Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

[MomoZB]

any possibility of... if a base is 3 stared and has attacks left to take,, gets penalized for not having a strong defensive base where they cant take there attacks?? would add a wrinkle in the mix...

What?
You don't see the issues with that? no

[MomoZB]

Then throw in the likelyhood of them adding a dump option on the next update then you'll have insta spam/dump ♥♥♥♥ to pad donation numbers through the roof.

ya.. that is what i said.....

[IcelandGold]

In my opion Clan Wars have ruend the game for farmers.(Includeing me.)Since im a farmer i cant 3 star bases. So i use all in drag raids. 500k 2 raids . And i hardly have time any more to play this game so Clan wars takes all the time .I was down to 10k elixir at one point. So i was forced to take a break from my clan.



Members of my clan have been rageing from the clan or even the game. If we dont get a fix for thad soon , allot of players are gona quit.


On and off buttun for if you wanna play in Clan wars maybe

Ice. Sorry for missspeeling if there is some

[magnor]

Thanks for clan wars supercell. It certainly has gone a long way toward energising our clan.

One thing that I've found though is that clan wars has increased the amount of times that we wish to send clan messages. Would it be possible to lower reduce the cool down time for clan messages or increase the size of clan messages? I don't feel that the only solution for this should be to increase the number of coleaders.

I know that many clans use third party apps as a solution to the clan message difficulties, but I don't know if supercell encourages this. If not, then a bit more freedom to sent more or larger clan messages would be really helpful.

[powerbottom]

Please let the players that attack and then leave the clan (or get kicked) NOT receive the bonus. Lately we have seen lots of new players in our clan that snipe high TH's immediately after clan wars has started. Some leave after both attacks and the others get kicked. I think they shouldn't be rewarded for their selfish behaviour.

This!!!!!!! We keep trying to fill a TH 8 or 7 slot and its all rejects that snipe waiting to be kicked and hop
to next clan. Its just gaming the clan wars setup. My kick button is worn out.

[MomoZB]

In my opion Clan Wars have ruend the game for farmers.(Includeing me.)Since im a farmer i cant 3 star bases. So i use all in drag raids. 500k 2 raids . And i hardly have time any more to play this game so Clan wars takes all the time .I was down to 10k elixir at one point. So i was forced to take a break from my clan.



Members of my clan have been rageing from the clan or even the game. If we dont get a fix for thad soon , allot of players are gona quit.


On and off buttun for if you wanna play in Clan wars maybe

Ice. Sorry for missspeeling if there is some

How come I am able to farm and three star bases? So you are blaming clan wars for being bad at the game?

For the kicking issue, I can see people using that to grief so sadly I like to keep it as is (Even though i trust my clan not to do this, when it comes to the general public, I don't.)

However I like to see something done about people leaving during prep phase and in the war. Some guy left because he had a football team for a name to join a clan with that name. Really do not understand men =.=

[magnor]

How come I am able to farm and three star bases? So you are blaming clan wars for being bad at the game?

For the kicking issue, I can see people using that to grief so sadly I like to keep it as is (Even though i trust my clan not to do this, when it comes to the general public, I don't.)

However I like to see something done about people leaving during prep phase and in the war. Some guy left because he had a football team for a name to join a clan with that name. Really do not understand men =.=

I agree with Momo about the kicking thing. Although snipers are annoying, and kicking them to cancel their loot bonus does seem like a suitable punishment, you also need to think about how this coukd be abused. Imagine being a high level player, asked to join a weaker clan to get a couple of three star wins off the opponents top players only to be kicked before the war ends by a clan leader who is a ♥♥♥♥er. That kind of situation would maybe not be as common as sniping but is just as bad if not worse. Unfortunately, this game, just like the world is full of selfish people who will use the system for their own gain.

[superclash99]

Although snipers are annoying, and kicking them to cancel their loot bonus does seem like a suitable punishment, you also need to think about how this coukd be abused. Imagine being a high level player, asked to join a weaker clan to get a couple of three star wins off the opponents top players only to be kicked before the war ends by a clan leader who is a ♥♥♥♥er. That kind of situation would maybe not be as common as sniping but is just as bad if not worse.

Your scenario does not make sense at all, since you WANT these high level players to continue getting 3 stars for your clan and to continue donating high level troops. Of course there is still the possibiliy, but that's no different than a rogue co leader/leader kicking people without any reason whether it's clan wars or not.

[TeilaTequila]

Clans are able to ♥♥♥♥♥ in war, they can begin an attack and if they are not winning be for the count down clock hits 30 second they can back out and attack someone else or change troops. This is completely unfair to the honest clans. We are.currently in war with IRAQI union leader is [RAgheed]. We have been seeing this our entire war, please fix this issue!!!

April 17th Update:

DE bug fixed by maintenance break!

Here are some ideas you guys have suggested that we would like to implement. Please note that we are not confirming the addition of any of these features, but they are currently under consideration. Ideas not on this list can be safely considered "ruled out" for the time being:

War Base Layout - saved layout separate from actual village
Dismiss War Base Clan Castle Troops
Numbers next to bases
Loot adjustments
Opt-in/Opt-out of wars
More War Info
Claiming Targets

April 11, update 2:

There is a new bug we've identified with Dark Elixir war bonus. The winning bonus is rounding down to the nearest 500 (400--> 0, 900 --> 500, 1065 --> 1000) and the losing bonus is rounding down to the nearest 100. This only affects DE.

There should be some rounding, but this was NOT intended. We will fix this in the next maintenance.

April 11th

• Phew - maintenance this morning solved the Scouting button problem, although you still may experience some slowness. The first round of wars is almost coming to an end! Wow... we made it =D
• Keep us posted about any issues, in particular if your entire clan is getting stuck in spectator mode. Make sure to check stickies before posting to see if your bug has already been reported. Cheers!
• Base sorting issues were related to the 0 second screen bug as well, so it should be fixed for your next war!
• Keep an eye out for issues as clans finish their current wars and matchmaking picks up again.

And finally, thank you for all your help guys! We couldn't have tracked down and patched up these bugs so quickly without your help! Let's see how this next round of matchmaking goes!

Ya'll are AMAZING

-Steve


April 10th, part 2

Maintenance coming to fix this issue: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...aration-Screen

Some clans are getting stuck in the Preparation Day, 0s screen.

We are actively investigating and some stuck clans should now be starting their War Day. We believe this will sort itself out, but we will keep you guys updated as we make progress.

April 10:

Your ideas, our thoughts:

1. Saved base layouts - Yes!!! We hope to add this in the next update, but as always, no promises!
2. Lock in or "save war base" button - We had this in a company playable but ruled it out due to the confusion it caused when we were testing it. We hope to add more distinction between your Village and your War Base in a future update, with the focus of resolving the current difficulty in preparing your war base
3. Showing Donation History - we will not add this. It is not part of the normal clan mode and we feel it is "too hardcore" to be able to track who is donating what. See the next note though
4. Dump Clan Castle Troops - Yes. It will happen, hopefully next update, but no promises yet.
5. Claim an opponent on prep day - Great idea, and we talked about adding it initially. We'll see how your guys' war days goes and what the feedback is then. I would mark this in the "maybe to likely" range of requests.

A note on how ranking is determined for clan war participants v. spectators
It is both intended and quite common that players with a higher TH are left out of a Clan War. The ranking is not based on TH level, it based on trophy count, and then the level of defenses. Check out the following explanation of how matchmaking should work:

1. The first x # of players go to matchmaking depending on their trophy amount and the position in the clan For example, in a 10v10 clan war, if one clan has 14 members, the 10 highest trophied members will be the ones to go to war.
2. Once a match is found, players are sorted on the map from strongest to weakest, in terms of defence power of their base, i.e., defense levels, hero levels, traps, etc.
3. We do not take TH levels into account. Instead, we only use overall strength of all defence elements in player’s village. For example, a TH8 with higher level defenses than a TH9 will be ranked higher than the TH9 in the war map.
4. XP has no bearing on the ranking of your war base on the war map

Updates on common problems and issues

1. Matchmaking and wait times: This should have improved in this morning's maintenance. We are closely monitoring the queue and will make any improvements in the future as needed.
2. "Stronger" players being left out of clan wars, placed in spectator mode: Please read our note above on rankings. This should explain why some players are placed in spectator mode despite having a higher TH. in addition, there may have been some server issues that caused some players to show up as less strong than they are. We are investigating any continued occurrences of this.
3. Unfair/unbalanced matchmaking: We will definitely improve matchmaking going forward to make sure clans are more evenly matched. We started off with the settings being pretty liberal, because we were worried that clans would not be able to find matches initially. This will be constantly improved with every maintenance/update.
4. Entire Clan Stuck in Spectator Mode: Should be fixed with this morning's maintenance, and avoided going forward by NOT PRESSING THE CANCEL button. Please post in our bugs subforum if your ENTIRE CLAN continues to experience this issue. And please note that this is a different issue than individual members being in spectator mode. Inevitably some members will be left out of the war.
5. Individuals showing lower War TH/Base levels than regular in village and in Spectator Mode: This is likely due to server overload issues but we will closely monitor this situation. They will have to sit out this first clan war, but we believe the issue will correct itself in the next war. Please keep us posted as we are closely monitoring this one.
6. Clan Chat Lag: Related to server overload. Should work fine now.
7. Donation Issues: Also related to server overload.
8. Completed CC6 appearing as CC5 in War Base: Also related to server overload, but we are monitoring closely.
9. War Log Button Partially Covers Clan Description Text on iPhone Fixed for the next update
10. Spell Factory Shows too many spells: Example: http://m.imgur.com/LriKAEM - Fortunately this is just a display issue. It counts the troops donate to war base as the amount of spells in the factory in the war base. Funky. Fixed for the next update.

April 9:

The most important note of all We are doing to a maintenance tomorrow morning to add more server capacity and fix some stuck clan states. We'll let you guys know when that will happen.

Note: DO NOT CANCEL MATCHMAKING!!! Matchmaking can take up to 60 minutes. By cancelling matchmaking you will go to the back of the queue, and finding an opponent will take even longer. Keep in mind that you can leave the matchmaking screen, and even log out of the game, while your match is found. You do not need to remain on the matchmaking screen in order to get matched up with another clan.

Another Note: Matchmaking is taking an average of 5-10 minutes ATM

Yet Another Note: Clan Chat issues, general lag, and donation issues are known. We believe they are mainly due to server load, and we are actively working to find a solution.

And Still Yet Another Note: Players have reported multiple instances of the "spectator mode" screen. This should resolve itself and let you return to matchmaking after some time. However, you can speed that process along by having all of your clan members log out of Clash (as in force quit). This should get you out of that screen and ready to go back into matchmaking instead.

--Original Text After The Break--

Hold on a second... do you have a question about how Clan Wars works? Go here to get for help: Clan Wars FAQs

This is the moment we've all been waiting for!!! Clan wars! The biggest update in Clash history is here, and we're looking forward to your feedback. We'll update this post with your suggestions as we go!

Please post ONLY feedback and suggestions on this thread. We truly appreciate reading thoughtful posts and ideas about how we can improve this epic new feature, so please refrain from posting spam on this thread. Let's give the floor to the most epic feedback ever

Found a bug with Clan Wars (we hope not)? Head here to report it: Clan Wars Bugs & Problems

[PrairieCrocus]

My idea to deal with that is to have elixir returns upon a win.
Win 100% elixir return, tie 80%, loss 50%. That also might help people

i like the idea of Elixer Return or at least being able to reuse troops.
Our 13 war just ended, we won, our top 6 bases were not even attacked. Waste.
PrairieCrocus GRASSQUATCH Clan