Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 20

Thread: Trophy system has major flaws...

  1. #1
    Fresh Spawn
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    1

    Trophy system has major flaws...

    this game is seriously flawed. trophies are a complete waste of time. here's why... raiding someones village needs to work like the wars do. u get awarded loot based on how well u attack them. u are matched up based on your own strengths and town hall level. not matched up based on how many trophies u have. the trophy leagues are flawed because all u have to do is purposely lower your trophy count and attack easy targets and steal their hard earned resources. its stupid that u have to go against the game design and lower your trophies on purpose to get ahead in the game. i cant tell u how many times i wake up in the morning to find 200k gold and elixir gone because someone ranked up and leveled up much higher than me raided me simply because his trophies are close to the same level. that makes the game extremely unfair. if i have over 600k in resources, im garenteed that im gettin raided. how am i suppose to save up resources for better upgrades when it gets taken all the time? if its setup like the wars, nobody loses resources, u get awarded resources trophies and a few gems, and then trophy count would actually. yes i understand that ultimately the game is designed to make real money off of people and they want u to buy shields to overcome this problem. this is why its flawed. it even says in the opening of the game where it gives game tips "keep fighting for those trophies!" for what?! its not like im being rewarded for earning them!! this puts me in a higher league level which gets me raided even more by people who aren't my level. this needs to change

  2. #2
    Forum Elder hawdog's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Posts
    2,192
    welcome to the forums.

    Nope, you need to change. The trophy system is quite well refined already.

    You're not the first to suggest this and you won't be the last.

    the fact that you believe trophies don't matter will make this next suggestion even more important for you.

    Here it is. Leave your townhall outside in a corner, surrounded by decorations. that's right, do no protect your town hall. Why? Because there are so many players who are simply trying to increase their trophy count. They will come across your base, destroy your town hall, then quite their attack, giving you a nice 12-hour shield for the cost of a measly 1000 gold and 1000 elixir, approximately. You will be surprised how often attacks like this will happen to you instead of full-raids against you.

    This is most important when you go to bed, since you can't rearm traps or refill your clan castle.

    Give it a try for a couple days, see how often you get attacked this way.
    kimchi, of whozonbeer | TH11 | Lvl147

  3. #3
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Attacking your base.
    Posts
    96
    Quote Originally Posted by CptnObvious48 View Post
    this game is seriously flawed. trophies are a complete waste of time. here's why... raiding someones village needs to work like the wars do. u get awarded loot based on how well u attack them. u are matched up based on your own strengths and town hall level. not matched up based on how many trophies u have. the trophy leagues are flawed because all u have to do is purposely lower your trophy count and attack easy targets and steal their hard earned resources. its stupid that u have to go against the game design and lower your trophies on purpose to get ahead in the game. i cant tell u how many times i wake up in the morning to find 200k gold and elixir gone because someone ranked up and leveled up much higher than me raided me simply because his trophies are close to the same level. that makes the game extremely unfair. if i have over 600k in resources, im garenteed that im gettin raided. how am i suppose to save up resources for better upgrades when it gets taken all the time? if its setup like the wars, nobody loses resources, u get awarded resources trophies and a few gems, and then trophy count would actually. yes i understand that ultimately the game is designed to make real money off of people and they want u to buy shields to overcome this problem. this is why its flawed. it even says in the opening of the game where it gives game tips "keep fighting for those trophies!" for what?! its not like im being rewarded for earning them!! this puts me in a higher league level which gets me raided even more by people who aren't my level. this needs to change
    You sir, need to learn the concept of the game.

  4. #4
    Trainee
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    25
    Quote Originally Posted by ImperiumOfMan View Post
    You sir, need to learn the concept of the game.
    You Sir,Need to put you th outside problem solved

  5. #5
    Banned
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Location
    Banned
    Posts
    5,519
    Quote Originally Posted by CptnObvious48 View Post
    this game is seriously flawed. trophies are a complete waste of time. here's why... raiding someones village needs to work like the wars do. u get awarded loot based on how well u attack them. u are matched up based on your own strengths and town hall level. not matched up based on how many trophies u have. the trophy leagues are flawed because all u have to do is purposely lower your trophy count and attack easy targets and steal their hard earned resources. its stupid that u have to go against the game design and lower your trophies on purpose to get ahead in the game. i cant tell u how many times i wake up in the morning to find 200k gold and elixir gone because someone ranked up and leveled up much higher than me raided me simply because his trophies are close to the same level. that makes the game extremely unfair. if i have over 600k in resources, im garenteed that im gettin raided. how am i suppose to save up resources for better upgrades when it gets taken all the time? if its setup like the wars, nobody loses resources, u get awarded resources trophies and a few gems, and then trophy count would actually. yes i understand that ultimately the game is designed to make real money off of people and they want u to buy shields to overcome this problem. this is why its flawed. it even says in the opening of the game where it gives game tips "keep fighting for those trophies!" for what?! its not like im being rewarded for earning them!! this puts me in a higher league level which gets me raided even more by people who aren't my level. this needs to change
    also about punctuation
    and paragraphs

  6. #6
    Super Member Chupacabra101's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2013
    Location
    Mars, where else?
    Posts
    799
    If you keep losing or getting attacked, what I would do is

    1. Make a better base. This may not be a problem, but this maybe why your being attacked.

    2. Spend your resources before you log off! If you have a builder doing nothing and you have a lot of gold, work on walls. If you have a ton of elixir, make a expensive army.

    3. Drop your trophies. You will find easier targets while not being attacked as much.
    Yerr ar new forumers get off my property! *Waves shotgun in the air*

  7. #7
    Forum Veteran
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    1,966
    Quote Originally Posted by CptnObvious48 View Post
    this game is seriously flawed. trophies are a complete waste of time. here's why... raiding someones village needs to work like the wars do. u get awarded loot based on how well u attack them. u are matched up based on your own strengths and town hall level. not matched up based on how many trophies u have. the trophy leagues are flawed because all u have to do is purposely lower your trophy count and attack easy targets and steal their hard earned resources. its stupid that u have to go against the game design and lower your trophies on purpose to get ahead in the game. i cant tell u how many times i wake up in the morning to find 200k gold and elixir gone because someone ranked up and leveled up much higher than me raided me simply because his trophies are close to the same level. that makes the game extremely unfair. if i have over 600k in resources, im garenteed that im gettin raided. how am i suppose to save up resources for better upgrades when it gets taken all the time? if its setup like the wars, nobody loses resources, u get awarded resources trophies and a few gems, and then trophy count would actually. yes i understand that ultimately the game is designed to make real money off of people and they want u to buy shields to overcome this problem. this is why its flawed. it even says in the opening of the game where it gives game tips "keep fighting for those trophies!" for what?! its not like im being rewarded for earning them!! this puts me in a higher league level which gets me raided even more by people who aren't my level. this needs to change
    0 capitalization.
    Cannot comprehend.
    Quote Originally Posted by johnnybro1234 View Post
    There were too many words for me to read them all
    Quote Originally Posted by djdiamond66 View Post
    Hey guys please new collector is gem collector all clash of clans playing time is explended sorry its playing its my idea the gemcollector christmas update s guys please work update all clash of clans fans best ideas in he world best startegy game is the Clash of Clans thank you is game game is Perfect

  8. #8
    Millennial Club
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,276
    Though I do agree with others in not liking the format and that it is likely you need to do the town hall outside thing and have better layouts, I do agree with the idea as well.

    I do not understand why town hall tens are in leagues where you see town hall fives mostly and such. I do not like it and the best argument I have for that is the fact of people purposely lowering trophy count. It could be seen as abusing the system in that aspect and as such could be changed.
    Started the game in January and three days later became a member of Zombie brains, the only clan I ever been in. Town hall eight since April 16th.
    Wars won, 86. War hero,543 stars
    Don't speed upgrade your town hall, being a level nine or ten does not help you if you have gold walls or lower.

  9. #9
    Trainee GimmeTroops's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    East Bay
    Posts
    25
    I thought SuperCell did a god job of determining how the clan wars are matched up...what would be wrong with a system like that finds players closer to where you are in the game for regular attacks, as opposed just going by trophies? And the other poster is right about making sure your base is covered and taken care of, but some times it just flat out doesnt matter when someone 20 levels above you comes in and completely rolls your base with higher level troops because they choose to keep their trophies down to have an easier time collecting loot. Im not that bothered by it, and I still go for trophies, but I definitely think the OP has a point.

  10. #10
    Trainee GimmeTroops's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    East Bay
    Posts
    25
    The trophy system is set up to be abused unfortunately. Seems to me the only incentive to go for the trophies is war loot bonus, which isnt even that great (at least not where I am)

    Quote Originally Posted by MomoZB View Post
    Though I do agree with others in not liking the format and that it is likely you need to do the town hall outside thing and have better layouts, I do agree with the idea as well.

    I do not understand why town hall tens are in leagues where you see town hall fives mostly and such. I do not like it and the best argument I have for that is the fact of people purposely lowering trophy count. It could be seen as abusing the system in that aspect and as such could be changed.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •