Clan Wars FEEDBACK here

[Harridan]

the clan war update is quite amazing. but some problems
device: iPhone 4S

iOS version: 7.1

problem: full loading bar, but never enters game properly.(only when using wifi; enters game smoothly using 3G or GPRS)

more details:
1.meet problem with both school wifi and home wifi(using my pc as a hotspot)
2.tried every troubleshooting steps in the forum listed(except factory reset); not working
3.successful in connecting to http://portquiz.net:9339/ for both wifi
4.both wifi works fine before the clan war updates, after the update cannot enter through wifi
5.other activities works fine on the device through wifi (open webpage, using apps, watching online video, downloading apps)

I'm quite sure it's due to the newest update and hope supercell could fix it quickly, thx a lot.

Same here but with Android. I can't connect with mobile network. With wifi I'm able to log in, but I play with the mobile
And it's not about the account because it doesn't start the tutorial after reinstaling.

[acealive]

Hello Supercell-Staff,

now for the feedback from M-Power clan, since this war is over now.

We love the clanwars, it's tons of fun and much more interesting than farming or pushing.
Don't get me wrong, we also loved the game before, but now it's even better.

We won the first war with almost 40 stars lead. The matchmaking was a little in our favour, but also the other clan failed on quite some of their attacks.

The design of the maps and war log ist great, awesome to be able to see all replays, two days for a war seems just fine.

We are in the middle of our secon war's prep day now.
The new matchup is ok as well, this time the other clan looks a bit stronger on the top end on first impression but I haven't scouted all their bases yet.

Unfortunately, we had a member leave the clan who will now be missed as an attacker in the war very much.
He was a newcomer from yesterday which brings me back to my suggestion of my first post in this thread, that people should have to be in a clan for like a week before they can fight a war, to not have those jumpers hurt the clan.

Another suggestion would be that the text one writes in clanwar clancastle for donations is saved, like it is in the normal clancastle.
So that you can write down your standard donation request for clanwars once and it is there in the next clanwar as well, until you change it.

all, we love the clanwars very much and most likely will be having them 24/7

[xorock]

1. ability to set clan war layout anytime. many times. permanently until change made.
Still dont understand what supersteve said about saving clanwar layout causing confusion. it will make life easier than swithcing the base at the end of preparation day since i can not online all the time.
2. Leader has ability to rearrange clan members who in or out of clan war before star searching match. it help to avoid problem with clan members whois not active or away temporary.

[lsrith]

Same here but with Android. I can't connect with mobile network. With wifi I'm able to log in, but I play with the mobile
And it's not about the account because it doesn't start the tutorial after reinstaling.

I feel SC tries to avoid this loading screen freeze issue. None of the SC mods replies to the problem so far; they dont even says they're looking to it...

[delusions]

This is a small thing, however donations to clan war base doesn't increase the troop donation achievement. Maybe create a "A clan in need" achiement to mirror the "a friend in need" one would be awesome

[Mynameshunter]

Had to hop on here and say: Awesome Work!

Way to fix the bugs in a timely manner. There were a couple annoying ones, no real show stoppers, and I'm impressed with just how quickly you guys knocked them out.

I'm sure there are about a million different feature requests floating around (heroes in CW while UGing, saving layouts, etc.) and I'm excited to see CW get even better/slicker, but I just want to say, the way I and my clan feel right now is:

You Nailed It! we're having a TON of fun with this.

[Jeezz]

All players who participate should share in the loot regardless of stars. I blew it. But, I helped my clan and participated. If players do _nothing_ then sure award them nothing. But, wow what a disappointment.

Totally agrea..

This is a clan effort, so rewards shouldn't be individual but to all players that take part.

It is actually punishing those players that dare try to attack the hardest villages, since they have the largest chance to fail.. While awarding those taking the easy villages instead.

[CanadianLegend]

But even more important is the ability to save at LEAST one layout. Going back and forth from our farming bases takes way too much time and patiente.

I was worried about this myself and would welcome the ability to save a different map for CW myself, but I think in reality this is a non-issue for the following reason: Sniping a TH only gives you 1 star which is next to meaningless in CW. It's really all about getting 3 stars so if you can lure some snipers and limit your opponent to 1 star simply by leaving your TH exposed then I think that's a win.

[mhscherer]

How to make your clan not participate in battles? Is there a way or you have no option?

[Lightsabre]

We finally started our clan wars this weekend, and just wanted to provide some positive feedback as there has been a lot of negativity with all the initial bugs. We got great clan matches and its going to be a fair fight. I really look forward to the update when we can select which of our war base clan troops we can dump, as someone gave wrong troops, but overall brilliant addition, so glad to see that clan wars is here to stay and its really the clash of the clans!