IGN: Jason (#2RCUP00Q) Level: 107 TH: 9
Clan: Savages (#GUJ0V9G)
Bring on the hogs... Please, attack my th9 defenses! In six weeks not one hog army has 3 starred me, most fail, 2 have two starred me, maybe 10% get 1 star...
You know what should be nerfed? Level four dragon spam with 5 rages that two star me every time! Or gowiwi with level 20+ heroes! They can two star me too!
I should make a post how brainless gowiwi and dragon spam is....
gowiwi... Golem left few wizzies behind it, golem right few wizzies behind... Wait a second.... Ok... Golem center, RAGE a few wallbreakers, more wizzies, heroes! More wallbreakers! Rage again!.. Freeze that inferno... Rage the heroes to take your center!!
Point is... No army strategy is really that complicated... This is because we are choosing the bases we get to attack that match our army and a strat we are comfortable with.
At least with hogs, hitting a maxed th10 or really good th9 can take some actual strategy.. Far more than dragon rage spam or golems rage wb hero freeze spam.
If this is the case... Then why do tons of people not have any issues with hogs?
Yes, for beginning th9s and lower townhalls they will crush you potentially... However your th8 or weak defensive th9 will get crushed by most armies....
while we are nerfing successful army combos.....
Townhall 7 and lower get crushed by giant healer combinations! Remember stomping the hell out of th6s at th7? Interesting to note, once you get to th8/9 healers become mostly useless!
So, yes, actually having to choose how to build your base is a great thing... Otherwise we would all just centralize everything, build those walls and all have the same similar base designs (anti gowiwi with strong air defense). Let's go back to those days! Then you can complain about needing to spend 500000 elixir to be able to raid anything...
I am TH 9 and most certainly do not have inferno, or multi at that. Hogs are not OP. TH 9s and TH 10s alike are not able to three star my base in clan wars. Similarly, I have maxed troops (for th 9) and find TH 9s in clan wars that I cannot three star with hog.
You, simply put, do not know what you are talking about. Go deeper.
I agree that hog rings will expose some defenses. However, with an appropriately sized core you should still be able to keep enough of your key defenses safe. Take Ringus as an example. The core Peabak was using right before upgrading to TH10 contained four Air Defenses, four Teslas, two XBows, the CC and DE storage. That's significant firepower and should work well against loons, hogs and giants/healers. What's left: GoWi__ and BARCH/BAG/BAM? The WTs thinning out the barbs while distracted on the collectors ringing the base and splitting up the storages into different compartments seems to work for me (and I have 3 ADs, two Mortars and 3 Teslas in my core: will change in 9 days when I get my fourth L7 Tesla). Haven't been attacked by GoWiWi, and the teslas wrecked the PEKKAs in my last GoWiPe defense. I'm not overly worried by them as they don't happen often at my trophy level, and I simply accept that a four or five spell GoWi__ will crush me. Its your time/elixir, use it how you will.
Yeah, high-level hogs can pose a problem. Show your base, that would clarify things.