Count donations of War Map :)

[Storyteller]

Hello there.

Abstract:

Display the amount of donated troops in war map in either the same donated troops log as the normal clan donations or some separate donated troops log.

Current Situation

Currently no one is aware of how many troops players have donated for the war map bases. This is especially a big issue in our clan, because we have agreed to only have the higher levels donate in order to have better troops in everyone's War Clan Castles. However these donators, including myself do not receive any credit for the huge amount of elixir and dark elixir burnt to create max level witches, dragons and wizards.

Solution

Simply display the amount of donated troops somewhere, so that it will be easier to manage the clan and see who actually donates and who doesn't. This is very valuable information for a leader and co-leader.

Thanks in advance for your responses.

[kidcudi88]

I agree and it motivates people to donate

[Storyteller]

I agree and it motivates people to donate

True! Hope this idea would really come alive...

[MomoZB]

This has been posted before and ill say what I said in them

Please no, cause too much problems

1. People be more motivated to donate giants (This almost lost us a war, ended up being a tie)
2. People should learn you do not need direct rewards every time for "helping"
3. It would be heavily abused if they allow troop release.
4. It makes ill feelings of those that can't donate because they are "not strong enough"

I still think the best solution is allowing 100% elixir/dark elixir return on what is donated on wins (80% tie, 50% loss)

No "gain" prevents my list from happening.

[Eeanie]

Developers need urgently to add function of dumping of soldiers from a clan castle. Not always it fill with that is necessary!

[Stormegetton]

No becasue people would donate crappy stuff

[Storyteller]

If you really can't control your clan from donating giants and other crappy stuff then that clan is completely useless. Leave it or start adding some rules! That's definitely not a reason to deny this idea.

[MomoZB]

Like I said, people do it now time to time and we do have rules but without not knowing who did it, it is a bit hard to talk to the person that did it. (It was actually our third war when it happened so everyone should of known better at that point too and it still happened) THIS change will ONLY MAKE that situation worse. I also dislike you said nothing in relation of this list:

This has been posted before and ill say what I said in them

Please no, cause too much problems

1. People be more motivated to donate giants (This almost lost us a war, ended up being a tie)
2. People should learn you do not need direct rewards every time for "helping"
3. It would be heavily abused if they allow troop release.
4. It makes ill feelings of those that can't donate because they are "not strong enough"

I still think the best solution is allowing 100% elixir/dark elixir return on what is donated on wins (80% tie, 50% loss)

No "gain" prevents my list from happening.

Just because you want something in the game, does not mean it is best for the game. IF you want the troop release thing, there is NO WAY a reward should be given for clan castle defenses due to abuse.

[Storyteller]

Like I said, people do it now time to time and we do have rules but without not knowing who did it, it is a bit hard to talk to the person that did it. (It was actually our third war when it happened so everyone should of known better at that point too and it still happened) THIS change will ONLY MAKE that situation worse. I also dislike you said nothing in relation of this list:


Just because you want something in the game, does not mean it is best for the game. IF you want the troop release thing, there is NO WAY a reward should be given for clan castle defenses due to abuse.

I think you're overseeing the good donators just to bring down the bad donators. Once again, I'll repeat this, if you cannot control your clan to donate what really should be donated, then your clan is useless! You should face the facts instead of denying them. Do not accept members who'd troll your war or simply be too low for the war, if you really want to become something in wars.

However, I believe it would be possible to also have a log showing what did people donate in war castle. That's how your problem would be solved.

[MomoZB]

Strawmans do not work on me, do not insult my clan just because you want to defend your idea.

(It was actually our third war when it happened so everyone should of known better at that point too and it still happened)

You failed to ague the list again:

1. People be more motivated to donate giants (This almost lost us a war, ended up being a tie)
2. People should learn you do not need direct rewards every time for "helping"
3. It would be heavily abused if they allow troop release.
4. It makes ill feelings of those that can't donate because they are "not strong enough"

I still think the best solution is allowing 100% elixir/dark elixir return on what is donated on wins (80% tie, 50% loss)