Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

[mauretto]

Quote everything! Great post TH3DAN!!!

Clan Wars has really changed this game in our clan. Many of us were starting to get bored with the endless progression, but clan wars has created SO MUCH more participation in the game. It is great. Here are the ideas that I saw listed and my opinion on them (we are 5-0 so far by the way):

War Base Layout - saved layout separate from actual village - Would be great!

Dismiss War Base Clan Castle Troops - A MUST HAVE FEATURE.

Numbers next to bases - This would really help us.

Loot adjustments - This is one of our biggest complaints. 2 days of war, planning, coordination, war castle donations, scouting, and I'm netting about 600k - 700k of each resource. That's about 3 - 4 farming raids for me. So I could make that in about 90 minutes normally. A winning loot bonus needs to be about 3x that number to really payoff for the amount of work IMHO.

Opt-in/Opt-out of wars - This would be wonderful. We boot every member that isnt going to participate and make them rejoin after we've matched.

More War Info - Not only would this be excellent, but more historical info would be nice.

Claiming Targets - We use a third party message board for this, but it would be a nice feature, especially if the Leader could "assign" bases to members.
---------------------------------------------------------

My Other Ideas:

Win/Loss record would be a great addition. Not sure why it shows only wins now. We only do one war per week, but are proud of our undefeated record and would love to show that off.

War Announcement Area - It would be nice if there was a section for war notes or assignments. Clan mail is very small and limited. Our clan chat turns over in less than 10 minutes when we are all on.

Internal War Ranking - Would be really awesome to see how valuable each member was to their clan in clan wars. Something like a running total of stars or stars x ranking of bases attacked. It would allow us to more easily track members that are improving or declining. We are constantly reassessing how strong each member is at attacking. This might help.

Clan War Leader board - This won't matter until the APM and Fluffybunny exploits are dealt with, but once the game is fair again, this would be really cool.

[rynoster]

I'm pretty sure this has been mentioned in the previous 187 pages somewhere...

I really think heroes need to be available for attacking, even if they are upgrading. Their levels are used for calculating our opposing clan right, so why can't I use them?

Being finished with all my defense and trap upgrades, I only have heroes and walls left, so right now both my heroes are constantly upgrading. Good luck taking on strong TH10's without heroes, at least for more than 1 star...

I am even willing to sacrifice hero levels for "war attacking" while they are upgrading, just give them to me please.

Other than that, Clan Wars are brilliant, things you have prioritised on the list will be great, and what TH3DAN added!

[G22RGE]

Clan Wars has really changed this game in our clan. Many of us were starting to get bored with the endless progression, but clan wars has created SO MUCH more participation in the game. It is great. Here are the ideas that I saw listed and my opinion on them (we are 5-0 so far by the way):

War Base Layout - saved layout separate from actual village - Would be great!

Dismiss War Base Clan Castle Troops - A MUST HAVE FEATURE.

Numbers next to bases - This would really help us.

Loot adjustments - This is one of our biggest complaints. 2 days of war, planning, coordination, war castle donations, scouting, and I'm netting about 600k - 700k of each resource. That's about 3 - 4 farming raids for me. So I could make that in about 90 minutes normally. A winning loot bonus needs to be about 3x that number to really payoff for the amount of work IMHO.

Opt-in/Opt-out of wars - This would be wonderful. We boot every member that isnt going to participate and make them rejoin after we've matched.

More War Info - Not only would this be excellent, but more historical info would be nice.

Claiming Targets - We use a third party message board for this, but it would be a nice feature, especially if the Leader could "assign" bases to members.
---------------------------------------------------------

My Other Ideas:

Win/Loss record would be a great addition. Not sure why it shows only wins now. We only do one war per week, but are proud of our undefeated record and would love to show that off.

War Announcement Area - It would be nice if there was a section for war notes or assignments. Clan mail is very small and limited. Our clan chat turns over in less than 10 minutes when we are all on.

Internal War Ranking - Would be really awesome to see how valuable each member was to their clan in clan wars. Something like a running total of stars or stars x ranking of bases attacked. It would allow us to more easily track members that are improving or declining. We are constantly reassessing how strong each member is at attacking. This might help.

Clan War Leader board - This won't matter until the APM and Fluffybunny exploits are dealt with, but once the game is fair again, this would be really cool.

I think all these ideas are GREAT

I personally think that Clan War donations SHOULD count towards your donation count. I have spent MILLIONS of elixir for my clan wars and have nothing to show for it, at least if my donation count went up that would be something

[MomoZB]

I think all these ideas are GREAT

I personally think that Clan War donations SHOULD count towards your donation count. I have spent MILLIONS of elixir for my clan wars and have nothing to show for it, at least if my donation count went up that would be something

You rather encourage people to spam giants for those counts blocking your good donations? I do not think it should count.... nor do I want it to. (Too easy to mass donate in a short time, unlike normal you have timer)

My idea to deal with that is to have elixir returns upon a win.
Win 100% elixir return, tie 80%, loss 50%

That also might help people with the view of not enough reward for the risk/time investment. (Of course it is outside the war bonus)

Plus having those count might cause social harm, I/E low level players have less opportunity to get those numbers up for achievement or whatever and people put high importance on those numbers...

I still think having that count does more harm then good. Also if you have the troop release thing, people will just donate giants and release them to pad numbers.

[G22RGE]

You rather encourage people to spam giants for those counts blocking your good donations? I do not think it should count.... nor do I want it to. (Too easy to mass donate in a short time, unlike normal you have timer)

My idea to deal with that is to have elixir returns upon a win.
Win 100% elixir return, tie 80%, loss 50%

That also might help people with the view of not enough reward for the risk/time investment. (Of course it is outside the war bonus)

Plus having those count might cause social harm, I/E low level players have less opportunity to get those numbers up for achievement or whatever and people put high importance on those numbers...

I still think having that count does more harm then good. Also if you have the troop release thing, people will just donate giants and release them to pad numbers.

I don't agree. People can spam giants regardless. Fortunately this doesn't happen in our clan as we have 45 good members. Choosing not to make it count towards donations because of people that try to ruin the game is unfair on those that do donate a lot as per requests.

[MomoZB]

I don't agree. People can spam giants regardless. Fortunately this doesn't happen in our clan as we have 45 good members. Choosing not to make it count towards donations because of people that try to ruin the game is unfair on those that do donate a lot as per requests.

I personally donate when they need help since I upgraded wizards to level five to do so. I do not care to show it in a number nor do I want it to due to possible ill feelings (I/E lower people can't donate because they do not have the level)

I am shocked you did not comment on my alternative and basically said "I want number" I see that as only caring about the self gratification more then helping a clan.

Also with the troop release, donating for numbers/ exp/ etc will be abused. Even if your clan doesn't it will be on the general scale, like donation trolls increasing because of a number. Just because your clan does not, does not mean the mass will do the same.

Again I think it will cause more harm then good and something I do not personally want/need.

[Coldfury]

I personally donate when they need help since I upgraded wizards to level five to do so. I do not care to show it in a number nor do I want it to due to possible ill feelings (I/E lower people can't donate because they do not have the level)

I am shocked you did not comment on my alternative and basically said "I want number" I see that as only caring about the self gratification more then helping a clan.

Also with the troop release, donating for numbers/ exp/ etc will be abused. Even if your clan doesn't it will be on the general scale, like donation trolls increasing because of a number. Just because your clan does not, does not mean the mass will do the same.

Again I think it will cause more harm then good and something I do not personally want/need.

Then throw in the likelyhood of them adding a dump option on the next update then you'll have insta spam/dump ♥♥♥♥ to pad donation numbers through the roof.

[topherthor]

any possibility of... if a base is 3 stared and has attacks left to take,, gets penalized for not having a strong defensive base where they cant take there attacks?? would add a wrinkle in the mix...

[PsYcHaYoGi]

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

[superclash99]

Please let the players that attack and then leave the clan (or get kicked) NOT receive the bonus. Lately we have seen lots of new players in our clan that snipe high TH's immediately after clan wars has started. Some leave after both attacks and the others get kicked. I think they shouldn't be rewarded for their selfish behaviour.