Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

[BLUEMunchini]

great update but please let us be able to see what is in other players army camps

[SGClasher]

Hey SC, just another up suggestion! I think it will be good if u can include a summary page during clan wars to see who has the highest defensive wins, highest offensive stars obtained and highest war loot achieved etc.

Its quite fun to have that rather than going thru the base one by one on the war map to see who has won how many stars OR the clan war replays page and count it manually etc.

Cheers~

[Jalad]

[QUOTE=PrettyRBK;1737924]We've seen a change in the clan and while we've seen more activity , the changes we are seeing are not necessarily for the best.

Don't get me wrong, our clan is having fun with Clan Wars, but I have to agree with this thoughtful post with some great suggestions on ensuring that Clash of Clans continues to be fun and satisfying for a variety of players, including adults with busy lives who still want to have fun with their clan mates without the additional commitments / responsibility that go along with the Wars.

Great, great post, and I hope SuperCell reads this and takes it to heart.

[BIGJAW]

Clan Wars are pretty exciting and I've found them enjoyable. I think that the link to my below thread could possibly make a nice addition to them as well.

Clan War Coffers! - I know now that Clans donating troops/resources has been ruled out but I think I came up with a pretty innovative idea that could help make Clan Wars more interesting during Preparation Day when Scouting has been completed.

[GrimBeeper]

1st hats off to you, Clan Wars is a great feature, and although there are a few bugs they seemed to be getting ironed out really quickly.

Problems encountered:
(1) As a TH7 my war win bonus was something like 515k g/515k e/1150de but the max a th7 can store is 400k/400k/1000de a bit stingy that the clan castle can't hold the loot from 1 war, don't you think? I guess it doesn't help that TH6 and TH7 share the same max level clan castle.

(2) Chat lat, lag, when I came on Sunday 17:00 BST system was very laggy, some of our clan members were reporting that clan castle request were not appearing due to lag, which when you can only re-request 20m later is a little problematic.

Looking forward to many more enjoyable Clan Wars!

[GunderB]

great update but please let us be able to see what is in other players army camps

Press the blue star next to clan info on war map page.. then choose enemy clan, and press the base u like to see... troops shows up there like in a normal search.

[AngryAngels]

I cannot say you are wrong.. if the loot is tripled for 3 stars, there is another problem. A high level player will 3 star low level enemy to triple the loot. Well...although you can get 6 stars, but which enemy your low level player can attack? You may say if the guy doesnt follow the rule, you'll kick him.. By that time, it causes jealousy already; or even worst, your clan may lose the war.

To me, the current system is good enough

No no, you get me wrong, if a High level player attacl a low level enemy he will only do a small loot .. ! Low level village only got poor loot. The mechanics stay the same as actually, a player that do 1 star got one third of the loot for this village .. 2/3 for 2 stars and so on.

High level village : 350k of loot => Do 1 star you get 116k, 2 stars and get 132k, 3 stars and get 350k
Low level village : 100k of loot => Do 1 star you Get 33k, 2 stars and get 66k, 3 stars and get 100k

Which so called "High" level player will attack a low level village ...to get a poor loot ?

[lsrith]

No no, you get me wrong, if a High level player attacl a low level enemy he will only do a low score .. ! Low level village only got poor loot. The mechanics stay the same as actually, a player that do 1 star got on third of the loot for this village .. 2/3 for 2 stars and so on.

Ahh...but then the loot must be changed as well... bcuz the current loot bonus, 3 times the lower loot is more than 1 time the higher loot..

Anyway, I'm happy with the current system; and hopefully, SC may come up with a better solution as the update continues

[AngryAngels]

A win bonus is a win bonus, you win with one star, you get the win bonus. Not different to the 'normal' game...never hear anyone complaining there.
ad1) I've got this thing with envy...I don't see how you're recieving less only because someone else is getting the same or even more, they're not taking it from you, are they?
ad2) If a higher ranked player 'takes away' the chance for a lower ranked player to make two stars by three starring 'their' base...it can tip the scales and ruin your whole clans win, that is what I meant. On the other hand, weaker members will help towards an easier match-up and so have already contributed before even the first clash commences. In a clan win, they deserve to get the same, they'll have played their part (btw inactive members get zero).
PS: we're 40, I'm the strongest, I'm virtually financing our war.
I am in for then fun, and having tons of it, I think you are too.
Have Fun!
TS

1 - You don't get it ... no problemo
2 - No player with a "high level" will attack a low level village with a poor loot .. !! Players will attack villages where they can do 3 stars AND with the best loot possible. No problem there... your math and logic are strange ...

[F3rnando84]

What happens if war clan loot is left in your clan castle and you get raided? Do you lose a percentage of that loot? Or is it left alone? Thanks