Justin's idea for Clan Wars LIVE ATTACKS! (with tons of pictures!)

[justinhu]

Great work Justin, and excellent job with the pics! I'd totally be for this is the servers allowed for it. I'm not quite sure if it could or not, but if they found a way to, I'm definitely pro-this idea

Edit: just noticed my name on a pic, love it!

Hey Mastermind

It's nice getting your idea recognized by the king of ideas! I think if Supercell makes a million dollars a day they can afford some new servers.

[justinhu]

Super special forum Easter Egg edition I made!

anybody else?

[HyperGamer]

Nice picture editing

[justinhu]

I know these replies are super late but I want to thank everyone for there positive feedback and encouragement.

Great idea and amazing edits!

Nice picture editing

Thanks! You can get some for your own idea at the iGFXMakers page

[Logan2792]

All the battle animations should be available to watch live, it would be crappy without them

[Phoenix64]

If a clan did not support ghosting, this would cut down on ghosting substantially in those clans.

[justinhu]

All the battle animations should be available to watch live, it would be crappy without them

It would get SUPER laggy and then would probably crash Supercells servers

[PhilISuppose]

Oh dear, technical info that I'm not familiar with. I'll try to figure it out.

Sure, a lot of data transfer but not more than current replays.

I don't think it's stored on the device as I've accidentally had my device run out of battery in the middle of clan wars attack and it just stops, you can see the replay afterwards, I think its just a delay between the server and device not a complete stop.

I don't understand what you mean

A lot of people have suggested that there shouldn't be a popup and I think its necessary for everybody to gather around the person doing the attack to cheer him on and give support. If clans put unpositive pressure on you, you should leave

There's a lot more data transfer involved.
Currently when you load a replay, it loads the whole replay in one go, and then plays it. (You can test this your self by turning off wifi mid replay, it will still complete)
So you're suggesting instead that replays should be:
Sent from Raiding Device to Server.
Save in a format that can be retrieved.
Loaded at ANY point, 30 seconds in, 60 seconds in etc. and watched from that point on LIVE by several other watchers.

Popups are awful, the diseased invention of 1990s web programmers minds. I bet you have them turned off in browser, why would you want them in game? I don't mind the idea of support etc, but I hate the idea of a pop up. It would be a massive backward step in design, whats next ads?

[justinhu]

There's a lot more data transfer involved.
Currently when you load a replay, it loads the whole replay in one go, and then plays it. (You can test this your self by turning off wifi mid replay, it will still complete)
So you're suggesting instead that replays should be:
Sent from Raiding Device to Server.
Save in a format that can be retrieved.
Loaded at ANY point, 30 seconds in, 60 seconds in etc. and watched from that point on LIVE by several other watchers.

Popups are awful, the diseased invention of 1990s web programmers minds. I bet you have them turned off in browser, why would you want them in game? I don't mind the idea of support etc, but I hate the idea of a pop up. It would be a massive backward step in design, whats next ads?

Well, Supercell is making millions so I can see them affording getting some more servers.

Ok, I see your point. Just add an option for the war starter to have the option of turning pop ups on/off.

[Lewishughes1234]

This should happen