Surrendering in Clan War

[RawrMonster8315]

You should be able to surrender in clan war. The following are rules for surrendering.

-36 hours must have passed (Preperation Day, 12 Hours in Battle Day)
-Leader must vote to surrender
-75% of members must vote yes to surrendering

[Cyrand]

👍 i like, and it gives an automatic loss, buy losses dont show, only on the war log so i guess its pretty OK!!! I like!!

[Emsboy]

This has been suggested earlier today. Search function would probably bring it up. A good point was made that people from the clan may want to do there last attack for loot only.

[hawdog]

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...271354-Forfeit

It's only 1 page back, on page 2.

I don't know why people are so against doing a search first before starting a new thread. Do you really think your ideas are original? It takes a few seconds to do a quick search.

But you're not alone. 90% if not more of the ideas posted here are already suggested, and/or ruled out by supercell already, as people would know if they ready the sticky that says "READ BEFORE POSTING"

[Cyrand]

This has been suggested earlier today. Search function would probably bring it up. A good point was made that people from the clan may want to do there last attack for loot only.

if they want loot, do a normal attack!!

[hawdog]

if they want loot, do a normal attack!!

guess you didn't read my reply in the other thread about the same thing.

You know how there is a new achievements called "war hero" and "spoils of war"? well for people who want to work towards these two achievements should be making two attacks every single clan war, even if they know their clan will not win the war. Go into your game and read about how to achieve these two achievements. You will see why no one wanting to complete these achievements will be okay with forfeiting a war.

If they were cooking some high level troops before bed and they were going to do their second clan war attack when they wake up the next day, only to find out that the war was forfeited while they were asleep, there will be many angry players.

That is why forfeiting or surrendering should not be implemented. Everyone should have a fair chance to do both their attacks.

[EvCal10]

This would be good (not that my clan PaperRockSpok would ever need or use it).

[Cyrand]

guess you didn't read my reply in the other thread about the same thing.

You know how there is a new achievements called "war hero" and "spoils of war"? well for people who want to work towards these two achievements should be making two attacks every single clan war, even if they know their clan will not win the war. Go into your game and read about how to achieve these two achievements. You will see why no one wanting to complete these achievements will be okay with forfeiting a war.

If they were cooking some high level troops before bed and they were going to do their second clan war attack when they wake up the next day, only to find out that the war was forfeited while they were asleep, there will be many angry players.

That is why forfeiting or surrendering should not be implemented. Everyone should have a fair chance to do both their attacks.

The idea of the surrender would be useful for when you get them people that dont attack or leave during war, but i do understand what you are saying, and i am actually after those achievements my self lool 😛