return for your gobs within your first 10 minutes - I will show you
our catapults right away - including the in-flight entertainment package we have installed
.... unless fluffy (the pet of our leader) is hungry
donation numbers: >200 till monday night,
but never as much as Megaan, chris, DP, Tanys, Andrew, rudekid, :spoon, sidlon, deblet and a few others

[Deblet]

Let those scaly beasts be freed

[boomster9]

"problem statement":
It requires time to ask the question and answer it (and in 95% you get a YES anyway).
That is wasted time and often by the time the process is finished someone else has donated a
few archers and there is no room left for a dragon. The potential recipient is sad.

I have no objection to adding dragons as an always-welcome donation. As I have had the embarrassing experience of dropping in archers when a dragon request was afoot, I agree that your proposal would solve this problem and prevent me from making similar cloddish behavior in the future.

or would it?

If our clan can still donate archers, a speedy finger can always intrude and prevent a dragon from entering. The only way I see this working is to employ a simple you-take-your-chances approach. Someone requests troops, and then takes whatever the clan's nimble fingers give. Maybe it's a dragon, maybe not. Lower-level players who can't yet cook dragons can step up to the donation plate whenever they want. If they are edged out by a faster finger - well, that's viking life, not a deck stacked against them.

If we permit dragon donations without stopping the dragon begging, we do not solve the problem of sadness but potentially introduce the problem of resenting archer donations - with unknown social consequences.