I really agree about the fact that, Clan war troop donations must be added to your overall troop donation. Either in Clan wars or in the Clan castle. Also, it would be a lot more easier to get achievements like the Friend in Need Achievement. So, I totally agree about the idea.
I think this is an idea that will probably be in the next big update. I've been wanting this ever since wars came out but it's really come up as a big topic now. I hope supercell can make this happen.
Since someone revived this thread, you should all know that this idea has been ruled out by Supercell. http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines Read this before starting threads, many "popular" ideas are ruled out.
GameCenter ID - DarkDefianceGC Kik ID - antoniofabritzi (Hay Day only)
Hay Day Friend Code: #Y29P8QC0
Level 73, Rep level 18
136/150 achievements, 16 masteries. Barn 4600, Silo 4500
2 Pearls of the Sea found in back to back nets, 27 total now!
SC has already addressed this: They want to implement it but it would be abused to much. Since there can be no cool-down for in-war requests, players could donate to a second account, delete the troops from the castle, and do it over and over and over again. They would beat friend in need achievement in one day, which defeats the purpose (to promote donating to clanmates.)
Originally Posted by TheGurgeMan
I'dthink a simple fix would be that if the donated CC troops are deleted then any points that were earned from the donation would be deleted as well.
I recall seeing this in the list of rejected ideas.
More over with the new upgrade (Clan XP and clan perks), donations for clan war bases may give some elixir back. Counting them with regular is not correct. Also, you ideally want highest level troups in the CCs.
I dont think this a good idea.... People could abuse this greatly by giving giants to war ccthen having them remove the giants and just keep giving giants to them until they get the friend in need award.
