Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

[FreshKiidd]

I need my account back but I can't link it because my phone got stolen and I want to put it on my iPad

[WilliamWallace]

Thanks very much for the awesome update !!

An idea that is shared within my clan is that it would be awesome to have the opportunity for clan members to sign up for a war before the clan matching process and the prep day so that everybody in the clan could have the possibility to participate even low level people and players who are away for any reason don't participate to the ongoing war.

Thanks,

Arno

Just replying to second this idea, I was happy to see that many share the same issue as hopefully it will bring enough attention to the issue. Clan wars are amazing SC, however, the rigid participant issue is a real problem for the social health of our clans. We need some way to adjust for players on vacation or otherwise unavailable. Maybe the leader or co leaders invite members to particpate and the matchmaking doesnt start until X amount of people have accepted the invite or maybe the leaders are allowed to "swap" participants. So if a certain memeber is unavailable to participate, that person could be substituted with another clan member. Or maybe the leaders have the ability to proxy raid for those unused attacks. There are 100 ways this could be resolved, please consider taking another look at the participant selection piece. Other than that, terrific job with this update, this has revitalized the game for most of my clan!

Thanks
william wallace
leader of the Malevolent Force Clan

[Emsboy]

Need to be able to approve clan wars donations. No accountability so peoe just donate whatever. I'm waiting for a dragon but captain scratch n' sniff donates 5 lvl 2 archers! I don't know who did it in order to correct them. I can't dump my castle so why not a message in the inbox?
Emsboy is trying to give you a dragon. Do you accept?
Yes or no option buttons. Done. Easy.
Please

[Kboom]

I think that clan wars should have a better bonus because we spend too much donating the best troops to defende our clan mates bases.
And added to it, we use the best troops to atack too, for me, lvl 76 CV8, my war cost was 700k of elixir and i won only 470k of each at the end of war. And 700k of DE. No profit.

My suggestion is to double de bonus, or make possible steel more from the war base storages, not only 40k. Come on, 40k, it makes only 8 baloons.
Or just improve the elixir bonus to pay for troops and profit.

SuperCell, amazing war system, realy great job. I enjoy it alot.

[WylECoyote]

My biggest problem with clan wars is people that leave the clan right after someone declared war on us. Leaving an inactive base in our clan.

[tdoshea90]

clan wars is fun don't get me wrong but the strategy is just to beat up on the little guys. there should be a scaled reward system where if you can 3 star the best guy/girl in the other clan you get more than just 3 stars. while 3 starring the lowest member should have diminishing returns.

[Elle2]

More feedback....

1) Heroes being upgraded should be avail on offense not just defense. Putting aside that I never understood logic of why that troop - but no other - is unavailable generally when being upgraded, it seems completely illogical to factor Hero strength into the match-up strength pairing process and then not allow them to be used offensively if being upgraded. This penalizes clans where Heroes are not maxed (majority) and gives huge advantage to those who have maxed them. And before anyone says "oh clans with maxed heroes will mostly be paired with other clans with maxed heroes" this is likely only true if all of them are maxed, our very first war we got paired against a clan where the top 2 guys both had completely maxed heroes, and our best hero level was below 20.

2) Would be incredibly helpful in a future update to give us some type of flag or ability to indicate if you want to attack a specific base. The logistics in trying to coordinate attacking across a large clan, especially with members in different timezones, has been daunting and more work than desired.

3) I suggested it earlier, but twice can't hurt lol, please give us ability to dump war CC troops and redo on prep day. Well intentioned (and some ill intentioned) players mess up donations and it's really awful for the impacted players who either didn't get what they wanted or whose base is now at a disadvantage because we can't fix and someone gave them weak troops.

4) CW has been great for reinvigorating clan participating (this is awesome, thank you!) but during wars the clan chat, predictably, explodes and literally moves so fast last comment can fall off within just a few minutes. This is exposing issue with CC requests generally - can you look at adding ability for the req to remain viewable & able to be donated until filled? Whether that's through a different tab, or at bottom but never falls off chat....I also had issue where a req gets all the way down to bottom of chat, you can't pull it up sufficiently to donate troops in the bottom boxes (witches specifically).

[jdelrio]

Completed 2 Clan wars, and we won both narrowly. The activity, communication and rewards generated by Clan Wars are amazing.

This version of Clan pvp is above and beyond better than the implementations of other mobile games I have tried.


I went in with some apprehension as my other experiences with Clan PvP and pvp in general on mobile is watered down and on PC is more weighted to available opponents rather than legendary memories and rivalries. This is something I really miss from Vanilla Word of Warcraft. PvP felt like rivalries were made, you encounter the same enemies sometimes and you recognized each other, pulled the fighting around you and pushed to overcome the enemy that defeated you in the last match. Everyone knew you, sometimes you got singled out and still won. Great memories and moments every time. After a few updates, matchmaking for pvp was opened up to every server, and you lost that epic rivalry and recognition.

This feeling is not entirely addressed yet but the fact that you can view your clan war history of attacks and replays is amazing to bring back the sense of accomplishment and track progress and epic moments.

I assume that the higher you go the less clans will be available at the level range and you will meet the same clan more than once, and stories will be written. I would love to find a way that is equally fair but would still let you declare an enemy clan as your target for the clan war, or let you meet that clan for war more than once. A lot of the ideas that come to mind abandon all form of fairness, like declaring a clan to attack or even selecting the clan war target from your defense log(both clans would agree to the Clan war to start it). Personally I would be ok with the unfairness of the war, forcing either to improve and revenge clan war for greater rewards if you in. But not sure if everyone else agrees, it is only fun through a series of wars. The greatest battles occur from miss matched opponents no?

Maybe if you declared an enemy clan icon as your Rival Clan, you would have a chance at a smaller pool of targets and thus a fair but repeatable match up would occur. For example, White diagonal lightning versus yellow cross clans would all be pulling each other in clan wars if they declared their preferred clan rivalries. This would make all clans using the same clan icon as part of a collected nation, and the rivalries would be between the nations.

[HawkeyeP]

We just won our first clan war. It is great. We are concerned about matching with a clan that does not use the Latin Alphabet for names. It will be difficult to coordinate if we can not identify villages because it is a non Latin Alphabet. This will create a big disadvantage for us identifying villages on the war map, or even looking at a clan list. SuperCell can you please fix this problem by:


1. Put numbers before village names on the clan war map
2. Allow us to click on the clan name to get to the clan list.


Thank you.


HawkeyeP

[Flytrap]

The map feels small. Agreed it's the same size but feels smaller.
Adding competitive war would be ideal. Adding a top 200 war clan section in the future.
as of now my feed back is thumbs up and no real complaints. Its well thought out