Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

[MoriartyLives]

Clan wars have re-engaged my entire clan in the game and have been wonderfully fun.

i would like to see a leader or co-leader have the ability to disqualify some number (maybe up to 3 or 5?) of their own clan mates from participating in an upcoming war. We, for example, have two clan mates who are vacationing this week and who will not have connectivity. We'd like to be able to force spectator status on them, because clearly we don't want to kick them out of the clan just because they are out of town.

it might be easier if the war maps' bases were numbered from top to bottom. To refer in the chat to 23 instead of some weird base name would be a lot easier for the clanmates.

i think matchmaking was very, very well done. Implementation in general was excellent and I love the large number of stored replays!

[Squian2]

My base went all black for a while till I reset it. Is anybody else seeing this?

I think this is just a rare bug. Nothing to do with CW

[Seb0815]

Hi all,

hope you're all fine and enjoying Clanwars as much as our Clan (Hamburger Horde) does.
I just wanted to post a feedback after our first two wars:

Matchmaking:
Our first match fitted very well. It was close in the beginning. At the end we had some really nice attacks which gave us an advantage we could defend until the end.
Our second match is disappointingly totally out of bounds. Our enemy is way too strong. It is a 30vs30 match and about 10 enemies are as strong (and some even stronger) then our top 2. Our 10 weakest players are all weaker than all of them.
This must be adjusted a bit. Longer waiting times are no problem for everyone when the match is fair imho.

Heroes/Spellfactory:
Upgrading them is a total disadvantage. Anything must be done for that. Maybe producing spells for clanwar in the saved clanbase and always active heroes with the pre-upgrading level?

Social effect:
Our clan is more active than ever before. There's much more communication - love that!

Hope this feedback helps a bit
Clash on!

[Tomnevers]

I am a casual level 110 player.

I prefer farming.

I don't understand how Clan Wars truly works. I wasted hundreds of thousands of elixir on a massive army, then I tried to scout some bases but it wouldn't let me. So I attacked and turns out the base was ridiculously hard and I lost everything. I'm a new dad and I have a job. I don't have the time nor inclination to care about Clan Wars.

I have previously purchased gems to advance myself in this game. I won't be buying any more gems.

There needs to be a better payoff for attacking. I can't build 2 armies of 20 dragons and then donate huge expensive troops to my clan for such a measly payout.

My clan is splitting up and basically that's been the only reason I log in to donate and accept troops.

[CanadianLegend]

i would like to see a leader or co-leader have the ability to disqualify some number (maybe up to 3 or 5?) of their own clan mates from participating in an upcoming war.

Agreed. I suggested something very similar before where leaders can select how many people of their clan will participate in the war so that the matchup could be done accordingly. If only 10 people in a 30 man clan clan want to participate it should be possible to have a 10 vs 10 war against some other clan. This would need to be done in an initial phase before the opponent is picked to ensure that there can be an even matchup.

It would be good if the clan leader could nominate the participants or if they could be chosen automatically based on some configurable parameters, e.g. most active, most trophies, etc.

[bhima]

Anyone agree? Haha

Horrible idea. A large percentage of clash players have proven themselves insufficiently mature to handle the opportunity to "chat" with a clan they are at war with. I think most of us can imagine what a train wreck allowing inter-clan chat during war would be...

[Bega87]

I love this clan wars supercell.
First I lve that you finally found a solution for make this game a community game and not a solitary game.
Most of the time especially for expert farmers things like clan castle was not use now is so important the choice and talk with your "clash friends" about everything.
Of course the clan wars will be better in a couple of weeks like every single update you do.
For the thing about the heros, I agree that if you upgrade then should be like every single building.
Love the loots bonus cause give a strong help for try to win the battle.
Just love the clan wars guys.
One thing I ask if is possible to have a button for save the war village.
Like I said before I'm an extremely crazy farmer and I love to put my town hall outside. If I'm out for work I would love to save my town for work when I want cause then I put again out my town hall. Anybody agree with it?
But again thank you supercell for make more interesting this game. Hope this will not start a crazy trolling thing of people ask for start a war and leave the clan (can happen people still stupid unfortunately).
Thanks again to everyone and good game all of you!!

[PrettyRBK]

We've seen a change in the clan and while we've seen more activity , the changes we are seeing are not necessarily for the best.

Our clan is Adults only. We have a good mix of people but we've had 3 good players leave in the last 24hrs.
All three active people in chat, donations and regular raiding.

The feedback we are getting:

Going to war too soon:
Right after a war, we got challenged within hours. Many wanted a cool down or a choice to accept the challenge. There is none, and we lost one player because of it. He didn't want to do it again within a day of the last war. From what we know he's gone to a small clan below 10 so he won't be required to War. He's was an original member.

Wanting to Opt out:
Members want an Individual Member Opt-Out option, a quick poll indicates that it is the highest desired feature next to a saved battle war base layout. We have 2 groups in the clan, some social players and some love the competitive players.

A) Social/Farmers aren't liking that they have to change their bases and learn new battle tactics to raiding big guys (often with poor results), they can't opt out. They are either resenting it or talking about leaving.
B) The competitive players are struggling with inactive and inactive raiders on battle day.

We are adults who often spent a good amount of money for gems, but we have jobs, kids, homes and outside lives that might prevent us from raiding that day. We lost a terrific player who is social on chat, donates really good troops - but has a best friend with cancer and felt she couldn't guarantee being around on battle day - she left due to guilt.

Bad Donations to War Castle Suck:
i know that seeing donation details aren't in the works (saw your post) but the fact that unlike regular donations where you can see real time who's donating... Our having to investigate bases like CSIs to figure out who did it is getting a old. Lol. The troop dump troops option will help us with the problem of people donating troops they shouldn't. I'd say our clan would really like that option as a compromise, please implement it.

The basic message is we like our clan, it's a good one and we have built good relationships out of it. We hate to see good people go and are looking to help prevent it.

[SGClasher]

Wow too many feedbacks here to read in detail on every page! Wish there is a summary of all the clan war improvement ideas on one thread

Overall i think the clan war is a great addition to the game. It kinda of revived my clan who were getting bored of trophy pushing.

But there are really many areas and features which countless formers have suggested to improve on to make clan war a better success.

So hope SC is really gathering all feedbacks here! Looking forward to a better clan war!

Cheers~

[xOMERTAx]

Myself and another member have experienced the game crashing mid attack as soon as the clan castle troops come out.

Usernames are Colt and WICK clan is Infa Kings

Not sure if it's a bug or what but it definitely happened. Plus our troops didn't defend themselves.