Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

[JtB]

Great update, and I'm sure its just because its new and we don't really know what we are doing...but the whole thing is seeming to take a lot of time to manage!

I have the following suggestions:

1. Please allow people within a clan to "opt in/out" of a war so that only the people who want to participate in a war do so... not everyone is available all of the time due to RL commitments...

2. Please allow us to be able to dismiss and replace troops from the clan castle, or at least see who donated what so that we can address trolling or misguided issues..

3. Please show the recommended targets during preparation day so that people can see who they are meant to be matched with.. yes i realise they are likely to be the same number in the opposing clan's war map but it would be good to make sure..

4. Please give us a way to "lock in" the war base at some point during the preparation day without having to wait for the clock to go to zero (even better, in addition to this would be to have saved bases in edit mode so that they are simple to switch over!). This helps with time zone issues for an international clan as its almost impossible to hit the search war button when everyone is awake...

5. Please give us additional communication tools other than clan chat. with an international clan, instructions, and comments in chat are too easily missed due to time zones and people who chat A LOT! Leader messages are too short, and the cool down period is way too long. we are having to rely on outside ways to communicate, such as glassboard etc and it can be difficult to get all clan members to register...

Other than that I think that this feature will add a great new dimension to a fabulous game ... keep up the great work

All great suggestions.

[shivampaw]

We still have people who should be taking part not taking part. What is the fix?

[DrDoom99]

Haven't actually begun Battle day yet, so may add more. Would like to see the following made available.

1) Add the feature for multiple base designs (max 4 designs) to allow easy switching back and forth whether farming or trophy hunting

2) Need the ability to dump CW Clan Castle during preparation day. Had some errant troops put into CC and cannot change them - This is a big one

3) Shorten preparation day. 24 hours is too long. Maybe allow for all members too get bases and CC ready, and click lock in or something to this effect.

DD

[Radu]

+1 to the following:

• Saved base layouts for fast switching.
• Ability to "lock in" your war base manually at any point during the prep day.
• Ability to see who donated to War Base CC's.
• Ability to dump War Base CC during prep day.
• Require approval of War Base CC troops before accepted into CC?
• If a member leaves after a war has started (prep day), the next member "on the bench" should take his/her place in the war. We had two hoppers leave today after matched in our first war and two long time members are stuck spectating even though we currently have 46 members. So we'll be fighting with 43 attackers but we have 3 people sitting out!!
• Ability for Leaders/Co-Leaders to "assign" or "suggest" or "mark" opponents to clan members, some sort of flag system or something. Organizing who will attack whom is proving to be near impossible.
• Clan War shared chat so warring clans can have friendly chatter/trash talk during war.

Can't wait to get our first war day under way tomorrow!

Then can play each child clanwars, no tactics needed, no skills needed...
Supercell great job, because you let this features out!

[TonyRigatoni]

so far, I really like what SC did with this update. I have a few suggestions that I think could help tweak things, but overall, excellent job. Yes, there are reports of bugs and glitches, but there isn't much they could do about that until the update launched anyway. So thanks for an awesome update SC! here are a few ideas that may make the experience even better:

Players should be able to dump their war base cc troops. This will help if there is a griefer in the clan that decides to donate goblins.

Players should have a button on their cc that toggles between 'Combatant' and 'Spectator.' This way, they can decide before hand if they want to join a clan war or just stay in spectator mode. Clans are losing or kicking members to avoid non combatants during the war. It would be nice if we could decide if we want to play or not.

[ZombieProcess]

11 of our members appear as town hall 4 on the map: with a clan castle capacity of 0--so we essentially cannot donate anything to them at all. huge advantage to the other team.

[cws]

It seems one of our members is filling our war castles with weak archers anyway to remove the troops?
Or better yet know who did it? Otherwise this is only get worse!! So we've lost a war before we even fired a shot due to a fifth colonist!!

[blackcollector]

Thank god (SC) for clan wars!

66 pages ... sorry if I'm too lazy to search my comments:

My leader started the war at a weird time. This results in end of preparation occuring at the same weird time. Here is what is bothering me and the possible solution:

1) At the beggining of preparation day, people got crazy donating everything and anything before we could set out request texts. I think for clan wars, people should set the accepted troops and level. Else it's just anarchy. Might be an interesting feature for regular castle too

2) Our war base is fixed at end of preparation. But I might not be available to switch precisely at that time. I'm not just talking about putting my TH inside here. I have to move my storages outside. This takes time and presence. A way to change just the war base without affecting our regular village would be nice. Lucky for me, my shield will cover preparation day so I can switch right away. But this means I cannot attack with my regular village.

Clan wars is suppose to be "only two attacks in two days", but my village is locked since the beginning of preparation day and I'm almost sure I won't attack until the war is finished (donating, preparing war attacks).

Looking forward to getting 3 stars on my 2 fights

[cech]

I like this idea!

If you spec troops then you still might get a 2* version when you need a 6*.

[bstaplin]

Not sure if i'm in the right area but I just had a question that I didn't see in the FAQs. What happens if both the leader and co-leader press start war at the same time?